Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Login

Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using
 

Email

 

Rudaw

Analysis

How will the Turkish-Russian rapprochement affect Syria’s Kurds?

By Paul Iddon 3/7/2016
Russian Prime Minister Vladimir Putin (left) and Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan (right). AP file photo.
Russian Prime Minister Vladimir Putin (left) and Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan (right). AP file photo.


Russia and Turkey have recently decided to take steps to patch-up ties after the tense seven-month long fallout following Ankara’s shooting down of one of the Kremlin’s warplanes over the Turkish-Syrian border last November. How the rapprochement between these two powers will affect the Syrian Kurds, if at all, has yet to be seen.  

The Russian and Turkish governments have said they both agreed on the need to cooperate against terrorism in the region. Turkish officials are quick to remind everyone that they perceive both the Syrian Kurdish Democratic Union Party (PYD) and Peoples Protection Units (YPG) fighters to be entities equally as bad as, if not worse than, Islamic State (ISIS).

In a 36-minute meeting between Turkish Foreign Minister Mevlut Cavusoglu and his Russian counterpart Sergei Lavrov last Friday Cavusoglu acknowledged that both countries still maintain different outlooks but can nevertheless talk about any issue, either “positive or negative”, since relations are returning to the cordial state they were in before last November.

Clearly Turkey and Russia still have some disagreements on the definition of terrorism. Turkey frequently insists that the PYD and YPG are inextricably linked to the Kurdistan Workers Party (PKK) – a group it is currently fighting in its own southeast and bombing in the Kurdistan Region. Russia, on the other hand, hasn’t designated the PKK a terrorist organization and even allowed the PYD to open an office in Moscow.

After aforementioned talks with Lavrov on Friday Cavusoglu claimed that, regarding the PYD office in Moscow, “We do not have sufficient information on this subject. We do not have sufficient information on Russia’s stance on the YPG and PYD in Syria.”

Russia insisted that the PYD be allowed to participate in the Syria peace talks at Geneva, however they were denied entry. The YPG, as part of the large Arab and Kurdish Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF) umbrella group, has been the most successful force on the ground in Syria in the fight against ISIS. They have consequently received support and training from the US-led coalition, however the coalition is hesitant about also supporting that groups political aspirations.

Since the Syrian war began five years ago Turkey has been demanding that Syrian President Bashar al-Assad step down and supported armed groups fighting him, many of whom are Islamist militants. The Turks became so alarmed by how fast the PYD Kurds were able to consolidate their self-rule over Syria’s Kurdish territories that they even seemed to perceive an ISIS victory over them, during the siege of Kobani, to be more desirable than Kurdish self-rule under the PYD along their southern border.

Turkey has opposed the Kurds joining together all of their cantons since they don’t want Syria’s northern border to be completely dominated by the YPG. Last February the Turkish military fired artillery over the border at the YPG to prevent them from advancing against Islamist militants in Syria’s northwest.

While the Russians have expressed sympathy for Syria’s Kurds and their battlefield victories against ISIS it has deployed its military forces to Syria primarily in order to shore-up the Syrian regime. And the Syrian regime, along with the various groups that make up a loosely defined “opposition”, are viscerally opposed to Syrian Kurdish autonomy and the “federal democratic system” they declared in March.

While Damascus is unlikely to be able re-conquer all of Syria if it ever does get a chance it will likely seek to reign in the Kurds, control their region and deny them any genuine self-determination.  

Turkey would likely acquiesce to Damascus moving in to crush Syria Kurdistan’s autonomous entity, and would likely be content with the prospect of the regime and the PYD Kurds fighting and weakening each other while hoping – in the same vein Henry Kissinger once lamented that, “It’s a pity they can’t both lose” about the Iran-Iraq War – they somehow manage to destroy each other.  

Both Moscow and Ankara need to cooperate and reach some compromises on their diverging goals in Syria. Russia, like the US, would welcome Turkey closing off its northwestern border to cut off armed Islamists like Jabhat al-Nusra from having any access to the outside world.

Turkey in turn would like to see Russian discontinue its limited support of the Syrian Kurds and ensure Assad adheres to any negotiated transition process which might come about in the future that would see him stepping down as president. Ankara may well calculate that any new Syrian government made-up of both elements of the current regime and opposition are likely going to oppose Syrian Kurdish self-determination and possibly even seek to have it forcibly dismantled.

Ankara would rejoice at such outcomes and would likely be willing to make some concessions and some compromises, in negotiations with Moscow over the future of that war-torn country.

Paul Iddon is a Rudaw reporter based in Erbil, Kurdistan Region.

Comments

 
Data pager
Previous
123
Page size:
PageSizeComboBox
select
FAUthman | 3/7/2016
Don't count on a Kissengerian abandonment of Kurds in Syria (and Iraq) under Hillary administration! In both regions US has air bases and military personnel. They wont just pack up and leave regardless of how the trio dance goes between Putin Erdogan and Assad!
pravd | 3/7/2016
i hope Turkey is seeking to do as author of Article described. i hope turkey is trying to flirt with Russia, syrian regime and at the same time with isis and al-nusra to derail Kurdish gains in the middle east. the good thing about that scenario, kurds and America have to stick to each other. and Ameica will see more clearly kurds are trustworthy and honest as opposed ti Turkey. as long as Kurd ans America on the same side, the other actors destined to lose. if turkey is pursing that, this will make Ameirca mad and America may look for ways to punish turkey more. ---------------------------------- nowadays smart Ergenokon members and perincek group are flying on the clouds and assume making deal with Russia help them crush Kurdish. but why Russia become suddenly Turkey protector. what they will get in return after apology beside economy and trade relations... ---------------------------------- do not forget people/countries are more afraid of friend that can beytray or stab in back any time than their open enemies. can Russia turn its back to Turkey? ----------------------------------------------- -------------- what Turkey can do. Germany passed genocide law all of sudden and they could not retaliate. --------------------
Riha | 4/7/2016
The best article about Russia-Turkey is from the Saker: http://thesaker.is/turkey-on-the-ropes/
Another Kurdistani | 4/7/2016
I remember how rudaw commentators were going on about they will destroy Turkey with almighty Russian friends. Now that's kind of burst. Left with us? Can't wait to see your brainless comments when us leaves you high and dry. One lap to another. Jump like stripper. You(pkk) should have listen to serok Barzani and Apo. Make friend with Turkey. Instead of primping your children's blood to Assad, iran and russia. Now see how long before us dumps you. Morons.
A Kurd in exile | 4/7/2016
Once more history proved that "The Kurds have no friend but the mountains!" The whole Turkey's attempt to patch up differences with both Russia and Israel was due to its concern about the Kurds. This point was missed by all political observers. About a month or so ago, the Kurds in Turkey downed a Turkish military helicopter. Their missile might, or might not, have come from Russia. But, Turkey assumed that the Kurds had been given the weapon by the Russians. It was after that event that Turkey decided to apologize to Putin for downing their warplanes several months ago and make peace with them. It is all about Turkey's fear of, and animosity towards, the Kurds.

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

Rojhelati Kurmanc | 4/28/2017 6:04:24 AM
NATO and Israel should attack Iran, you will also get support from Kurds, Baloch, Arabs, Majority Iranians and Gilaki in Iran. Entire arab sunni...
Iran’s Kurdish opposition call for boycott of May elections
| 4 hours ago | (1)
michel.kinnis | 4/27/2017 3:21:49 PM
POTUS Trump is not Housein Obama !! He will help the Kurds in both Syria and Iraq to Prevent Iran to come through to Syria and Lebanon. Israel says...
Rojhelati Kurmanc | 4/28/2017 5:48:43 AM
Turkish trolls working hard, how are you doing "Berivan".
After Turkey struck YPG positions, US says it's asked Ankara to stop
| yesterday at 12:07 | (11)
Dutchman | 4/27/2017 1:27:18 PM
Israel has a right to defend itsself against terrorist groups like Hezbollah and its parners in crime: the Assad regime, Iran and Russia. Putin knows...
Rojhelati Kurmanc | 4/28/2017 5:45:05 AM
The kurds in Libanon have no rights in Libanon. Israel should remove the arabs in Israel and put in the kurds instead. Arabs never took the deal to...
Israeli warplanes strike Lebanese Hezbollah weapons cache near Damascus, reports
| yesterday at 12:52 | (3)
T.I. | 4/27/2017 11:18:15 PM
Merkel knows that the EU can't influence or contain Turkey (Erdogan) through "engagement", what she's really saying here is no matter how bad Turkey...
Mohamedzzz | 4/28/2017 5:12:34 AM
Angela Merkel is right, all Muslim countries look guidance from Turkey and an upset Turkey can bring a lot of trouble, with or without adhering to EU.
Merkel calls it a mistake for the EU to turn its back on Turkey
| 13 hours ago | (3)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

Kurdish MPs ask European parliament to support reactivation of their parliament 13 hours ago |

Kurdish MPs ask European parliament to support reactivation of their parliament

Kurdish parliament has been blocked since October more
Kurdish referendum needs parliamentary mandate, PUK and Gorran 22/4/2017 | (5)

Kurdish referendum needs parliamentary mandate, PUK and Gorran

KDP insists the referendum doesn't need a more
Surviving two genocides: Families escaped Halabja attack only to face Anfal 21/4/2017 | (2)

Surviving two genocides: Families escaped Halabja attack only to face Anfal

“How can I not be worried? My heart burns in pain more
0.187 seconds