Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Login

Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using
 

Email

 

Rudaw

Iraq

Is the Mosul operation being launched prematurely?

By Paul Iddon 5/10/2016
Iraqi troops have been preparing for the Mosul offensive for months. AP file photo.
Iraqi troops have been preparing for the Mosul offensive for months. AP file photo.
ERBIL, Kurdistan Region – Although it fell to Islamic State (ISIS) militants more than two years ago, analysts fear that the long-anticipated campaign to recapture Mosul could be carried out prematurely, without a clear plan for post-battle governance.

“I think they are rushing into it,” warned Dylan O’Driscoll, a senior fellow at the Erbil-based Middle East Research Institute (MERI). “I think it’s political; basically you had (Iraqi Prime Minister Haider) Abadi promise to finish the operation before the end of the year,” he told Rudaw English.

“If you look at his political position this is something he will have to deliver on for his short-term political future," O'Driscoll said.

"In the US, liberating Mosul before January will be an almost swansong end to Obama’s administration and will also lay the groundwork for the next leader,” O’Driscoll said.

“Delivering this future will be seen as a benefit," he added. "But what’s going to happen in four years?  These are the questions we need to ask. Again, it’s political short-sightedness which we have witnessed in Iraq over and over again," he warned.

Ramzy Mardini, a nonresident fellow at the Atlantic Council, argued that, "militarily speaking, the Mosul operation is doable," warning like O’Driscoll that the problems lie in post-liberation governance.

"It’s where plans are regarding the governance and political dimension of the equation that make the liberation of Mosul premature," he told Rudaw English.

Mardini worries that if the main force routing ISIS from Mosul isn't strong enough to stabilize the post-battle order, then a dangerous power vacuum could be created, which several militias will seek to fill, much to the detriment of the region's stability and security.

"Liberation without a singular chain of command will contribute to a post-conflict environment that lacks control and executive administration," Mardini said. "Without a force ready to monopolize violence the day after, the 'militiaization' of post-ISIS Mosul becomes a real possibility."

Mardini also worries about the lack of any "central arbiter to manage the relationship, behavior and expectation of the various forces that will control and govern Mosul." That, he fears, will ultimately result in the Shiite-majority Popular Mobilization Forces (PMF) -- or Hashd al-Shaabi -- militia gaining a foothold in Nineveh.  

"This should concern political leaders in Erbil," he warned. "The Kurds will face a new reality of having Shiite militias on their border, with some even wishing to push the Peshmerga out from territories they gained control of since 2014."

The prospect of a far from ideal post-ISIS situation on Kurdistan's borders, Mardini added, may also undermine any outcome of negotiations with Baghdad concerning independence.

"The central government’s authority in the negotiation process will be undercut, given its increasing lack of control over the use of violence," Mardini said. "Without authority, you are not in a position to make enforceable concessions."

For these reasons Mardini concludes that the Mosul operation should not be launched until Baghdad has the means to both capture the city militarily, which he believes they are ready for, and then stabilize it and implement some form of governance thereafter, which he doesn't believe they are presently capable of doing.

Consequently, he fears Mosul and the wider Nineveh region will continue to be a source of instability, which will threaten the region if this operation is launched in the coming weeks, as anticipated, based on comments by leaders and military authorities in the region and beyond.  

Michael Knights, the Lafer Fellow at the Washington Institute and Iraq expert, argues that there is "never going to be an optimal time to liberate Mosul."

Knights, like Mardini, fears that the Hashd al-Shaabi could get a foothold on the Kurdistan Region's border. However, unlike Mardini, he believes this could happen if the Iraqis delay the launch of this operation.

"If we wait to build more forces then we risk the Shiite militias pushing their way back into the offensive, which would be a disaster," Knights reasoned.

"If we wait for a grand bargain on territories with the Kurds then we could be waiting for years," he added.

"The momentum is there now and ISIL (ISIS) is collapsing. ISF (Iraqi Security Forces) and Shiite PMF will advance, whatever the coalition does or doesn't do," Knights concluded.

Comments

 
duroi | 5/10/2016
dīvide et īmpera (divide and rule) the maxim used from Julius Caesar to Napoleon to modern day politicians in all corners of the world. With ISIS in Iraq and in Syria, the Iraqis and Syrians are divided and this has created an opportunity for Kurds. Let them remain divided and instead "act on the referendum" to remove the divisions among Kurds and Kurdish parties that others have created in order to divide and rule Kurds. Act now and make excuses later (Fac et excusa) is another maxim by my academic forefather Emanuel Kant.
dutchnational | 18/10/2016
To misquote another Roman. Ad ceteram, Anatolia (Turkey) delenda est. By the way, Turkey should be destroyed. (As it is now)
American | 19/10/2016
It may be premature if the Kurds don't have military hospitals. These can save thousands of Peshmerga young men from dying preventable deaths.
Leon Ash | 14/11/2016
Kurdish military hospitals are a must, and I don't understand those who downed the post.
6761 Views

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

Yassir Fekaiki
Yassir Fekaiki | 10/16/2018 10:13:15 PM
Thank Bafel talabany and his henchmen, how come no kurd is holding the traitors accountable?
mark bishop | 10/18/2018 7:27:40 AM
We have great respect for Masoud Barzani. But his statement on October 16 only gives us half of a message. He says that the events leading up to...
Kurds want justice a year after Iraq's takeover of Kirkuk
| 16/10/2018 | (6)
Jiyan | 10/18/2018 7:15:41 AM
Bahman Ghoubadi's films have had no good use for Kurds, they only belittle Kurds as premimitive and useless. I hope other filmmakers will be more...
Kurdish filmmakers need to be better storytellers: Amir Gholami
| 20 hours ago | (1)
haluk | 10/17/2018 4:53:04 AM
Around 1200 BC, different factors such as climate change, volcano eruptions, earthquakes and large scale migrations (the mysterious "sea people")...
Orxan | 10/17/2018 11:44:08 PM
This Is Assyria and mesopotamian history Kurds are Iranians, they do not belong in this land
Ancient lost city of Mardaman slowly gives up its secrets
| 16/10/2018 | (3)
Ian Birmingham | 10/17/2018 7:41:56 PM
As clearly demonstrated on 25 September 2017, 93% of KRG voters favor independence from Iraq. PUK lied to and betrayed KRG on 16 October 2017,...
Burkan | 10/17/2018 9:57:41 PM
Where’s the sources for the conversations and meetongs that took place? Any third party or just what youclaim?
The fight for Iraq’s presidency: What happened on October 2?
| yesterday at 01:45 | (7)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

Pipe connects Duhok with Mosul Dam to help dwindling supply in Kurdistan 6 hours ago |

Pipe connects Duhok with Mosul Dam to help dwindling supply in Kurdistan

It is clean water and we are connecting it to more
Rights group: Insulting the Turkish president shouldn't be a crime 7 hours ago |

Rights group: Insulting the Turkish president shouldn't be a crime

Four graduates of the Middle East Technical more
1.125 seconds