Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Login

Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using
 

Email

 

Rudaw

Opinion

Turkey, Land of Irony

By DAVID ROMANO 6/3/2014
column
column

The online Free Dictionary defines ‘irony’ as “The use of words to express something different from and often opposite to their literal meaning.”  The source adds that “Something is ironic if the result is the opposite of what was intended; an ironic event is an incongruous event, one at odds with what might have been expected.” The Meriam-Webster Dictionary offers two similar definitions of ‘irony’: “the use of words that mean the opposite of what you really think especially in order to be funny;” and “a situation that is strange or funny because things happen in a way that seems to be the opposite of what you expected.”

With my non-native proficiency in the language, I could not seem to think of a good Turkish equivalent for the concept of irony. I’m not sure if Kötü Tesadüf – literally “bad coincidence” – quite captures the idea. Alaylı might be another translation of ‘ironic,’ but the term as I understand it means something more akin to ‘mocking,’ ‘teasing’ or ‘sarcastic.’  Pulling out my thick Langenscheidt English-Turkish Dictionary, I found confirmation of Kötü Tesadüf and Alay as the definition of ‘irony,’ and also istihza – which I suspect is an Arabic origin word and is more often translated as ‘sarcasm’ or ‘mockery.’

I really did not expect Turkish to lack a real, authentically Turkic equivalent of the word ‘irony,’ whether in the English sense of the word or its old French and Latin origins (ironie and ironia).  Politics in the Turkish Republic involve more irony than anywhere else on earth I can think of.

We could start with the “Turkish” War of Independence, when Mustafa Kemal Ataturk rallied Muslim Ottomans to defend the Sultanate and Caliphate against Christian and Western powers. After winning the war, Ataturk went on to abolish the Sultanate and Caliphate and founded a secular republic that repressed public expressions of Islamic piety. He also aligned the new Turkey with the Christian West, holding yesterday’s European enemies up as the model that Turks should strive to emulate. Although the new republic was secular, most Christians were labeled “Greeks” even though they spoke Turkish and not Greek, and around a million and a half of them were deported to Greece. The irony of it all was quintessential, but not in any ‘mocking,’ ‘teasing’ or ‘sarcastic’ sense.

Soon after Turkey became an electoral democracy in 1950, the military stepped in to hang Adnan Menderes, the most popular freely elected Prime Minister Turkey had yet seen. Then the Turkish generals drew up a more liberal constitution that did more to protect individual freedoms and the democratic process, and promptly withdrew back to their barracks. By the late 1980s, Turkey was being described as the most democratic Muslim state in the region at the same time that it remained the most repressive country towards Kurdish identity, culture and language. Although Saddam, Assad and Khomeini were infinitely more authoritarian than any of their successive Turkish counterparts, they at least recognized and admitted the existence of a Kurdish people.

All of which brings us to today. A politician imprisoned for Islamist incitement in the late 1990s founds a new, moderate and avowedly secular Adalet ve Kalkınma Partisi (Justice and Development Party, or AK Party) in 2001. Campaigning on a platform of honesty and anti-corruption, in 2002 the one-year old party wins enough votes in the general elections to eclipse the older corrupt political parties and form a majority government on its own. The Islamist political prisoner of yesterday becomes Prime Minister and brandishes Turkey’s dream of joining the European Union to push through democratic reforms. The Americans embrace him and support him, and international business and investments flood in from all directions. Soon the former-Islamist-but-now-democracy-loving Prime Minister tames the Turkish military and dismantles the “deep state” apparatus truly running the country from the shadows.

Then, starting on December 17, Prime Minister and his AK Party (‘ak’ means ‘white’ or ‘clean’ in Turkish) find themselves embroiled in a huge corruption scandal. Cabinet ministers are forced to resign and their sons are imprisoned after shoe boxes containing tens of millions of dollars and euros are found in their homes and that of the president of Turkey’s state bank. Soon surreptitiously taped phone conversations between the Prime Minister and his son – during which the Prime Minister is heard to tell his son to hide all the money outside the home somewhere, and quickly – get leaked. The leak is thought to come from a unofficial movement of devout anti-Islamist Muslims whose followers hold many official positions in the police and judiciary in Turkey.

To safeguard the rule of law, the Prime Minister then dismisses thousands of prosecutors, judges and police officers – especially those involved in the corruption investigations. He appoints a new "deep state" to secure the new establishment. To protect democracy, he quickly passes laws to bring the judiciary and intelligence organizations directly under his government’s political control. To protect average citizens from the Internet and whatever may leak its way into that sordid realm, he pushes through a new censorship law. As the Prime Minister bravely fights on, he blames the United States, Europe, investors, international businesses and many other former friends for the whole conspiracy against him. Whereas in most countries electoral politics means that leaders must resign after evidence of serious corruption comes to light, this Prime Minister confidently announces that the voters (rather than the judiciary and police that he dismissed) will pronounce him ‘innocent’ in the upcoming elections.

Thinking about all this, I really could not believe that Turkish does not have a word for irony, at least in the sense that I use it here. So I went online to google translate, punched in the word ‘ironic,’ and clicked “translate to Turkish.” The screen flashed back the word 'ironik' at me.

David Romano has been a Rudaw columnist since August 2010. He is the Thomas G. Strong Professor of Middle East Politics at Missouri State University and author of The Kurdish Nationalist Movement (2006, Cambridge University Press).

Comments

 
Simko | 6/3/2014
Let's say Turkey is the state of irony.The political life in Turkey is,in fact,permeated with a blend of irony and cynism.Unfortunately the Turks are not worse than their Western or Eastern partners when it comes to deal with the Kurdish problem.
Qaraman | 6/3/2014
Here is an even better irony, long before all this Roj TV was reporting on corruption, severe human right violations in Turkey like the use of indiscriminate force by police, the horrible state of Turkey judiciary where "evidence" are produced for each case, and many many other issues. Essentially the exact same things every one now is saying, for this and brodcasting in Kurdish Roj TV was branded "terrorist mouth piece", banned and shut down in Europe, now that's irony! Denmark and many other European countries made a deal with the corrupt Islamist Erdogan and shut down a secular TV channel that dared to shed light on the ugly side of their NATO ally Turkey.
Dan Rom | 6/3/2014
Maybe it is the lack of a proper native term for the word "ironic" that leaves the Turkish people so vulnerable to such overt ironies. Like a virus spreading through a population with natural immunity, politically ironic and very grievous behaviour is difficult to defend against because the people have no conception of how atrocious the disconnect is between what is said and what is done.
Herdem Kurdman | 6/3/2014
The modern turkish republic or the republic of turkey is a product of British humour.
Tags :
6911 Views

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

me | 2/12/2019 12:16:30 PM
what jobs here pay 4500 usd a month !? that is 54 k annually!
SuperJC | 2/15/2019 6:38:20 AM
How this person becomes a poor guy even he's right skill in one of good industry....This poor guy got no brain in the first place and then mix-up the...
Venezuelan oil worker packs up for Kurdistan Region, better life
| 10/2/2019 | (11)
Hansi Oemeran | 1/30/2019 5:58:35 PM
Turkey has literally caused for this conflict to go astray. Now, tens if not hundreds of jihadist groups fighting for supremacy. This is going to...
Schools in Indonesia | 2/15/2019 6:29:49 AM
Syria has a strong diplomatic relationship with major superpowers, of which most of it are closest allies like Russia, Iran ,China, India ,...
Al-Qaida’s advance in northern Syria threatens fragile truce
| 30/1/2019 | (2)
John Bird | 2/15/2019 6:02:41 AM
The Islamic regime in Iran is having a taste of their own medicine. They brought terror and destruction to the region 40 years ago. Let them now...
United Nations encourages states to help Iran after terror attack killed 27
| 18 hours ago | (1)
Artush | 2/14/2019 10:34:43 PM
Its really sad and pity to see the russian flag along side the pirate turkish flag and mullah flag.
Israeli | 2/15/2019 5:21:56 AM
What a picture 3 criminals , 3 killers together .
Putin: Northern Syria must return to Damascus control
| yesterday at 07:03 | (7)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

KDP and PUK ‘meet in the middle’ after months of dispute, delay 11 hours ago |

KDP and PUK ‘meet in the middle’ after months of dispute, delay

"we solved what remained through consensus more
Officials address ‘increased’ drug use in Kurdistan Region 11 hours ago |

Officials address ‘increased’ drug use in Kurdistan Region

He blamed the increase on neighboring countries more
0.375 seconds