Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Login

Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using
 

Email

 

Rudaw

Kurdistan

Iraq urged to join ICC to bring ISIS leaders to justice

By Judit Neurink 30/4/2015
Islamic State leader Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi delivering a sermon at a mosque in Iraq in July. AP file photo.
Islamic State leader Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi delivering a sermon at a mosque in Iraq in July. AP file photo.
ERBIL, Kurdistan Region – The United Nations, European Union and other global organizations are urging Iraq to join the International Criminal Court (ICC) so leaders of the Islamic State, or ISIS, can be prosecuted for crimes, rights abuse and murders.

Without joining the ICC, the organizations are concerned that ISIS leaders such as Abu Bakr al Baghdadi will never face international justice at The Hague, Netherlands.

“Without Iraq joining the ICC, Baghdadi cannot be tried there, as he is an Iraqi national,” said Balkees Jarrah, expert in international justice at Human Rights Watch.

The ICC tries perpetrators of war crimes and crimes against humanity, for example the major players in the conflicts in Rwanda and the former Yugoslavia.

Because both Syria and Iraq did not sign the Rome Statute, which is the foundation of the ICC, the court has no jurisdiction to handle the crimes ISIS committed in these countries.

“That is needed for the persecutor to be able to examine potential abuses there,” said Jarrah.

Neither countries seem eager to join the ICC, because as Jarrah put it: “It would be looking at crimes committed by all sides, not only by ISIS, but also the Syrian regime and other actors.”

That means even the Syrian president could be charged by the court. China and Russia last year blocked a resolution in the UN Security Council to refer the situation in Syria to the ICC. By doing so, they blocked the only possibility to involve the court in matters that concern countries that are not a member.

Yet as that veto only covered Syria, the Security Council could still be asked to refer the crimes in Iraq to The Hague.

Such a measure is what the Kurdistan Regional Government (KRG) is actively lobbying for. KRG officials are convinced the ISIS crimes against the Yezidi minority amount to genocide and a special Kurdish commission is already collecting and documenting the evidence needed to prove it.

“Anyone can forward information to the court’s persecutor, regardless of whether she has a mandate or not,” said Jarrah. This  means the special Kurdish High Commission for the Identification of Genocide Crimes can forward its findings to the ICC.

The same goes for the UN Human Rights Council in Geneva, which recently mandated a fact finding mission to examine the crimes committed in Iraq. In its report, the rights council called on the UN Security Council to give the ICC jurisdiction for these crimes, Jarrah said.

Even if Iraq joins the ICC, that does not guarantee the ISIS-leaders end up there. Because if national courts can persecute and try the perpetrators, the ICC does not even want to get involved.

“The ICC is a court of last resort and should only step in when national authorities are unable or unwilling to conduct the persecutions,” said Jarrah.

The fact the Iraqi government recently announced it would set up a special court to persecute ISIS crimes, could also block the Kurds who wish to get ISIS leaders tried at the ICC for genocide.

Former Iraqi president Saddam Hussein demanded to be tried by the ICC but was not because the new Iraqi government decided to set up a special court to do so itself. Yet this trial, ending with his execution in December 2006, was seen by many as not impartial or fair. This might convince the ICC that it now needs to play a role in the ISIS case.

An argument the KRG might use is presenting ISIS as a direct result of the sectarian policies of Baghdad towards the Sunni minority, and that this political situation cannot guarantee a fair trial against ISIS leaders.

Although Baghdadi escapes international prosecution for the moment, dozens of ISIS fighters and leaders are being tried by courts in their own countries after they return from Syria.

“Many of the fighters are dual nationals, and their countries can carry out investigations and persecutions for their crimes,” said Jarrah, pointing out they are mainly charged with membership in a terrorist organisation and, in some cases, tried for war crimes.

Some foreign ISIS fighters have even been charged in absentia while still serving with ISIS.

Such cases have been reported in most European countries, but Germany, which has over 700 nationals inside ISIS, is known to be the most active in prosecuting returnees from Syria.

While it is closed for Iraqis and Syrians, for those Europeans who played a major role in ISIS the door to the ICC is open, Jarrah said.

“The ICC would have jurisdiction over nationals of countries that are member of the court. If the fighter is British or German, the court has jurisdiction,” Jarrah said.

“[The ICC] would have to consider if the crimes are grave enough to merit the attention of the court, and also look if these individuals are the most responsible, and not just the foot soldiers.”

Comments

 
Eszpresszo | 30/4/2015
And just why does these Europeans think they are the only ones who can give a trial to the Daeesh? This is typical, flawed West European thinking, stuck on the notion that they have some kind of intellectual and moral superiority. What would trial in the Hague result in, other than a sentence in a comfortable European prison. Consider this: with food, clothing, climate-controlled shelter and medical treatment guaranteed, the convicted Daeesh would live better in prison than the refugees that they have sent fleeing their rampage. Iraq has shown it could give a fair trial to Saddam Hussein and punish him accordingly. I am sure the Kurds can deliver proper justice to these barbarians, if they choose to. However, I see no point in letting any of them live. These people came to deliver death and brutality. They deserve nothing less than what they imposed on their victims.
Whatever | 1/5/2015
Iraq can join the ICC only after Kurdistan Region becomes independent so that Baghdad does not send all the Kurdish leaders that it does not like to ICC on alleged crimes against humanity. Another regard in which Iraq cannot be trusted by the Kurds.
Ian Birmingham | 1/5/2015
The delivery of Daesh to ICC for trial is more about increasing the prestige and reputation of the ICC than anything else. While I agree that the ICC should be elevated in importance, this can be better done with cases other than Daesh. The Daesh terrorists should be brought before a military tribunal, duly convicted, and summarily executed using two bullets per head.
MF | 3/5/2015
And after the trial a slap on the wrist . Trials are no good unless severe punishment us meted out . The only punishment for IS is death.
10540 Views

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

me | 2/12/2019 12:16:30 PM
what jobs here pay 4500 usd a month !? that is 54 k annually!
SuperJC | 2/15/2019 6:38:20 AM
How this person becomes a poor guy even he's right skill in one of good industry....This poor guy got no brain in the first place and then mix-up the...
Venezuelan oil worker packs up for Kurdistan Region, better life
| 10/2/2019 | (11)
Hansi Oemeran | 1/30/2019 5:58:35 PM
Turkey has literally caused for this conflict to go astray. Now, tens if not hundreds of jihadist groups fighting for supremacy. This is going to...
Schools in Indonesia | 2/15/2019 6:29:49 AM
Syria has a strong diplomatic relationship with major superpowers, of which most of it are closest allies like Russia, Iran ,China, India ,...
Al-Qaida’s advance in northern Syria threatens fragile truce
| 30/1/2019 | (2)
John Bird | 2/15/2019 6:02:41 AM
The Islamic regime in Iran is having a taste of their own medicine. They brought terror and destruction to the region 40 years ago. Let them now...
United Nations encourages states to help Iran after terror attack killed 27
| 18 hours ago | (1)
Artush | 2/14/2019 10:34:43 PM
Its really sad and pity to see the russian flag along side the pirate turkish flag and mullah flag.
Israeli | 2/15/2019 5:21:56 AM
What a picture 3 criminals , 3 killers together .
Putin: Northern Syria must return to Damascus control
| yesterday at 07:03 | (7)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

KDP and PUK ‘meet in the middle’ after months of dispute, delay 11 hours ago |

KDP and PUK ‘meet in the middle’ after months of dispute, delay

"we solved what remained through consensus more
Officials address ‘increased’ drug use in Kurdistan Region 11 hours ago |

Officials address ‘increased’ drug use in Kurdistan Region

He blamed the increase on neighboring countries more
0.391 seconds