Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Login

Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using
 

Email

 

Rudaw

Syria

The tragic consequences of a war between the regime and the Kurds in Syria

By Paul Iddon 19/8/2016
Syrian Kurdish fighter in Hasakah, Syria Kurdistan. AFP photo.
Syrian Kurdish fighter in Hasakah, Syria Kurdistan. AFP photo.

A week after the Kurdish-led Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF) liberated Manbij from Islamic State (ISIS) the Syrian Kurds have been bombed by regime warplanes for the first time in the city of Hasakah. Escalation of regime bombings and clashes between the regime and the Kurds run the risk of relieving the pressure on ISIS following one its most significant losses in Syria in months. 

 

On Thursday and Friday clashes between Syrian Kurdish forces with the remaining regime-controlled enclave in that Kurdish-majority city saw scores killed and thousands of civilians evacuated from the city. This serious escalation risks breaking out into open conflict between the regime and the Kurds, an outcome which could well give ISIS a strategic windfall at a critical moment in this war – since the Kurds would have to divert manpower and resources to fight off the regime instead of mount offensives against those militants. 

 

On the ground in Syria the SDF, of which the Syrian Kurdish Peoples Protection Units (YPG) is the primary component, is the most formidable force by far in the battle against ISIS in Syria. The Syrian regimes only attempt to mount an offensive against ISIS last June was completely repelled by the militants, meaning no ground force will be able to mount major offensives against ISIS in Syria if the regime and the Kurds end up going to war.  

 

Given its concentration on the ongoing battle for Aleppo the regime in Damascus will unlikely be able to do more than bombard Kurdish forces in Hasakah and Qamishlo with the remainder of their forces in those areas and airstrikes. They could, however, threaten YPG forces in Aleppo’s Kurdish majority Sheikh Maqsoud neighbourhood and possibly even the northwestern Kurdish Afrin Canton in the foreseeable future. The two most vulnerable areas the Syrian Kurds in the northeast want to be able to access and protect. 

 

A much better outcome for both sides would be a ceasefire. The YPG have clashed, sometimes violently, with these remaining regime forces in Syria Kurdistan (Rojava) before. None of those clashes escalated into full-fledged war since it has been in neither sides interests to divert resources into fighting each other when they face adversaries much closer to home. Consequently a largely successful, especially by Syrian standards, de-facto ceasefire between them has largely remained in place for about five-years now. 

 

If that comes to an end before ISIS is defeated in Syria then those militants will likely manage to survive and retain hold over territory, including cities, in Syria’s east. Without working in tandem with allied ground forces airstrikes alone won’t be able to completely destroy ISIS in these areas.  

 

The US will unlikely seek to establish a full-fledged long-term no-fly zone against the regimes warplanes, or bomb the regimes ground forces to prevent them entering Rojava. Turkey may well oppose the US warplanes protecting a group they view as part of the Kurdistan Workers Party (PKK) from its strategically-important southeastern Incirlik Airbase – from where the US, UK and France (until 1998) policed the no-fly zones over Iraqi Kurdistan back in the 1990’s and early 2000’s. 

 

That would mean the US would have to fly from bases in the Persian Gulf from about 2,000 kilometers away – flying jet fighters from aircraft carriers in the Mediterranean or Red Sea would entail flying over regime-held territory if Turkey disallowed use of its airspace for such an endeavor – which would make it very difficult to maintain a round-the-clock protective aerial umbrella over Rojava. 

 

Also such a move would run the dangerous risk of clashing with Russia. The Kremlin’s ally in Damascus has voiced its opposition to the deployment of western special forces soldiers to train the SDF. Russian fighter bombers already bombed a base in southeastern Syria, near the Jordanian border, where American and British special forces were training the New Syrian Army anti-ISIS militia, twice last June 16th.  

 

Russia officially claimed the incident was an accident. However it could be reasonably interpreted as a warning against the western powers which have deployed these advisory military forces to Syria, especially given the fact that they bombed a day after British special forces advisors left that very base. 

 

Given the difficulties and risks the coalition will face if they try to forcibly protect its most reliable, by far, on the ground partner against ISIS in Syria the importance of averting war between the regime and the Kurds is all the more crucial. Damascus and Qamishlo need to quell the current hostilities in recognition of the fact that neither of them, at least for now, have anything to gain from going to war with each other. 

 

Paul Iddon is a Rudaw reporter based in Erbil, Kurdistan Region

Comments

 
Data pager
Previous
Page size:
PageSizeComboBox
select
kurt basar | 19/8/2016
You have to wonder, if the Syrians bombing of the Kurd's was beginning of their new cooperation w/ the Turkish terrorist state's Salafi thugs? Turkish terrorist state thugs will sell their filthy soul to anybody, who can stop any Kurdish autonomy in Syria. Question is, for how long those supposed to be civilized nations & NATO are going to tolerate this new Muslim Hitler? who is openly hosting and supporting all of the Muslim terrorists worldwide, exporting the savage Muslim terrorists to their country, burning the Kurdish toddlers & children's alive and destroying those ancient Kurdish cities with the NATO's tanks & plains w/ his 8 months old & ongoing cruel and barbaric curfews. we have to wonder?
duroi | 19/8/2016
Assad is acting cocky after the visit of Erdogan to Russia, but Assad and his Shiite allies are digging their own graves by attacking the Kurds in Rojava. This could help unify the Sunni Arab and Kurdish opposition in Syria. To help this, YPG should capture and exchange the Syrian/Iranian army generals (and high ranking officers) in Jazireh Kurdish province and exchange them for Kurds abducted by the Sunni Arab opposition and enter a ceasefire agreement with Sunni Arabs by negotiating 36.4 N Par as the border line between Kurds and Arabs in Raqqa, Allepo and Iskandarun/Hatay provinces of Syria (with a Misfan-Handarat route to Sheikh Maqsoud).
Cradley | 19/8/2016
Instead or forcing a no fly zone from Turkey the Americans can use bases in Cyprus, KRG or even Rojava itself. If they don't want to do that they can use aircraft carriers outside the coast of Syria. Or they could arm YPG with mobile anti air systems. They can shoot down one of Assads jets as a warning with their own jets. There are a lot of options if they really want to stop Assads terror air force.
Circassian 4Ever | 20/8/2016
God protect those 300 US troops embedded with the SDF. All Hell will break lose if those troops are harmed by Syrian or Russian airstrikes.
bebegun | 20/8/2016
Assad needs to take into account that there are 15-20 thousend very well equipped and well trained Syrian Kurdish Peshmerga in KRG waiting for a green light from PYD to enter Rojava. These forces will be able to help YPG link up Afrin and northern Aleppo to Kobani. When that happens it will be game over for all of his troops and militias in Hasaka and Qamishli. So think long and hard before escalating this with Kurds

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

Leon | 3/24/2019 8:03:06 AM
Sistani is not the governemnt, so get fucked. Iraq should use force to remove him.
Iraqi PM proposes parliament sacks Nineveh governor
| yesterday at 11:47 | (1)
Adam | 3/23/2019 2:49:50 PM
I wander what the Saudi royal family would say.
Gunrash | 3/24/2019 3:10:11 AM
Golan is Israeli just like Kirkuk, Amed, Mehabad and Afrin are Kurdish! Enough with the hypocrisy and selective indignation. UN is a joke.
Trump’s Golan statement draws strong regional condemnation
| yesterday at 08:49 | (4)
Adam | 3/23/2019 2:40:05 PM
Now the west especially America have the duty to reward the Kurds with real protection.
Kurde Canada | 3/24/2019 1:41:08 AM
God is no more with ISIS. They were just being used by him. They were betrayed.
SDF declare ‘total elimination’ of ISIS caliphate
| yesterday at 09:32 | (4)
TerraNova | 3/23/2019 10:02:06 PM
And now you show the world that The United States of America stands by it's allies and dose NOT abandon an ally that sacrificed thousands of brave...
Dutchman | 3/23/2019 11:18:00 PM
Trump is right when he sais that the US together with it's allies defeated ISIS. And it is also good that he wants to continue to work with his...
Trump: ISIS ‘are losers, will always be losers’
| 16 hours ago | (3)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

Mosul mourns victims of the ferry disaster 5 hours ago |

Mosul mourns victims of the ferry disaster

Grieving Mosul is not celebrating victory over more
Iraqi fishermen flounder on the Shatt al-Arab 15 hours ago |

Iraqi fishermen flounder on the Shatt al-Arab

Iran and Kuwait prevent them from fishing further more
Trump: ISIS ‘are losers, will always be losers’ 16 hours ago | (3)

Trump: ISIS ‘are losers, will always be losers’

"We will remain vigilant" more
0.375 seconds