Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Login

Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using
 

Email

 

Rudaw

Analysis

Would Turkey favor Assad on its borders over the PYD?

By Paul Iddon 25/8/2016
A YPG fighter eyes a Turkish tank on the Syrian-Turkish border. AP file photo.
A YPG fighter eyes a Turkish tank on the Syrian-Turkish border. AP file photo.

Less than two weeks have passed since the Kurdish-led Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF) captured Manbij from Islamic State (ISIS). Since then, the Syrian Kurdish Peoples Protection Units (YPG) have fought regime forces in Hasakah, where they have been bombed by Damascus for the first time last week. Ankara did not condemn this action, believing it proved that the Syrian regime was finally beginning to view the Kurdish Democratic Union Party (PYD) as a threat.

 

While the Turkish government has long stressed that it staunchly opposes both President Bashar al-Assad and the ruling PYD, Ankara may well see a return of military forces under Assad’s command to the Syrian border with Turkey as a more favorable outcome to continued PYD presence there. 

During the ISIS siege of Kobani in late 2014 Turkey was criticized for massing its armor on the border and not intervening, seeming to believe that ISIS militants would defeat the PYD and not continue on to threaten Turkey itself. This week, the Turkish military played a key role in the Jarablus operation, which ousted the remaining ISIS militants on Syria’s northwestern border with Turkey. During the course of this operation it has hit both ISIS militants on the border and SDF forces further south with artillery. 

Turkey may well view a war between Assad and the PYD positively if it sees results in the PYD being subdued and Syrian Kurdish autonomy dismantled. 

Aaron Stein, an expert on US-Turkey relations at the Atlantic Council, told Rudaw English that Turkey, “has to live with the PYD’s dominant presence east of the Euphrates River” across Syria’s northeastern border. 

“Ankara’s policy has always been to deny them territorial control west of the river and has, both at Tishreen and then Manbij, made exceptions after negotiations with the United States,” Stein pointed out. 

Turkey acquiesced to the SDF crossing to the west bank of the Euphrates from the Tishreen Dam last December and agreed in May not to interfere with the Manbij operation after the US assured them that Arab members of the SDF would lead it, with the YPG playing a limited supporting role before retreating back to the east bank of the Euphrates upon the completion of that operation.  

Stein pointed out that the Jarablus operation is helping push ISIS from the Turkish border, “while reinforcing its position that the YPG must move units back across the Euphrates. A win-win, if the scope remains narrow.”

Samuel Heller, a Beirut-based analyst on the Syria conflict, argues that Ankara sees a PYD presence on its border as a direct threat to its own security and territorial integrity, given the links between the PYD and the Kurdistan Workers Party (PKK). 

“For a long while, Turkey has regarded the Assad regime as the fundamental reason for Syria’s war and its destabilizing impact on Syria’s neighbors, including the capture of large sections of northern Syria by the PKK-linked PYD and the unrest in Turkey’s southeast. But even if Assad is the root cause, it’s now the PKK that poses a grave and imminent threat to Turkey’s national security and its territorial integrity,” Heller told Rudaw English. 

“I don’t think Turkey can tolerate a PKK safe haven running the length of its south border. If it comes down to it, I don’t think we can rule out the possibility Turkey will prefer that Assad control some sections of northern Syria now held by the PYD/YPG; for Turkey, that may be the lesser evil,” he added. 

Professor Joshua Landis, a Syria expert and Director of the Center for Middle East Studies at the University of Oklahoma, doesn’t rule out the possibility that Turkey might be looking into transforming Turkish relations with Iran and Russia in hopes they will move against the PYD. 

“Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan says that he will not accept normal relations with Damascus so long as Assad is at the helm. All the same, it is clear that Erdogan and his new Prime Minister are looking for ways to transform his relations with Iran and Russia in order to place greater pressure on the Kurds and stop their advance along Syria’s border with Turkey,” Landis told Rudaw English. 

“We don’t yet know how much Erdogan will give Russia and Iran on the Syria question, in order to achieve greater pressure on the Kurds. But many are betting that Erdogan’s back peddling on the Syria question has not come to an end,” Landis added. 

 

Aliza Marcus, an analyst on Kurdish issues and author of ‘Blood and Belief: The P.K.K. and the Kurdish Fight for Independence’ believes Turkey’s “view on Assad has softened.”

"Turkey's gone from demanding that any solution exclude Assad to now saying he could stay in a transition period. Given Ankara's hostility to Syrian Kurdish YPG forces, it's not impossible that it would prefer to see Syrian troops at its border instead of Kurdish ones. But for that to happen, Assad would end up battling YPG, which won't easily give up control of the border area,” she told Rudaw English. 

Paul Iddon is a Rudaw reporter based in Erbil, Kurdistan Region.

Comments

 
Data pager
Previous
12
Page size:
PageSizeComboBox
select
Ayhan Bilgili | 25/8/2016
While Turkey doesn't have any problem with Kurdistan Regional Government of Iraq, Turkey has serious problem with PKK and YPG. Reason ? Simple, because PKK and YPG trained people blowing themselves, carrying out suicide attacks in Turkey. Everyone in this region agrees to one thing, there should be peace where people can focus on improving themselves, economies, education. Everyone is tired of talking about which country have what interests in this region. So PKK YPG should stop being tool used by foreign powers.
Hersh | 25/8/2016
YPG will be making a historical mistake if they stubbornly go ahead towards Al Bab and loose American support. Why risk everything? only a few neighborhoods were left in Kobani when the Americans came in and saved them, did they forget that? this is unbelievable stupidity
Policy | 25/8/2016
Erdogan policy to favour Assad on their border is really fuck up. They just don't know what they wanted. First they want Assad out. Then they want Rebel forces to win. How for heaven sake are the rebels going to win with Assad controlling the border. No weapon supply of any kind can get through to the rebels, if Assad control the border. Erdogan brain needs rewiring. Turkey is so concern with Kurd that they forgot Assad and the Russian are more dangerous. Assad will never forgive Erdogan messing with Syria for many years. Russian only made peace with turkey for their own reason, that is to break up the NATO alliance and reduce American influence. Once that has been achieved, Turk are going to get what's coming.
Guest | 25/8/2016
It's not about who Turkey prefers. It's about what fits in best with Turkey's long term grandiose scheme of recreating the Ottoman Empire. Turkey, or any other country, doesn't have the right to dictate what Syrian citizens can and can't do.
Guest | 26/8/2016
@Hersh: I agree with you on that point. But, I also hope that you, too, will agree with me on this one: The Kurds should under no circumstances listen to Obama administration and move against ISIS in Raqqa or any other non-Kurdish land. It will be an absolute stupidity for the Kurds to spill the blood of their young fighters to liberate the non-Kurdish territories, and later to be ordered by Joe Biden to give it up and go home.

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

FAUthman | 7/22/2017 2:23:51 PM
This referendum will not effect Abadi's reelection one bit. It is six months before Iraq's parliamentary elections are held and only one month before...
FukUS | 7/22/2017 2:30:04 PM
Why you ask? Because Americans are liars trust them and you will lose they just use everything for their purpose. They said the same every year even...
Why America wants Kurds to postpone the referendum
| 3 hours ago | (4)
morteza | 7/22/2017 12:48:01 PM
99% attacks on america and trump from social media comes from iranian facebook and twitter accounts.
Yam | 7/22/2017 2:05:26 PM
@mortrza, that's just the thing, the American's are clueless about how active the Iranian-American community really is. Not saying all Iranians work...
US threatens Iran with 'serious consequences' if American citizens not released
| 9 hours ago | (3)
Muraz Adzhoev | 7/20/2017 9:49:22 PM
Certainly the threat should not be underestimated, but at the same time it should not be dramatically overestimated. This is the matter of efficiency...
Muraz Adzhoev | 7/22/2017 1:04:01 PM
I would recommend Lahur Talabani to advise Aso Talabani, the official representative of the KRG in Russia not to make unacceptable and public...
With retaking of Mosul, ISIS sleeper cells and guerrilla warfare biggest threat
| yesterday at 10:30 | (3)
Kurds are their oen worst enemy | 7/22/2017 12:37:17 PM
You know if Baghdad was any less corrupt, or more democratic or better in any way I would understand the argument. Not only are they not but we all...
The realist Kurd is here | 7/22/2017 12:58:51 PM
The Kurds still live in a tribal society...!!! Why? It's simple. After years of fighting for the Kurdish people's rights in Iraq, they (polititions)...
Have Kurds Moved Beyond Tribalism?
| yesterday at 03:32 | (12)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

French charity replaces Virgin Mother statues destroyed by ISIS in Iraq 1 hour ago |

French charity replaces Virgin Mother statues destroyed by ISIS in Iraq

The 15 Virgin Mary statues, which are 1.5 meters more
Why America wants Kurds to postpone the referendum 3 hours ago | (4)

Why America wants Kurds to postpone the referendum

The US has been giving Iraq one chance after more
Yezidi mother in Canada hopes to reunite with son she thought was dead 6 hours ago |

Yezidi mother in Canada hopes to reunite with son she thought was dead

A campaign is underway to help the family reunite more
0.516 seconds