Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Login

Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using
 

Email

 

Rudaw

Analysis

What role does Turkey seek to play in Mosul operation?

By Paul Iddon 9/10/2016
Turkish tanks at the Turkey-Iraq border. Photo: Burhan Ozbilici/AP
Turkish tanks at the Turkey-Iraq border. Photo: Burhan Ozbilici/AP
Turkey is adamant that it will play a role in the liberation of Mosul from Islamic State (ISIS) militants as tensions with Iraq over its deployment of troops in Bashiqa intensify. But Turkey is likely looking to play a longer-term political role in the region than becoming deeply involved in the military operation, analysts say.

"We will play a role in the Mosul operation and no one can prevent us from participating," Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan vowed earlier this month, amid widespread anticipation that the Mosul operation is about to begin.

The Turkish base in the town of Bashiqa in northern Iraq near Mosul is first and foremost a military training camp for the former Nineveh Governor Atheel al-Nujaifi's Sunni Hashd al-Watani militia. Nujaifi told Rudaw that the Turkish troops will only play a supporting role in the Mosul operation and, "if there is a need, they will offer support to Peshmerga, Hashd al-Watani and even the Iraqi Army."

"We will need Turkey soon, particularly for evacuation and aid operations. And I expect there will be collaboration from all the countries on this," he added.

Turkey recently began treating at least 62 Kurdish Peshmerga soldiers who have been wounded fighting ISIS. 

Nujaifi believes the current tensions between Ankara and Baghdad will be solved soon through "political and diplomatic means."   

Michael Knights, a Lafer Fellow at the Washington Institute for Near East Studies, previously told Rudaw English that he doubts Turkey will play much of a direct role in the operation given the small size of their contingent in Bashiqa. Instead, Knights envisions Turkey playing, at best, a supporting role to the Hashd al-Watani. 

"The deployment in Bashiqa is a mid-sized training mission," he explained. "The artillery and tanks are really there for self-protection. But they might fire in support of Nujaifi's forces advancing on Mosul."     

Aaron Stein, a Resident Senior Fellow at the Atlantic Council's Rafik Hariri Center, also doubts that Turkey will play any direct military role in the operation and doubts that the Hashd al-Watani will take part in the battle for Mosul. 

"If and when the coalition does take the city, it is unclear if Turkey or the Hashd al-Watani will help to ‘hold’ the city," Stein told Rudaw English. "The Nujaifi-Baghdad relationship, and therefore the Turkey-Baghdad relationship, remains difficult and it is hard to foresee a scenario whereby Iraqi Prime Minister Haider al-Abadi will openly welcome a Nujaifi/Turkish role."

Turkey wants to play a role in shaping the future of Mosul and the wider Nineveh region. Erdogan's recent remarks, Stein said, indicate he wants local Arabs, such as Nujaifi's militia, to liberate Mosul, which is "a reference to his government's discomfort with the [Shiite] Hashd al-Shaabi, and any role they may or may not play in the Mosul campaign." 

"The Turkish government has made similar comments about Turkmen in Tel Afar, a reference to the PKK [Kurdistan Workers' Party]/YPG [Syrian Kurdish People's Protection Units] in Shingal," Stein added. "There is a possibility that the Hashd al-Watani will try to play a role in post-ISIS Mosul, or that Turkey will try and funnel money through Sunni Iraqi Turkmens in Tel Afar – something that Ankara was already doing before the rise of Islamic State."

"As of now, it doesn’t look like Turkey will have a direct role in the Mosul fight, but Turkey will remain a serious outside player in the city regardless," he concluded.

Joel Wing, an Iraq analyst and author of the Musings on Iraq blog, believes that possible Hashd al-Watani participation in the Mosul battle "will be for political reasons only." 

"They are a small force and would have no real impact on the actual battle," Wing told Rudaw English. "I'm not sure what Turkey will do." 

"The recent complaints from Baghdad about their presence may be enough to stop Ankara from doing much other than supporting Nujaifi, but you can't tell in the end," he added. "Mosul is as much a political conflict as a military one and every force in Iraq wants a piece of the pie to claim that they helped defeat the Islamic State. Just as importantly, they want to make claims to Mosul and Nineveh as well."

Comments

 
Data pager
Previous
12
Page size:
PageSizeComboBox
select
No Interfering Turkey! | 9/10/2016
No one asks for Turkeys participation, but it still wants to participate. Obviously Turkey wants to weaken Iraq by increasing its influence and trying to control the Mosul area. They cannot hide their intentions any longer.
Germans Hate Turks | 9/10/2016
What role for Turkey ? It will be that in Rojava.As soon as Mosul is liberated by Kurds and Iraqis Mr.Biden will call all Iraqis to return immediately to Baghdad and Kurds to Arbil and Turkey will enter triumpmhantly into Mosul and beyond : perhaps till Baghdad.Of course,Biden will solemnly issue that statement from Ankara where he will be for the occasion.America bows to the tyrant Erdogan .
Ben | 10/10/2016
The Iraqi government needs to keep up the pressure because Turkey doesn't have the stomach for a war with Iraq. They'll have the entire Arab world down on their neck and that's VERY bad for business!. Sorry Turkey Iran will win this round as well, they'll force all the Turkish bases out of Iraqi/Kurdish territory not just the one in Bashiqa.
vlog | 10/10/2016
It seems neither the experts nor the turks understand the gravity of the situation, I really don't think the Iraqis are bluffing about attacking the turkish base this time. Even if they don't attack the base themselves they can't and won't stop the shia militias from doing it. The US is 100% behind the Iraqi government, in fact they trying to persuade the kurds to turn against the turks as well, and already a large portion of the kurdish political establishment have come out against the turkish bases
Fuat | 10/10/2016
Turks want their homeland back from pre-WWI. They have all the right to expand. This right is given to them by Israel example by taking their homeland back from 4000 years ago.Arabs are incapable of managing their lands. They are incapable of uniting.Turkey will bring the peace and security into the region. Besides Russia will back Turkey even if West doesn't.The West will be the spectator because they will have no guts to interfere. Sorry guys I know this is not a popular idea but it is the fact.

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

Guest | 10/16/2018 5:19:46 PM
I agree with you Mr. Romano. Except, I don't think Turkey is an emerging threat, it's conversion to a totalitarian style government along with its...
Masque du Furet | 10/17/2018 4:54:08 AM
Well, as hostage diplomacy seems efficient, it is time for Tutkey to find new hostages (mormons, popists might be interesting). OTOH, if US do not...
Time for US to reassess Turkey's support for extremists
| yesterday at 10:22 | (5)
Baban | 10/16/2018 8:47:00 PM
A cruical milestone in the history of our homelands, a beautiful insight in the work of uncovering important artifacts that i hope will take shape...
haluk | 10/17/2018 4:53:04 AM
Around 1200 BC, different factors such as climate change, volcano eruptions, earthquakes and large scale migrations (the mysterious "sea people")...
Ancient lost city of Mardaman slowly gives up its secrets
| yesterday at 07:13 | (2)
Kdp sold kirkuk | 10/17/2018 3:28:43 AM
Both sold kirkuk. Kurdistan will never be indipendent with kdp puk. Why kdp join iraq govermentare they not against iraq or are they just liars?
Shawn | 10/17/2018 4:21:31 AM
This PUK guy is blaming KDP for the mess the KirKuk in!!! Are you kidding. This PUK dude needs to get his head out his rear and shut the F****k...
KDP, PUK in row over Kirkuk governorship
| yesterday at 08:05 | (8)
Y. A. | 10/16/2018 11:28:54 PM
May Allah Khode help The Kurds and make their enemies taste occupation so they would feel it as they have made the Kurds feel it
Kawan | 10/17/2018 1:44:33 AM
A dark day in kurdish history
The fall of Kirkuk: Flashbacks of October 16
| yesterday at 12:00 | (10)
0.25 seconds