Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Login

Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using
 

Email

 

Rudaw

Analysis

Will Turkey go to Raqqa through Rojava?

By Paul Iddon 14/9/2016
Turkish soldiers cross into Syria near the border town of Karkamis. Photo: Bulent Kilic/AFP
Turkish soldiers cross into Syria near the border town of Karkamis. Photo: Bulent Kilic/AFP
Earlier this month Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan confirmed that talks are underway between the US and Turkey over taking military action against Islamic State (ISIS) militants in their Raqqa stronghold. Could Turkey realistically play a major role in capturing Raqqa from the militants?

What Turkey could do “will become more concrete after talks,” Erdogan said. “What can be done on the issue is related to the US stance.” 

His spokesperson, Ibrahim Kalin, said on Tuesday that Turkey does not yet have any plans to move against that city; it is focused on al-Bab for now. 

Nevertheless it is well worth pondering what Turkey can do militarily against ISIS in Raqqa, apart from contributing more jet fighters to the US-led counter-ISIS campaign, which has already been carrying out airstrikes against Raqqa for two years now. 

Since intervening militarily in northwestern Syria three weeks ago, Turkey has been targeting both ISIS and Syrian Kurdish forces on the west bank of the Euphrates River. Given Raqqa’s location eastward of that river, and southward of Syria’s northeastern PYD-controlled border, could the Turkish military possibly help capture Raqqa without rolling through Rojava (Syrian Kurdistan)?

Robert Lowe is deputy director of the Middle East Centre at the London School of Economics where his main research interest is in Kurdish movements in Syria. He told Rudaw English that Turkey could choose this course of action, but warned of its likely consequences.

“Turkey could choose to push deeper into Syrian territory to try to wipe out both ISIS and the Rojava project, but it would be massively risky,” Lowe said. 

“If the Turks decide to destroy Rojava they will likely face a difficult and drawn out struggle against the [Syrian Kurdish People’s Protection Units] YPG and the [Kurdistan Workers Party] PKK inside Syria and an escalation of the conflict with the PKK inside Turkey,” he explained.  

Such an intervention, he added, could see Turkey embroiled in a lengthy conflict on foreign soil which would “probably cause large scale displacement of the population of northern Syria.” 

“Such an operation would attract international condemnation because, while the removal of ISIS would be welcomed, there is a feeling that the PYD needs to be restrained rather than wiped out. I think the US would oppose Turkey marching through Rojava to attack Raqqa,” Lowe explained. 

“Good luck to the US if they’re trying to persuade Turkey and the YPG to stop confronting each other,” Lowe went on to remark. 

Lowe reckons that the Turks could find an alternative route to Raqqa that would lessen the risk of more direct clashes between them and the YPG.

“The Turks don’t need to go through Kurdish territory, I think they could head south from Jarablus and stay on the west bank of the Euphrates along Lake Assad to the Thawra dam and then go on to Raqqa,” Lowe explained. “The YPG seem to have pulled back from Manbij so they’re not in the way any more for this route.”

Since punching through Rojava could be a disastrous move for Turkey, it is worth contemplating if Ankara could reach some kind of an agreement with the PYD which would permit their soldiers and armor to cross through their territory. 

Back in February 2015, local authorities in Rojava, according to Idriss Nassan, a Syrian Kurdish official, allowed a large Turkish military force to cross their territory as part of their incursion to relocate the Suleyman Shah tomb, a Turkish exclave inside Syria, closer to the Turkish border. 

However, since that time the tentative ceasefire with the PKK has collapsed and clashes have escalated along the Syrian border between Turkish forces and the YPG. 

“I don’t see how a deal [for the Turks] to go through Rojava could work,” Lowe said. 

But, he added, “The Kurds might buy that they know they are weak and they don’t need a fight with the Turkish Army. But I doubt the Turks would go for it, they are too hostile to the PYD and they finally have their chance to hit them.”


Paul Iddon is a Rudaw reporter based in Erbil, Kurdistan Region.

Comments

 
Data pager
Previous
Page size:
PageSizeComboBox
select
WhatIfTheyUsePKKStrategies | 15/9/2016
Turks can follow the PKK strategy, instead of attacking YPG military targets head on. PKK has sabotaged power plants, water distribution centers, construction yards. The paradigm was 'making life as hard as possible' and incite a revolt feeling. Turkish army can easily destroy any power plant, water processing center, construction yards, roads. They can also place bombs on railroads, normal roads, booby trap the obstacles. Turkish Special Forces can carry out assassinations on teachers and public workers, shoot at ambulances. That is, they Turks want to use Kurdish strategies.
New Era | 15/9/2016
Turkey is desperate and frustrated. If Erdogan doesn't prevent the Rojava project , the fascists in his own country could cut his head off. But this is not Kurds business, they should focus on achieving their goals
dutchnational | 15/9/2016
For Turkey to punch through Rojava near Tell Abyad is, with losses, certainly possible. However, they would have a continous fight on their flanks while attacking IS, which is tactically unsound. Nothing would prevent the YPG to attack Turkey as retaliation and punch through the borderguard, which would be easy for them. Transfer some 10.000 fighters to the mountains of Turkey and Turkey would have a huge problem. It might cost them SE Turkey.
germiany | 15/9/2016
The Turkish army just had a few skirmishes with YPG north of Manbij when both the US and Russia warned Turkey to stop, imagine their reaction to a big incursion into Kobani or somewhere else in Rojava. It's not even sure if Turkey can pull it of, the YPG has enough manpads to wipe out hundreds of turkish tanks and helicopters, all they'll be left with is their fighter jets and you can't win anything with fighter jets alone. Also going around Rojava will be extremely difficult to pull off, for one it will be logistical neightmare, two neither Assad Russia or Iran will accept it so they'll be fighting on two fronts.
Muraz Adzhoev | 15/9/2016
It depends on terms and conditions that US will insistently recommend Turkey to accept, most likely, soon after the libaration of Mosul.

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

Adstar | 7/25/2017 3:38:26 AM
She made her own bed.. Now she can sleep in it.. You can be assured most Germans will not want her back.. They do not support the death penalty but...
green activist defector | 7/25/2017 12:22:14 PM
joshcka fischer the "green activist" and turkish lobbyist in berlin maybe can talk to his boss in ankara to solve this girls situation.
German girl who joined ISIS wants to leave Iraq, return to family
| yesterday at 11:45 | (10)
Gorran is betrayal | 7/25/2017 11:31:12 AM
Russia recognizes the right of the Kurds on indpendence , but Gorran denies the Kurds the right to hold the referendeum on independence.
kurd | 7/25/2017 11:33:27 AM
when he talks to turkish and iranian newspapers, he condemns kurdish independence. some of these comments show how many are naive
Sergey Lavrov to Rudaw: Referendum is expression of Kurdish people’s aspirations
| yesterday at 08:55 | (8)
Gorran is betrayal | 7/25/2017 11:22:49 AM
Gorran is treason , is anti-kurdish .
alan | 7/25/2017 11:29:41 AM
A new leader who is not family member of the former leader? If KDP or PUK gets a new leader he will be from the same family. Thanks we have Gorran...
New Gorran leader: We can achieve party’s objectives through dialogue
| 10 hours ago | (2)
Dana | 7/25/2017 10:47:59 AM
All that useless repetition of obvious information made the article horrible to read, not to mention that it missed the most important detail, which...
Al-Qaida in Syria close to snuffing out competition in north
| 16 hours ago | (1)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

NRT TV owner announces vote-no campaign for referendum 5 hours ago |

NRT TV owner announces vote-no campaign for referendum

He called referendum a “dangerous gamble with more
Kurdish official says US role essential in post-IS Syria 6 hours ago |

Kurdish official says US role essential in post-IS Syria

Americans " must continue until a democratic more
PM Abadi: I won’t deploy tanks to Kurdistan in response to referendum 7 hours ago |

PM Abadi: I won’t deploy tanks to Kurdistan in response to referendum

PM Abadi: “I mean, what I will do? Will I deploy more
0.313 seconds