Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Login

Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using
 

Email

 

Rudaw

Analysis

Would a Kurdish speaker in Iraq’s parliament change Kurd’s fortunes in Baghdad?

By Paul Iddon 13/5/2018
Iraqi parliament in session. File photo: AFP
Iraqi parliament in session. File photo: AFP
Since 2003 the largely ceremonial role of Iraqi president has been filled by a Kurd while the Sunnis invariably filled the role of parliamentary speaker. Some are now suggesting a Kurd should take the job and strengthen the position of Kurdish MPs in Baghdad. 

As Rudaw’s Rebwar Karim Wali pointed out, by settling for the role of presidency for the last decade and a half, “the Kurds have been distracted with a ceremonial position.” He argues that instead of settling for this position they should seek the position of speaker since, “having the position of the speaker of the Iraqi parliament, which works on the basis of majority vis-à-vis minority, is important so that the legislative body doesn’t turn into a place where conspiracies are made against the Kurdistan Region.”

The incumbent President of Iraq is Fuad Masum and the parliament speaker is Salim al-Jabouri. While Kurds have always been allotted the post of president by parliament, this is not a condition under the constitution or any Iraqi law. 

Joel Wing, author of the Musings on Iraq blog, points out that successfully attaining the position of speaker “would be a huge upgrade in the power of the Kurds in parliament.”

“The problem is that after the independence referendum the Kurdish parties are completely divided and will come into parliament with a greatly diminished position,” he told Rudaw English. 

“The scenarios that would allow them to get the speakership would be something like a major split between the main Shiite parties in which they are unable to unite and start going to the other lists to try to put a new government together,” he explained. “Otherwise there’s probably little chance this will happen.”

Furthermore, even if the Kurds attain this post, it is unclear whether it will give them much influence over Iraqi affairs. Yerevan Saeed, a Research Fellow at the Middle East Research Institute (MERI), points to past instances of Kurds securing posts in the government which they thought could secure their interests but ultimately did not. 

“Haunted by the machinations of the last century by Iraq and the neighboring countries, Kurds thought that they needed to secure the position of foreign ministry so that they would be aware of any potential plot against them,” Saeed told Rudaw English. 

“But Iraq was able to punish the Kurds in some other way which was to completely cut the share of the federal budget for Kurdistan in February 2014. This measure by the federal government made the Kurds to change their priorities from foreign affairs to finance, thinking that would ensure free flow of money to Kurdistan and prevent any financial punishments from Baghdad. But once again that proved it to be futile since Baghdad was able to cut Kurdish budget even though the Minister of Finance was a Kurd.” 

Hoshyar Zebari, the minister of finance, was infamously removed from his post in a vote of no confidence via secret ballot in September 2016. This came a mere month after the then-minister of defense, Khalid al-Obeidi, a Sunni from Mosul, was also removed from his post under questionable circumstances. Zebari deemed the move unconstitutional. 

“Presently the Kurds think that if they would be able to secure the speaker of parliament that will grant them some kind of veto on future legislation that will be against their national interests,” Saeed added. 

However, he believes this will ultimately prove futile.

“This deep deficit of trust, which has been fueled by past history and the unfair measures taken by post-2003 Iraqi governments against them, continuously reinforces the notion that Kurds have always held true, Baghdad has no good intention towards the Kurds when it has power.”

“Iraq is not the country of rule of law. Rather it is dominated by one sect and the judiciary is not independent,” Saeed concluded. “For these reasons minorities like Kurds and Sunnis will always be disadvantaged.”

1943 Views

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

toralf | 7/29/2018 7:59:32 PM
Your water problems seem to be political, not a result of a changing climate, which is also a political issue and not a proven fact.
Truthseeker | 8/14/2018 9:44:01 AM
the turks do it deliberatly this is always the way they defeated the local powers. read how they defeated the byzantinian empire its hilarous...
Up the creek without a creek: What’s causing the Middle East water crisis?
| 29/7/2018 | (2)
SuperJC | 8/14/2018 5:27:01 AM
Erdogan does all the things against Allah...then calls Allah to help him. Contradict one...two...and thee. Even Allah says bye-bye.
good guy | 8/14/2018 9:32:46 AM
guys short short short lira this a chance in a lifetime🎊🎊🎊🎊🎊🎊🎊💶💶💶💷💷💷💵💵💶🌁🌁💶🗼💷💵💴💴💶💷💷💷⛲️⛲️⛲️🚡🚡🚡🚡🚠🚠🚠
Why is Turkey facing economic oblivion?
| yesterday at 10:59 | (6)
steve | 8/14/2018 8:49:23 AM
corruption is EVERYWHERE in the middle east and it always get to a point where people have had enough. NOBODY in America is talking about a war . It...
Iranian | 8/14/2018 9:28:05 AM
@trinity Sounds like Erbillywood script.
Iran's Khamenei: ‘No war, no negotiations with the US’
| 21 hours ago | (5)
JK | 8/13/2018 9:24:12 PM
....but but but ISIS was defeated last year!
Tron | 8/14/2018 9:25:50 AM
yes and 300 million outside while 50 million in nonmuslim countries.
20,000-30,000 IS fighters left in Iraq, Syria: UN report
| 15 hours ago | (2)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

What effect will a Hashd drawdown have on Nineveh? 4 hours ago |

What effect will a Hashd drawdown have on Nineveh?

"Yezidis have an understandable fear of any more
Turkey crisis risks souring military ties with US 5 hours ago |

Turkey crisis risks souring military ties with US

"It'll just force Turkey into Russia's hands" more
New Generation announces 50 candidates for KRG election 13 hours ago | (1)

New Generation announces 50 candidates for KRG election

The party secured four seats in Iraq's May 12 more
0.203 seconds