Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment


Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using





Mixed Feelings Over Barzani’s Visit to Diyarbakir

By Rudaw 16/11/2013
A tea shop in Diyarbakir. Photo by Adam Reader.
A tea shop in Diyarbakir. Photo by Adam Reader.

Kurdistan Region President Massoud Barzani is expected to arrive in Diyarbakir, the largest Kurdish city in Turkey, on Saturday. He will meet with Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan; attend the inauguration of government projects and partake in some wedding celebrations.

Barzani’s invitation to Diyarbakir clearly marks a break from the traditional Turkish policy towards the Kurds in the whole region. It is true that provincial elections are coming in March next year and Erdogan wants to win Kurdish voters. But the story of the visit cannot only be read from this angle.

As a prominent Kurdish leader, Barzani will be the first to visit Diyarbakir and be received as the president of the Kurdistan Region. This has symbolic significance at the minimum. Unlike previous Turkish governments, Turkey’s foreign policy under Erdogan’s Justice and Development Party (AKP) has shown flexibility and leniency toward the Kurds.

This has to do with several factors. First, Kurdistan is rich in hydrocarbon resources -- something that Turkey is in desperate need of. Secondly, the recent Arab spring further pushed AKP to embrace the Kurds more pragmatically, to avoid any security fallouts of the kind seen on Arab streets. And of course, the peace process with the Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK) is a soft way to defuse historical tensions between Turks and Kurds in the region. Barzani has been invaluable for Ankara on all of these issues.  In return, Ankara is almost working as protector of the Kurdish enclave in northern Iraq. It has helped Kurdistan to be economically developed and soon it will have its own independent source of income from its nearly-completed pipeline.

As Barzani prepares for his trip, there are mixed feelings on both sides of the border. Some of the Kurdish leaders from northern (Turkish) Kurdistan have already argued that the AKP wants to use Barzani to attract traditional Kurdish voters that have gone to the pro-Kurdish Peace and Democracy Party (BDP) in the previous election. Meanwhile, the Turkish nationalists view Barzani’s visit as another attempt to divide Turkey.

Selahattin Demirtas, the co-chair of BDP, said he welcomed Barzani’s visit as long as it did not harm the Kurds politically.

“From Erbil to Amed (Diyarbakir) is Barzani’s home and Barzani can be considered an experienced politician if he does not become a tool for AKP’s election campaign,” said Demirtas at a press conference in Paris.

Ahmet Turk, the co-chairman of the DTK (Democratic Society Congress) warned about AKP’s plans to undermine Kurdish political parties in Turkey by inviting Barzani. He believes that Barzani’s invitation is aimed at the March elections. “Barzani should interpret the Kurdish people’s expectations correctly. Some people may have invited Barzani for the next elections. I hope that Mr. Barzani notices this,” Turk said earlier this week.

After returning from a visit to Baghdad last Monday, Turkish Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoglu told journalists: “We are happy when we see bonds between Turkey and Bosnians or Albanians in the Balkans. The same is valid for Kurds as well. This is in fact a part of our normalization and reflection of self-confidence. In the past, there were those who were against any contact between Kurds inside Turkey and outside, as if it would be the end of the world.”

Relations between Turkey and the Kurdistan Region hit an iceberg when Barzani threatened to intervene in Diyarbakir in 2007 in response to Turkish interference in the Kurdish city of Kirkuk.

"We will not let the Turks intervene in Kirkuk," Barzani said at at the time in an interview with Al-Arabiyah television. "Kirkuk is an Iraqi city with a Kurdish identity, historically and geographically. All the facts prove that Kirkuk is part of Kurdistan," he said.

Erdogan declared that cabinet members and deputies will attend collective opening ceremonies in Diyarbakır next Sunday. “All together, we will embrace the people of Diyarbakır in our province of Diyarbakır,” he said.

The main opposition Republican People's Party's (CHP) deputy chair Sezgin Tanrikulu, a Kurdish politician from the southeastern region, cautioned Barzani to watch his reputation.

“Mr. Barzani is a prestigious name of the 50-to-60-year-long political struggle of the Kurds. He has earned this reputation from the struggle in his personal history. I hope that he takes care not to sacrifice this reputation to internal political strife, conflicts and fights in Turkey,” he told journalists.

On the other hand, the Iraqi Kurdish parties are divided over Barzani’s trip to Diyarbakir.

The leader of the Kurdistan Islamic Union, Muhammad Rauf, believes that Barzani’s trip will contribute to the peace process and strengthen Kurdish-Turkish ties. In the meantime, he lamented that Barzani’s trip is only tied to the upcoming election in Turkey.

“What’s important is contribution to the peace process and everyone is looking out for his own interests, and we are looking for the interest of our people in Northern Kurdistan,” Rauf told Rudaw.

However, Muhammad Hakim, an official of the Kurdistan Islamic League (Komal) told Rudaw, “such relations between the Kurdistan presidency and Kurdistan government with the neighboring countries are murky for us, therefore I cannot comment on this.

The main Kurdish opposition group, the Change Movement (Gorran), also warned that Barzani’s visit to Diyarbakir would not serve Kurdish interests. Rebeen Omer, a Gorran official in Erbil, told DIHA news agency: “Barzani’s trip will be good publicity for AKP and it could hinder the peace process between Turkey and the PKK.”


Data pager
Page size:
TAK | 16/11/2013
barzani will pay the price for his crimes this weekend. No guy has the right to stand in the way of our revolution. T A K
Russel Check | 16/11/2013
"Mixed feelings"? Rudaw interviews a dozen Kurds across Kurdistan, all with different affiliations and political stand and they ALL said the same thing! "Barzany is being used by AKP" yet the title is "Mixed feelings"
Raven | 16/11/2013
Kurds do not recognize the legitimacy of Turkey. We have never recognized it and never will! As far as we are concerned, Mongols occupied Anatolia 900 years ago and massacred its inhabitants. They are occupying force and have no legitimacy whatsoever! Neither historically, legally nor morally. It is the duty of every honorable Kurd to kick the occupiers out of Kurdistan.
Atheist | 16/11/2013
Instead of all these sinister plots against the Kurds Erdogan should start to see reason and logic and try to be honest. He invoke god, prophets and truth often. Yet he is decitful and dishonest in all his manners. If he is honest he can solve the Kurdish issue in one day. Alas, he's a liar, and a bad one. I wrote him an open letter 7 years ago, excerpts published In Hurriyet Daily News ( on how he can solve the Kurdish. problem. Unfortunately he is not trying to solve the Kurdish problem. He tries to manage it! Big difference!
Bakir Lashkari
Bakir Lashkari | 16/11/2013
These reaction from various Kurdish political fractions and iTS various Kurdish regio'ns are mostly based on the emotional levels! The Turkish Government and iTS president Erdogan is trying to use the Barazani's présence in DiyarBakir for iTS own political ballots in the Kurdistan parts of Turkey and Syria.There are various scenario's about the historical visit of Massoud Barzani to DiyarBakir at this point of time. The key question is who needs who and Why?who is getting the benefits from whom? There are the political, economical, social and cultural aspects which are mainly the mixed of pro and contra effects as well as the implications of the outcome of the visit of Massoud Barzani and Erdogan in DiyarBakir. Why there are different views and mixed feeling over the Barzani visit to meet Erdogan in DiyarBakir? Because there are so many complicated aspects and mutual interests for the. KRG & Turkish relationship which no one knows what the impacts could be? On the whole I would say the meeting between Erdogan & Barzani in DiyarBakir have some positive impact on the upcoming Provincial election in Turkey for some political Parties. The major problem between the current peaceprocess between the Turkish. Government and PKK is that they use the name of Peace and not the word compromis and consensus, which means to give in order to get or the otherway around. I believe that Massoud Barzani believes in the compromis and consensus startegy rather than the peaceprocess which causes so many obstacles, due the fact that both Party's, The Erdogan Government & PKK Are focussing on the Total package of demanding and conditional matters. I do not believe that Barzani let himself to be used by Erdogan for iTS getting the most Kurdish voters by the coming election in Turkey. It seems that Turkey is very much interested in the natural resources of Kurdistan Region in one hand, and on the other hand Turkey wants to control the Kurdish cases and aspirations in various parts, like in Iraq, Syria and in Turkey as well. Neither Turkey nor KRG is intending to resolve the kurd cases in Turkey and Syria by force, which not in the Economic interests of both bilateral relationships. In my opinion the idea is how to isolate the YPN in Syria led by Salih Muslim in one hand and disconnect the relationship between the political wing of the PKK from iTS Violence orientated fighters now in Syria, helping Salih Muslim to destabilize the Kurdish unitiy in all parts of Kurdistan as well as causing the deadlock peaceprocess between Turkey and PKK Political Kurdish workers Party. The main and key issue is how to stop the backing and support of the PKK to Salih Muslim in Syria politically and military's aid? On the other hand how to win the hearts and soles of the Kurdish people in Turkey like DiyarBakir when it 's to restarting negotiations between Turkey & PKK which might lead this time to free Ocalan from the prison! To my view Mr Massoud Barzani can play a major role in solving the Kurdish issues in Turkey and Syria, if the Kurdish political Parties agree upon the compromise and consensus which means for all Parties to give and to get !
Tags :

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

Herki | 1/22/2017 12:22:09 PM
Is he bored?
Chris | 1/22/2017 12:24:42 PM
Has Netanyahu gone mad? Does he really think the Iranian people will listen to him? Yes, they are oppressed by their backward and cruel religious...
Israeli PM Netanyahu addresses Iranian people, says he'll soon speak to Trump
| 8 hours ago | (3)
dire straights | 1/22/2017 11:54:45 AM
In every civiled country in the world a referendum is held ONLY in the region that wants to seperate and NOT the wntire country because that makes no...
Pola | 1/22/2017 12:16:27 PM
To get independence Kurds need unity and not corrupt politicans who just talk about indipendence every month to get more voters. If a leader promises...
Iraqi MP: Baghdad does not have power to negotiate Kurdistan independence
| 11 hours ago | (3)
pre-Boomer Marine brat | 1/21/2017 5:33:44 PM
The "2011 mistake" was a willful and ideologically-driven decision on the part of Barack Obama. As a Senator, he'd been the most vigorous opponent...
Bilbas | 1/22/2017 10:25:56 AM
President Barzani calls on US to keep its forces after Mosul
| yesterday at 07:36 | (2)
KURDISH STATE | 1/22/2017 8:26:44 AM
PYD is one party rule. No opposition and no known allies. It is there just to provide Turkey with the pretext to invade Kurdish lands .It is there...
amed | 1/22/2017 8:41:25 AM
Could any logical and intelligent one explain that how a piece of land will have two separete armies and two chiefs of command so that to defend and...
Syrian Kurdish faction likely to dispatch KRG-trained Peshmerga to Rojava
| 14 hours ago | (5)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

UPDATED: UN envoy to Syria meets with Kazakh FM ahead of Astana talks 7 hours ago | (2)

UPDATED: UN envoy to Syria meets with Kazakh FM ahead of Astana talks

UN envoy told Rudaw they are "working hard", more
Iraqi MP: Baghdad does not have power to negotiate Kurdistan independence 11 hours ago | (3)

Iraqi MP: Baghdad does not have power to negotiate Kurdistan independence

"It canot negotiate in this dangerous issue more
Syrian Kurdish faction likely to dispatch KRG-trained Peshmerga to Rojava 14 hours ago | (5)

Syrian Kurdish faction likely to dispatch KRG-trained Peshmerga to Rojava

President Barzani hinted at the deployment last more
0.234 seconds