Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment


Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using





With enemies like theirs, do the Kurds need more friends?

By Arnab Neil Sengupta 9/1/2019
Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF) fighter in Hajin, Deir ez-Zor province, eastern Syria, December 15, 2018. File photo: AFP
Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF) fighter in Hajin, Deir ez-Zor province, eastern Syria, December 15, 2018. File photo: AFP
Rather than despair over the fickle nature of American political and military support, the Kurds of the Middle East should try to look on the bright side: their regional foes probably inspire far too much fear and loathing in Washington to outwit the Kurds in the foreseeable future.

Without Turkey, Iran, Syria, and Russia’s hasty endorsement of President Donald Trump’s shock military withdrawal announcement on December 19, critics of the move would have had to strive harder to prove it amounted to a brazen betrayal of a battle-tested ally and a blow to the West’s security interests and, therefore, deserved to be shelved indefinitely.

It would be churlish to deny Recep Tayyip Erdogan credit for having the presence of mind to win Trump over to his side in the course of one phone call, which had reportedly been arranged for Trump to get his Turkish counterpart to back off and stop threatening to attack the Western-backed Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF) in northeastern Syria.

But if Erdogan’s soothing words seemed to settle the dispute over continued US support for the Kurds of Syria in the fight against ISIS, his overenthusiastic backing for Trump’s unilateral withdrawal decision has contributed to its reopening.

At the same time, Turkey’s hyper-patriotic cabinet ministers got one up on their boss by sending gratuitously cruel messages to the Kurdish fighters who form the bulk of the SDF bravely battling ISIS in northeastern Syria.

Hulusi Akar, the Turkish defence minister, cemented his place in the book of follies by saying Kurdish militants east of the Euphrates in Syria “will be buried in their ditches when the time comes”. The rhetoric might have been ramped up for effect, but it served to expose Turkey’s true intentions dressed up as a mission to take over the international coalition’s fight to defeat ISIS.

Mevlut Cavusoglu, Turkey’s foreign minister, unwittingly did his bit to galvanize American support for the SDF by saying Turkish forces were determined to cross the Euphrates River into Kurdish-held territory in Syria as soon as possible, and urging France to remove its forces from northeastern Syria now that an American withdrawal was a done deal. What was perhaps intended to score political points at home now looks in hindsight like a classic case of jumping the gun.

Turkey's triumphalism proved to be infectious. The Syrian government scored an own-goal by allowing its army to claim it had entered the SDF-controlled part of Manbij for the first time in six years and raised a flag there. An unintended consequence of the televised statement by a spokesman that the troops were in the northern Syrian city to “crush terrorism and defeat all invaders and occupiers” was to set alarm bells ringing in Washington – if not inside the White House.

Although Syrian government officials were careful to avoid the hyperbole of their Turkish counterparts that would have generated more international opprobrium, its military's reaction clearly smacked of premature schadenfreude. Whatever the mood now in Damascus, until the Kurdish-led Syrian Democratic Council (SDC) formally announces it has reached an agreement with Bashar al-Assad’s government, forecasts of an easy victory for Syrian forces over their rivals could very well remain just that.

The satisfaction expressed by Assad’s allies in Tehran with Trump’s planned military pullout was a dead giveaway that they too were counting on a rapid reversal of fortune. “From the start, the entry and presence of American forces in the region has been a mistake, illogical and a source of tension, and a main cause of instability,” an Iranian foreign ministry spokesman was quoted as saying by state media. The reaction was not surprising given there’s little love lost between Iran and Kurds in general and its own Kurdish population in particular.

By some accounts, Iran’s “deep state” stood to gain the most from Trump’s move, which would have helped it gain full control over a strategic arc of the Levant. A flipside of the withdrawal would have been the likely unraveling of Trump’s policy of exerting “maximum pressure” on Iran, after his administration had withdrawn from the 2015 multilateral nuclear deal and reinstated economic sanctions. But with Iran hawks such as John Bolton, the national security adviser, and Mike Pompeo, the secretary of state, appearing to have put the Syria withdrawal plan into a deep freeze, the depth of Tehran’s disappointment can scarcely be overestimated.

Unlike the others, Russian President Vladimir Putin probably had a sense that Trump’s pullout plan sounded too good to be true. Reacting with guarded optimism, he said “if the decision to withdraw was made, then it is a correct one”, adding that “as for defeating ISIS, I do generally agree with the President of the United States”. Sergei Lavrov, the Russian foreign minister, also voiced skepticism about the announced withdrawal, lamenting “the Americans don’t always do what they promise, far from it”.

Even so, Russia could not resist the urge to announce a three-way summit with Turkey and Iran on the Syrian conflict, while a Kremlin spokesman wasted no time welcoming the reported entry of Syrian forces into Manbij, saying: “Of course, this will help in stabilizing the situation. The enlargement of the zone under the control of government forces ... is without doubt a positive trend.” In retrospect, even the Russians had got ahead of themselves in lauding Trump’s impulsive diplomacy without realizing the pitfalls.

As long as the Turks are busy defending themselves against accusations of harboring plans for “slaughtering Kurds”, they are unlikely to make much headway in shaping Western public opinion in their favor. And with so few leading lights of the US foreign policy establishment willing to cut even a NATO ally some slack, the chances of a breakthrough are practically non-existent for the likes of Iran, Russia, and Syria.

By contrast, despite the perils of Trump's erratic leadership and the loss of two staunch allies in Washington – Pentagon chief Jim Mattis and the US envoy to the global coalition fighting ISIS, Brett McGurk – Syria’s Kurds and their Arab allies continue to have the unalloyed respect, gratitude, and admiration of members on both sides of the aisle. The Kurds like to say they have no friends but the mountains. But with enemies like theirs, who needs more friends?

Arnab Neil Sengupta is an independent journalist and commentator on the Middle East.

The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the position of Rudaw.


Data pager
Page size:
Arab | 9/1/2019
The terrorist state of Turkey is under illusion , they really think they could deny 45-50 million KUrds their right and freedom , no force on earth can make the kurds give up their right and their freedom
As it happened | 9/1/2019
Here is how it has happened :During the infamous phone of last December 14 th., Erdogan has bullied Trump, he has insulted him, humiliated him and threatened him with war if he did not withdraw his troops. So, Trump was shocked and got scared of the Turkish bloody despot, and out of fear he was quick to tweet his withdrawal announcement without consulting his close aides. As you see it was not an American decission, it was indeed a cowardly announcement of an order given by Erdogan for American troops to surrender and withdraw. It was a personal affair between the two presidents with the Turkish despot smashing the American president who frightened has surrendered to the Turkish thug.
European security | 9/1/2019
Trump will sow chaos in the world and will provoke the fall of the western security . Turkey will invade Greek and other European lands. Merkel behaves realy scared whenever she meets Erdogan. Theresa May, very submissive, behaves more thuggish, immoral and more depraved than the Turkish sultan when she meets him. Macron sometimes voices some opposition but his Western allies prefer to surrender to Erdogan.
OP | 9/1/2019
What's the author saying exactly? it would be better if these despotic brutal regimes who oppress Kurds, do in a way that didn't attract so much attention? slaughter Kurds silently like the good old days? and with friends and supportes like these Kurds don't need enemies either
Qom | 9/1/2019
The threats and hate rhetoric against Kurds wasn't for "domestic consumption". The Turkish regime was only honest of their intention of ethnically cleansing the entire birder region with Syria of Kurds and relocating the 4 million Sunni's there. That's exactly what they did when they invaded Afrin.
Tags :

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

Rebwar | 3/20/2019 3:31:33 PM
Lol this kardogan lost it ahahah everything just to stay relevant. I have a bad news for u mr. KARdogan your time is soon to be up and done. And 1...
Leon | 3/21/2019 1:45:34 AM
Phobia is the irrational fear of something. Islamophobia is an oxymoron since there is no irrational fear about Islam, the fear is real. Islam calls...
Erdogan again airs attack video at rally despite criticism
| yesterday at 09:56 | (7)
guest2002 | 3/21/2019 1:30:04 AM
Yezidis have every right to have their own forces to protect them. We all clearly remember r The Iraqi army running away followed by KDP Peshmarga...
Iraqi skirmishes with YBS now ‘under control’ in Shingal: PM Abdul-Mahdi
| yesterday at 12:55 | (1)
Muraz Adzhoev | 3/20/2019 9:12:34 PM
NEWROZ PIROZ BE! But unfortunately fireworks were not set off and the Kurdish national flag was not risen in all areas of Southern Kurdistan,...
Newroz piroze! Fireworks fill Erbil’s sky for the new year
| 16 hours ago | (1)
John Bird | 3/20/2019 6:29:26 PM
So how come the Shia regime did manage to restore the shrine of Imam Hussein’s daughter in Sinjar, but ignored the rest of Mosul Plain? No doubt that...
Political rivalry bigger threat to Mosul than ISIS
| 20 hours ago | (1)
0.219 seconds