Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Login

Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using
 

Email

 

Rudaw

Iraq

The scale of Mosul operation presents challenges unlike previous battles with ISIS

By Paul Iddon 19/10/2016
Peshmerga forces on their way to the frontlines hours before the operation was launched. Photo: Rudaw video
Peshmerga forces on their way to the frontlines hours before the operation was launched. Photo: Rudaw video
ERBIL, Kurdistan Region – Forces liberating Mosul from Islamic State (ISIS) can expect the militant group to use many similar tactics they employed in Ramadi and Fallujah as the battle progresses, but the size of Mosul and the large civilian population will be serious complicating factors, analysts say. 

“The main difference with Mosul to the previous operations is scale,” Michael Knights, the Lafer Fellow for the Washington Institute for Near East Policy, told Rudaw English. “Mosul is 12 x 12 miles, Ramadi was 5 x 5, Tikrit was tiny, only 2 x 3 miles.” 

“Ramadi had a [population] of 300-490,000 maximum, Mosul was 1.4 million before 2014,” Knights added. “So this presents unique challenges for us taking the city, but even more challenges for ISIS to defend it.”  

Joel Wing, an Iraq analyst and author of the Musings on Iraq blog, echoed Knights when he pointed out that the “major difference” between Mosul and these two past operations was the size of the urban battlefield. 

Mosul “is a major metropolis compared to places like Tikrit, Ramadi and Fallujah,” Wing told Rudaw English. “That means it will take longer to seize it.”

Wing believes that the Fallujah operation earlier this year “provides a good model for how Mosul will go down.” 

“In Fallujah the Islamic State had tough outer defenses, but once those were broken the city fell rather quickly,” he explained. “That was because most of the population was still in the city and ISIS had its families and personnel there and therefore could not lay IEDs [improvised explosive devices] and such on the inside. Mosul is similar because it is the group's headquarters and has a large population.”

“Another similarity with Fallujah is the huge humanitarian disaster that ensued with displaced people and taking care of them, which will also play out in Mosul,” Wing added. 

Owen J. Daniels, the Assistant Director for the Middle East Peace and Security Initiative at the Atlantic Councils’ Brent Scowcroft Center on International Security, sees parallels with the recapture of Ramadi last December. 

“On the coalition side, we can expect some similarities to the Ramadi operation in both tactics and reliance on air power,” Daniels told Rudaw English. 

In Ramadi the elite Golden Division of the Iraqi Special Operations Forces (ISOF) spearheaded the ground assault into the city with close coalition air support, which reduced large swaths of it to rubble.  

“The coalition will plan to encircle and isolate Mosul through a pincer movement, with Kurdish Peshmerga forces approaching from the northwest and Iraqi Security and Special Forces approaching from the southeast. The international anti-ISIS coalition will provide air support through heavy bombing, as it did in Ramadi and Fallujah, to weaken ISIS as much as possible before ground forces move into the city. As a result, we can probably expect similarly high levels of destruction and damage to Mosul’s buildings and infrastructure,” Daniels explained. 

ISIS “has embedded itself deeply in Mosul, arguably deeper in Ramadi and Fallujah,” he added. “This means that the upcoming fight could leave the city in ruins. Mosul could resemble Fallujah in that ISIS’s defenses on the outskirts may give way to less-heavy interior defenses.” 

Daniels believes that in Mosul ISIS will consolidate their positions and slow down their enemies on the ground using booby traps and roadside bombs while using their tunnel networks “to flee or surprise coalition ground forces.” 
 
“Ramadi and Fallujah also demonstrated that the attackers who remained in those cities fought to the death, and often relied on car or suicide bombs when their situations became dire. We should expect the use of similar tactics in Mosul, plus new techniques they appear to be using like bomb-armed drones,” he explained.

The primary contrast Daniels sees is the broad number of forces fighting to retake Iraq’s second-city. 

“The coalition fighting force for Mosul is going to be quite broad, incorporating Iraqi Security and Special Forces, Kurdish Peshmerga fighters, Sunni tribal forces, and Shia militia groups,” he said. “The size of Mosul and sectarian diversity of the operation’s forces could see eventual success, but through fits and starts.”

Even though Shiite Hashd al-Shaabi militia forces and the Kurdish Peshmerga have agreed to remain on the outskirts of the city, “the involvement of so many actors threatens to make implementing the chain of command and post-conflict stabilization plans extremely difficult,” Daniels warned.

“The lack of a political agreement between all parties for post-conflict governance and repair of the city could prove a major point of tension in the immediate aftermath of the fight, and will test the strength of Iraq’s central government,” he concluded.

Comments

 
Excuses | 19/10/2016
Excuses for razing the city and cleaning up ethnic groups already prepared.
Sargon Nineveh
Sargon Nineveh | 20/10/2016
True. Mosul's liberation is being eyed closely by various foreign governments eager to change the demographics of Mosul post-ISIS (Turkey, Iran, KSA. etc). One thing is for sure, Mosul will always be a Sunni city, regardless of the ethnicities that live there. Aleppo, unfortunately, is on the way to becoming an Alawite-Shi'ite city if Assad and Khamenei have their way.
Brian | 21/10/2016
Kurdistan must be granted UN declared and US protected autonomy in all areas it has fought for. There would not be a Mosul liberation had it not been for Kurdi's hard-fought gains. Protection and autonomy must be the just reward!
6495 Views

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

Bart 56 | 11/19/2017 4:23:43 AM
Is Erdogen a sectarian, racist dictator?
Christian refugees in Lebanon want to return to Kurdistan
| 16/11/2017 | (1)
duroi | 11/13/2017 4:41:34 PM
It is heart breaking to lose your family and friends. Most of the 500+ victims were across the border in Iran and the city worst hit is SarPol Zahab...
IranMan | 11/19/2017 12:55:52 AM
Is it me, or others have also notice there is not ONE piece of "news" on rudaw.net telling us what the KRG administration, with its super rich...
Earthquake hits near Halabja, felt from Kurdistan to Kuwait, fatalities reported
| 12/11/2017 | (15)
Carlo | 11/18/2017 9:29:30 PM
US allies hates each other
Love Kurdistan | 11/18/2017 9:59:20 PM
Mr PM Barzani, make no more mistake. DO NOT COUNT ON AMERICANS ANYMORE. I would be considering of forming alliance with others as well. Be a smart...
Tillerson to PM Barzani: US encourages Baghdad to start serious talks with Erbil
| 18 hours ago | (3)
Stewee Guy
Stewee Guy | 11/18/2017 8:39:29 PM
Sad to see a full row of Kurdish women wearing ISIS hijabs.
Muraz Adzhoev | 11/18/2017 9:06:21 PM
The “transitional government” must be established in order to provide overwhelming unity only for the achievement of the main goal by implementation...
Kurdish Islamic party calls for establishment of transitional government
| 17 hours ago | (2)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

Iraqi gov’t considering changes to 2018 budget to do KRG “justice” 5 hours ago |

Iraqi gov’t considering changes to 2018 budget to do KRG “justice”

To fulfill justice, the Kurdistan Region’s share more
Hashd forces accused of Shiafication of Mosul's Christian towns 6 hours ago |

Hashd forces accused of Shiafication of Mosul's Christian towns

The Hashd al-Shaabi forces are systematically more
Kurdish Islamic party calls for establishment of transitional government 17 hours ago | (2)

Kurdish Islamic party calls for establishment of transitional government

KIU "found the formation of a transitional more
0.203 seconds