Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Login

Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using
 

Email

 

Rudaw

Analysis

Forget Raqqa: Deir Ezzor is where US-Russia should coordinate against ISIS

By Paul Iddon 27/5/2016
Syrian army soldiers preparing for an attack on ISIS in Deir Ezzor. AFP file photo
Syrian army soldiers preparing for an attack on ISIS in Deir Ezzor. AFP file photo

The United States has once again turned down a Russian suggestion to coordinate counter-Islamic State (ISIS) operations. Washington declined to coordinate with Moscow before, too, due to its indiscriminate bombing across Syria, which has killed hundreds of civilians, as well as its continued support for the Syrian regime of President Bashar al-Assad.  


As part of Russia’s latest proposal for military cooperation the country’s Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov suggested that American and Russian air power synchronize their support of the Syrian Kurdish-majority Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF), which is currently mounting an offensive against the ISIS-occupied province of Raqqa.


US air power has invariably proven much more capable of carrying out more precise targeted strikes against ISIS positions and vehicles. The US bombing campaign against Raqqa has hit specific militant targets to minimize civilian casualties while the Russian bombings have devastated residential areas through what appears to be largely indiscriminant bombing.


While Russian participation in an operation against Raqqa could prove to be counterproductive, and result in an unnecessarily high civilian death toll, there is one place where the US coalition should consider very limited ad-hoc coordination with the Russians in Syria, Deir Ezzor.


The Syrian city is located approximately 140 kilometers southeast of Raqqa and is capital of the province of the same name. ISIS have managed to takeover large parts of it and the only obstacle to their complete domination of the city – which would put them in full control of two Syrian provincial capitals – is a contingent of Syrian Arab Army (SAA) soldiers who have been holding out in the airport and other parts of the city for around two years now.


The humanitarian situation in Deir Ezzor is dire thanks to ISIS’s continued presence, the inability of the UN to truck in humanitarian aid to civilians trapped in that city which resulted in the agency undertaking its first and only humanitarian airdrops in Syria over that city. The Russians have also dropped supplies to the SAA troops in Deir Ezzor in recent months.


If the SDF successfully surround Raqqa from the north, east and west it is possible ISIS could withdraw to Deir Ezzor without putting up a fight for Raqqa. Instead their forces withdrawing southeast to Deir Ezzor could reinforce ISIS militants already in that city and takeover all of Deir Ezzor and make it their new Syrian stronghold. After retaking Raqqa the SDF may not be willing to launch an operation much further south and ISIS could dig-in, secure that city for themselves and live to die another day.


In recognition of the fact that is in nobody’s interest the US and Russia should mildly coordinate a campaign to put further pressure on ISIS in Deir Ezzor. The US could step-up targeted air and drone strikes against the group there and the Russians could logistically reinforce the SAA in Deir Ezzor by sending them more heavy weapons. Moscow could possibly even consider embedding some Russian commandos with the SAA in Deir Ezzor. The US coalition could share intelligence with those commandos concerning the ISIS targets they are bombing in the city and possibly even coordinate with them in certain areas to keep the militants dispersed and under pressure.


The US coalition was right not to coordinate with neither Assad nor the Russians. However it is far from the US interests to see the SAA overwhelmed in Deir Ezzor and ISIS secure an alternative stronghold to Raqqa. 

 

Paul Iddon is a Rudaw reporter based in Erbil, Kurdistan Region.

 

Comments

 
Help the Ezidis | 27/5/2016
The author forgets to say that it is very easy for the Russians to drop food and more weapons to Deir Ezzor: why don't they do that? The author is also wrong about Raqqa: it is clear that if the YPG and YPJ should have got more sophisticated weapons from the US/EU they should have advanced already inside Raqqa. It is not the strategic competence of the YPJ or YPG mister Iddon, it is the political will and pressure of Turkey on the US/EU not to give these heroes the approriate weapons. The YPG and YPJ would have encircled Raqqa if they had the weapons!!
fermin | 27/5/2016
A decent idea that will never materialize. The United States and Russia have two very different objectives in Syria, they're rivals but occasionally their interests cross as in the case with ISIS. They'll cooperate to a degree but don't expect anything major because they both keep their eyes on their long term goals.
American | 28/5/2016
I think this author is mental retard. What part of "We will not stop until ISIS is completely eradicated from Syria and with so many Arab Syrians that want to join a non-ethic, secular, and democratic movement are joining in the hundreds every week." ~ SDF General. Why the hell do you think that we would even work together with an ally of a despotic dictator that barrel bombs his people indiscriminately in the name of terrorism, and is the soul reason why ISIS is so successful in that country?
Ben | 28/5/2016
Well ffs surround the city you idiots and stop daesh from heading south I hear there about 25 thousand of you and about 700 daesh how come you can't contain them and get them as the come out of the city
Bill | 4/6/2016
I can't help laughing when someone like Ben, who can't compose a complete sentence labels others idiots.
Tags :
5963 Views

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

Adstar | 7/25/2017 3:38:26 AM
She made her own bed.. Now she can sleep in it.. You can be assured most Germans will not want her back.. They do not support the death penalty but...
green activist defector | 7/25/2017 12:22:14 PM
joshcka fischer the "green activist" and turkish lobbyist in berlin maybe can talk to his boss in ankara to solve this girls situation.
German girl who joined ISIS wants to leave Iraq, return to family
| yesterday at 11:45 | (10)
Gorran is betrayal | 7/25/2017 11:31:12 AM
Russia recognizes the right of the Kurds on indpendence , but Gorran denies the Kurds the right to hold the referendeum on independence.
kurd | 7/25/2017 11:33:27 AM
when he talks to turkish and iranian newspapers, he condemns kurdish independence. some of these comments show how many are naive
Sergey Lavrov to Rudaw: Referendum is expression of Kurdish people’s aspirations
| yesterday at 08:55 | (8)
Gorran is betrayal | 7/25/2017 11:22:49 AM
Gorran is treason , is anti-kurdish .
alan | 7/25/2017 11:29:41 AM
A new leader who is not family member of the former leader? If KDP or PUK gets a new leader he will be from the same family. Thanks we have Gorran...
New Gorran leader: We can achieve party’s objectives through dialogue
| 11 hours ago | (2)
Dana | 7/25/2017 10:47:59 AM
All that useless repetition of obvious information made the article horrible to read, not to mention that it missed the most important detail, which...
Al-Qaida in Syria close to snuffing out competition in north
| 16 hours ago | (1)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

NRT TV owner announces vote-no campaign for referendum 5 hours ago |

NRT TV owner announces vote-no campaign for referendum

He called referendum a “dangerous gamble with more
Kurdish official says US role essential in post-IS Syria 6 hours ago |

Kurdish official says US role essential in post-IS Syria

Americans " must continue until a democratic more
PM Abadi: I won’t deploy tanks to Kurdistan in response to referendum 7 hours ago |

PM Abadi: I won’t deploy tanks to Kurdistan in response to referendum

PM Abadi: “I mean, what I will do? Will I deploy more
0.203 seconds