Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Login

Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using
 

Email

 

Rudaw

Analysis

Palmyra’s fall a badly needed propaganda coup for ISIS

By Paul Iddon 12/12/2016
Syrian policeman in Palmyra's ancient Roman amphitheater before ISIS's May 2015 takeover. AFP file photo.
Syrian policeman in Palmyra's ancient Roman amphitheater before ISIS's May 2015 takeover. AFP file photo.
Islamic State’s (ISIS) assault on Palmyra over the weekend appears to be a concerted effort to rectify its incremental losses of territory in both Iraq and Syria.

The militants may well be trying to replicate their stunning and surprising takeover of that city, along with Iraq’s Ramadi, back in May 2015. On that occasion the Iraqi Army had just achieved its first US-backed victory since its infamous loss of Mosul, the recapture of Tikrit in April. Losing Ramadi was an enormous setback for Baghdad and the city was not wrested from the militants’ grip until the end of the following December.

In their only real victory against ISIS to date, Russian-backed Syrian regime forces managed to recapture Palmyra from the militants last March. They too had been humiliated by ISIS in Raqqa province in August 2014, when the militants besieged them in al-Tabqa airbase and routed them from the entire province. A subsequent offensive by Syrian regime forces into Raqqa province, to retake the city of al-Tabqa west of Raqqa city, in June ended in an abysmal defeat for them at the hands of the militants.

The latest attack on Palmyra comes after the militants have been forced from the major cities of Iraq’s Anbar province – Ramadi and Fallujah – and as they are completely surrounded in their largest city, Mosul. In northeast Syria, they have the Kurdish-led Syrian Democratic Forces’ (SDF) offensive, launched last November 6, to deal with. In northwest Syria they lost Manbij to the SDF in mid-August and are currently under siege in the city of al-Bab by Turkish-backed Free Syrian Army (FSA) fighters. To Raqqa’s southeast they control most of Deir Ezzor province, aside from the provincial capital, where a garrison of Syrian soldiers has been holding out against their siege for over two years now.

Therefore, it makes sense for ISIS to push westward, where they are more likely to make a quick breakthrough, a breakthrough which is important for propaganda reasons and morale among its own rank-and-file. They have made similar moves in the past. Their loss of Tikrit was softened by the aforementioned seizure of Ramadi and Palmyra and their November 2015 loss of Shingal was overshadowed by the group’s infamous massacre in Paris that same month.

If ISIS is able to consolidate its takeover of Palmyra, it will pose a test to the Syrian regime and its Russian backers, since it will reverse their only victory to date against the militants in Syria. If ISIS does get another chance it will likely try and completely destroy the ancient UNESCO world heritage site this time around.

This would be a slap in the face to UNESCO and other proponents of the preservation of cultural heritage, as well as Moscow. Last May Russia invited journalists to witness the spectacle of the Mariinsky Symphony Orchestra performing in Palmyra’s ancient Roman amphitheater, the same site where ISIS executed 21 Syrian soldiers simultaneously the previous July. To once again lose this site to the marauding militants, never mind having it completely destroyed, would be symbolically damaging to Moscow and Damascus and a propaganda victory for ISIS.

On Sunday the Russian press reported that Russian air power had managed to drive the militants out of the city; however, ISIS was able to regroup and reenter the city with very considerable force, at least 4,000 militants according to Syria’s own state-run SANA news. According to activists there, the militants are currently searching the city for any remaining loyalists to Syrian President Bashar al-Assad.

This comes as Damascus is heavily focused on crushing the remnants of its armed opponents in east Aleppo. They will likely want to continue securing as much territory as they can in that key province before diverting any significant resources and manpower to another attempt to retake and hold Palmyra.

If ISIS can secure their capture of Palmyra, destroy the site and terrorize the city’s populace once more, before either leaving or being driven out, they will have saved some face among their followers, who are no doubt beginning to realize that the caliphate’s days are numbered.

Comments

 
Ikran teacher | 12/12/2016
LONG LIVE KURDISH FIGHTERS.THE ONLY FORCES THAT BEATING THE BLACK CROWS UP.LONG LIVE PESHMARGA,HPG,YPG.
Dutchman | 12/12/2016
Unfortunately the fall of Palmyra is not just propaganda. This small desert town was the one and only gain that Assad and the Russians ever made against IS. Talking about propagande, the Russian knew how to act as if they are still a world power with a big Russian opera in Palmyra, but their contribution to the fight against IS is zero, nothing at all. Barrel bombing Assad and Buke missle Putin are just good at bombing civilians. They are war criminals, a threat to mankind and its world heritage.
Free Kurdistan | 13/12/2016
Palmyra did not "fall", it was handed to ISIS by Assad, why? Because to show Trump that ISIS is a threath and they left alot of weapons to ISIS, why? These will be used against Kurds (SDF). Just like Assad and Iran let turks come in to Jarabulus to fight kurds, this will make kurds bleed long time they tought. So after the jihadist our biggest enemy is shia terrorists and not ISIS. why? because isis has no open support but Assad does. Assad and SAA is not a friend of YPG, do not belive "flag" propaganda by Assad trolls on Twitter, they use kurds for their own propaganda. When they are finished with the sunnis, they will kill the kurds like Hafez did. Wake up! PYD is doing a great job btw, they do not side with Assad or Russia but stay neutral. Russia should pick PYD, why stay with losers like Assad and Hizbollah that will fall in the end? PYD are pro-US. So trump support the kurds and remove PKK from the terror list. Why support islamist Turkey that want to destroy US? We are kurd, support us.
WhyThisAssKissing | 13/12/2016
@Free Kurdistan: Islamist Turkey that wants to destroy US? What are you smoking? You think anyone with above 80 IQ will buy your stupid rhetoric?
jens holm | 13/12/2016
Well,its not a real comment. But I certainly hope none are cooking as "FREE KURDISTAN" spoiling good meat whith whatever.

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

pete | 6/17/2018 6:41:13 AM
"The PKK is a named terror organization in Turkey" ??? Why do you always publish Turkish propaganda? Why do you never mention that PKK is not...
Turkish forces hit PKK gathering in Qandil: Erdogan
| yesterday at 11:44 | (1)
barb scott | 6/17/2018 3:25:12 AM
Baloney! The CiA already funded and trained rebel groups way before the Grafitti boys. These funded groups were armed and shot police during the...
Karl | 6/17/2018 4:40:57 AM
If these boys really were responsible for the revolution against an evil regime, why were they released alive? Did these boys pay for the weapons,...
Graffiti boys who lit Syria war brace for regime attack
| yesterday at 10:53 | (2)
Iranian | 6/17/2018 12:29:41 AM
I'm Iranian. I hate traitors, sepaRATists, Tribalist racists and backward stalinist communists. But I'm against death penalty.
Prisoners riot to save Kurdish man on death row in Iran
| 16/6/2018 | (1)
pre-Boomer Marine brat | 6/16/2018 6:42:22 PM
Probably a good idea, though from what I've read, today's PKK are rebels who rejected his calls for detente - who wanted to kill Turks as much as...
Outsider | 6/16/2018 11:27:32 PM
Sure...let's see what they will say in few weeks and months...I remember well what they were saying only weeks ago... "YPG will never leave"... yes,...
Manbij officials remove Abdullah Ocalan images: commander
| 16/6/2018 | (2)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

Hashd al-Shaabi accuses US of killing 22 fighters in Syria airstrikes 57 minutes ago |

Hashd al-Shaabi accuses US of killing 22 fighters in Syria airstrikes

"American jets struck three fixed bases of Hashd more
HDP chair accuses Erdogan of ‘speaking on behalf of women’ 2 hours ago |

HDP chair accuses Erdogan of ‘speaking on behalf of women’

"Whether to smile or not, how many children to more
PKK denies casualties following Turkish weekend assault on Qandil 4 hours ago |

PKK denies casualties following Turkish weekend assault on Qandil

"We have had no losses in these attacks" more
0.25 seconds