Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Login

Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using
 

Email

 

Rudaw

Turkey

Turkey-Iran Energy Ties Outweigh Serious Differences Over Syria

By Alexandra Di Stefano Pironti 3/2/2014
Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan (R) with Iranian President Hassan Rouhani in Tehran last week. Photo: AFP
Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan (R) with Iranian President Hassan Rouhani in Tehran last week. Photo: AFP

BARCELONA, Spain – What was the message of Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan’s visit to Tehran last week?

It was this: Turkey is so determined to get the cheap oil and gas it needs to fuel its rise as a regional economic powerhouse that nothing will derail that goal, not even differences over Syria.

A report by Turkey’s Middle East Institute (MEI) released after Erdogan’s visit, and another by the Rand Corporation in the United States in September, both note that Iran and Turkey are pursuing a pragmatic foreign policy: Tehran needs a close, reliable market for its huge oil and gas reserves, and Turkey’s economic progress is tied to uninterrupted supplies of fuel.

“Iran is the second-largest supplier of natural gas to Turkey, behind Russia. Iran also provides close to 40 percent of Turkey’s imports for crude oil,” the Rand report says.

It notes that Ankara imports nearly 60 percent of its natural gas from Russia, and that Iran represents “one of the few alternatives available for reducing this dependence.”

“Turkey is an energy-hungry country and is planning to increase oil and gas imports from Tehran after the gradual lifting of sanctions,” says the MEI report, referring to the recent lifting of some economic sanctions against Iran following a deal with a US-led coalition over Tehran’s controversial nuclear program.

“Turkey uses a significant portion of its imported Iranian natural gas to generate electricity, and Iran is Turkey’s second-largest gas supplier, after Russia. Iran seeks a bigger share in Turkey’s energy market as well,” Gonul Tol, MEI’s Director of the Center for Turkish Studies, says in the report.

The Rand report, while noting that “Turkey and Iran tend to be rivals rather than close partners,” observes that “Turkish energy needs and Iran’s vast oil and natural gas resources have been an important driver of the increasing Turkish-Iranian cooperation.”

Access to cheap energy is so important to Ankara that, despite Western sanctions and the risks of investing in Iran, in November 2008 it began pursuing a deal to invest $5.5 billion to develop Iran’s offshore South Pars gas field, reportedly one of the biggest in the world.

“Interest in the agreement was rekindled during Erdogan’s visit to Tehran in October 2009, despite continued US objections,” the Rand report says. “Ankara argued that the deal was essential to meet its energy needs and that the agreement could help to bolster European energy security,” it notes.

The deal was finally shelved in July 2010, following US objections to the agreement, and after Tehran and Ankara failed to find common ground on the production and marketing of the gas.

Last week when Erdogan returned to Tehran, accompanying him were his ministers of economy and energy. Ankara has been reportedly demanding a discount from Iran on the price of natural gas, a request rekindled during  Erdogan’s visit.

The conflict in Syria -- important to Turkey because it is happening across its border and to Iran because Syria has for decades been Tehran’s staunchest Arab ally – was not the centerpiece of Erdogan’s visit.

By all accounts, the visit was a cordial one, filled with diplomatic niceties from both sides.

“The fact that Turkey and Iran have been backing opposing sides in the Syrian civil war has led to tensions in their relations, but neither country can afford a long-term fracture,” Tol noted in her report.

“Turkey recalibrated its Syria policy and is now more in tune with Iran,” she says. “Turkey and Iran see eye-to-eye regarding the end of the Syrian crisis, which has no military solution,” she adds.

Iran is not the only hurdle that Turkish leaders are determined to cross in pursuit of cheap and plentiful energy supplies.

Despite decades of hostility with its own large Kurdish minority, Ankara reversed its anti-Kurdish policy when last November it signed a comprehensive and controversial energy agreement with the autonomous Kurdistan Region in northern Iraq.

The deal, to import Kurdish oil through a pipeline extended by the Kurds to carry their own oil to the Turkish port of Ceyhan, upset both Baghdad and Washington.

“Ankara’s increasing energy cooperation with the Kurdistan Regional Government (KRG) has raised concerns in Washington and has put Ankara at odds with US policy,” the Rand report explains.

“The decision represents a significant reversal of previous Turkish policy, which had sought to prevent the KRG from obtaining direct control over the energy resources in the region, for fear that this would strengthen the KRG’s drive for the creation of an independent state,” the US study adds.

It warns that: “US officials should thus not expect Ankara automatically to fall in line with all US policy initiatives directed against Iran. Ankara will seek to retain a degree of flexibility regarding its policy toward Iran and may be hesitant to support some US initiatives if they are seen to conflict with broader Turkish national interests vis-à-vis Iran.”

Turkish Energy Minister Taner Yildiz spelled out his country’s policy as clearly as possible in an interview with Rudaw in December: “I would say frankly that Turkey will not sit idly about its nearby sources (of energy),” he declared.

Comments

 
Data pager
Previous
Page size:
PageSizeComboBox
select
Turkish Muslim | 3/2/2014
''Despite decades of hostility with its own large Kurdish minority, Ankara reversed its anti-Kurdish policy when last November it signed a comprehensive and controversial energy agreement with the autonomous Kurdistan Region in northern Iraq.'' This is a big mistake and absolutly not true. The fact that Turkey is changing it's politics is because the kemalist racist dictator regime is bankrupt. Kemalist generals are in prison and the Islam has taken over with democracy(majority of the votes). It is a fact that Kurdish muslims can work together with Turkey because Turkey is looking with a islamic eye view to the world. If Turkey had kemalist dictator generals still on power , then the support for norther Iraq/Kurdistan was 0,0%. And the war with the PKK would have go on and not stop like now. It is the Quran who brings us to the right path. That is the reason why we support our Muslim brothers. In this case , the Kurds in Turkey + norther Iraq/Kurdistan. When the kemalist where on power , Turkey didn't even bother looking to Muslim country's. But now we are looking to them and we support for example the Syrian rebels (FSA). If the kemalist alawite regime in Turkey was still on power , then they would have give support to Assad(alawite) and attack northern Iraq with war planes with the support of Maliki(shia).
FAUthman | 3/2/2014
Anyone that may say the old Safavid conflict would be rekindled between these two and does not adequately look at the economics of this relationship is way off the mark. If you are a supplier and the other guy is your consumer you are in bed together for life as long as you need each other. Suppliers among themselves become competitors but supplies and consumers become bedfellows, this should be a lesson for the Kurds to remember when it comes on how many eggs to place in which basket.
yek KRD | 3/2/2014
sorry but did i missed something? when did "Ankara reversed its anti-Kurdish policy"? rudaw stop making jokes...
Qaraman | 3/2/2014
Wait are these analysts implying a strategic deal between these two? anyone striking a strategic deal with Ankara must be deaf, dumb and blind, the Iranians are many things but dumb is not one of them. Two years ago Damascus was Erdogand "second home" now suddenly it's Tehran. Everyone knows that Tehran always chooses inferior allies but for long term, and they really do stick with their allies through thick and thin. Ankara is the opposite, they had no trouble turning their backs on their main Nato ally when the US needed them the most during second Gulf war, they had no problem provoking Israel until their relationship totally collapsed, and they had no second thoughts of stabbing Assad in the back when they saw an opportunity despite being as close as two countries can get. One minute they are massing their army on your border, the second minute they are your "lost brothers", then suddenly their army is back on your border again, they do this back and forth with everybody and can never be trusted on big issues or long term. Tehran is in the same position as KRG, they really don't have many options at the moment so of course they will do business with them, considering the circumstances it's good for both sides, and that's all it is, circumstance based.
Bakir Lashkari
Bakir Lashkari | 4/2/2014
Turkey is only taking care of it's own interest and protecting it's own border. The current ties between Turkey and Iran is a signal for the Kurdish leaders that everything is possible in political and conomical interests, therefore Turkey can very easily switch from it's now with Kurdistan to exchange it for Iran. Neither Turkey Nor Iran is happy what is improving and progressing in Kurdistan Region. they will allways staying the historical enemies of the Kurds next to the Arabs Iraqi governments, no matter Which type it is, wheather it is the Sunnis or Shiites or you can either be bited by the dog or by the cat, no differences can be considered! The Kurds should allways be very careful with three enemies which are surrounding the Kurdish borders, The Arabs, The Turkish and The Fars (Hajam). The key smart approach is, do not be too close them and not too far from them, but allways keep it up the right distances with our hostile enemies. I would rather make more Economic and Poilitical friendships also with the enemies of my enemies, they could be also my friends!
Tags :
6007 Views

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

FAUthman | 1/23/2017 2:14:51 AM
Barzani could be in constant communication with Tehran that we do not know aboout and relations are probably good. The visit will occur when it is...
Dar Zana | 1/23/2017 3:21:44 AM
I agree! we should maintain friendly relationship with Iran. If you can't beat them, might as well join them! Plus Kurds are one of the founding...
Why is Barzani not visiting Tehran?
| 19 hours ago | (4)
Hamid Sayadi | 1/23/2017 12:51:50 AM
referendum!,... referendum!.... referendum!...Is this a carrot stick in front of the hours hanging?! to run a schmuck on Kurdish population in the...
FAUthman | 1/23/2017 2:46:24 AM
Mr. Rubaie is not correct in his legal arguments. Kurds can negotiate with the representatives of the sovereign government of Iraq and that would be...
Iraqi MP: Baghdad does not have power to negotiate Kurdistan independence
| yesterday at 11:45 | (8)
Rojava | 1/22/2017 10:20:57 PM
The problem is: Is turkey and erdogan protecting western values Or Is erdogan protecting jihadi values. Mr Barzani has to understand that. The ...
Hamid Sayadi | 1/23/2017 12:57:43 AM
Too many Chiefs.... Not too many Indians{KURDS}! As saying go.
Syrian Kurdish faction likely to dispatch KRG-trained Peshmerga to Rojava
| yesterday at 08:49 | (13)
Alamgir | 1/22/2017 11:44:09 PM
@james come to Iran and we will show you what Iranians do to propel the threaten their safety. Russia intervened to that degree for Syria now think...
KURDISH STATE | 1/23/2017 12:17:39 AM
The message does not tell what is going to happen next. But it clearly indicates that something is about to happen. Why is the message then ?
Israeli PM Netanyahu addresses Iranian people, says he'll soon speak to Trump
| yesterday at 02:21 | (13)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

UPDATED: UN envoy to Syria meets with Kazakh FM ahead of Astana talks yesterday at 03:47 | (2)

UPDATED: UN envoy to Syria meets with Kazakh FM ahead of Astana talks

UN envoy told Rudaw they are "working hard", more
Iraqi MP: Baghdad does not have power to negotiate Kurdistan independence yesterday at 11:45 | (8)

Iraqi MP: Baghdad does not have power to negotiate Kurdistan independence

"It canot negotiate in this dangerous issue more
Syrian Kurdish faction likely to dispatch KRG-trained Peshmerga to Rojava yesterday at 08:49 | (13)

Syrian Kurdish faction likely to dispatch KRG-trained Peshmerga to Rojava

President Barzani hinted at the deployment last more
0.453 seconds