Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Login

Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using
 

Email

 

Rudaw

Opinion

Rojava: Let Rudaw In

By Paul Iddon 10/8/2015
-
-

The Middle East has a particularly peculiar history when it comes to the banning of media outlets. The BBC for example earned the consternation and fear in Iran of both the last Shah's regime and the current Islamic Republic regime alike. The former attributed great powers to it given its small role in the 1953 Anglo-American coup against the famous Iranian Prime Minister Mohammed Mossadeq. It was even suggested by some Iranian air force generals to the Shah after the revolution got underway in 1979 that they could take out the BBC's relay towers in order to stop that media outlet from continuing to broadcast in Iran. That proposal was turned down, but it nevertheless aptly demonstrated their conspiratorial fear of the power that news agency seemingly possessed.

The present authorities also see it as amounting to little more than a nefarious propaganda outlet.

Similarly the Al Jazeera network is often viewed as a troublemaking broadcaster by many authorities and governments in the region. The Americans disliked it for its coverage of the Iraq War and the Saudi and Egyptian regimes dislike it for what they perceive to be its support for the Muslim Brotherhood organization.

It's also worth noting that the mouthpiece of the Iranian regime, Press TV, can send its correspondents to report in Israel, a country whose existence it bitterly, and routinely, denounces as an illegitimate and irrevocable enemy. Would we think less of Israeli democracy if they didn't let Press TV journalists in to report on Israeli affairs?

Of course we would. And quite rightfully so, too.

Freedom of speech means you permit unpopular and/or controversial things to be said. You don't muzzle the press. Even if some outlets in the press you find to be, biased, beneath contempt or overly ideological.

Recently journalists working for the Erbil-based Rudaw news agency were banned from covering events in Syria Kurdistan (Rojava) for allegedly being anti-PKK. Which is ironic considering the fact that Rudaw's website was also filtered recently in Turkey who accuse it of being pro-PKK. Being accused of polar opposite ideological and/or political leanings in such a way show how ridiculous the pretexts given for censorship invariably are.

It upset me to see Rojava ban Rudaw. Yes Rojava is enduring some very tough times now. Combating the threat posed Islamic State (ISIS) has seen to most of the society being mobilized in order to fight in defense of their homes and their territory. And of course they want to convey a favourable and sympathetic impression to the world of their plight and their efforts to erect a durable autonomous polity.

Keeping Rudaw out, unfortunately, is a regressive step for them to take. At such a critical juncture it is transparency that will give Rojava greater legitimacy. Even if complete transparency does result in the showcasing of the nastier sides of this war. Transparency however, especially at a time of war, will unequivocally demonstrate Rojava's confidence in the form of democracy and society it claims to be successfully spearheading in that part of Syria.

By disallowing Rudaw journalists entry into Rojava the authorities there are in turn denying a whole window and perspective on the many important unfolding events there. Instead of banning the media – or only selectively allowing in those who they think will report positively and uncritically about the situation and the conduct of the authorities there – Rojava should permit journalists from a whole range of agencies to cover and report on their situation. Even if journalists do shine a light on the struggles, sufferings and general travails of ordinary civilians in Rojava their presence will still lend credibility to the efforts of the authorities to establish an open and democratic system in Rojava. Freedom of the press is always one important indicator of how democratized and open a society truly is.

Rojava should reverse its decision to ban Rudaw journalists. They should lift the ban and permit them entry and as much access as possible. In doing so they will be priding themselves on the fact that however tough things may be at this point in time, they are fighting for a free and open society. The very thing that Daesh thoroughly detests and seeks to eradicate.

Paul Iddon is a freelance journalist and political writer who writes on Middle East affairs, politics, developments and history.

The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the position of Rudaw.

Comments

 
Data pager
Previous
12
Page size:
PageSizeComboBox
select
ITALIAN OBSERVATORY | 10/8/2015
The article is well written.The PKK is not Kurdish,it is largely infiltrated and manipulated by Turkey and its mission is to provide Turkey with the necessary pretext to kill Kurds at will.Sometimes Turkey iduces PKK to performe small violent acts against Turkey with the only purpose to justify disproportionate killing campaigns that Turkey launch against the Kurdish people.PKK ,like Turkey,is against everything Kurdish; and RUDAW is Kurdish,what the PKK is not.
Kurdish Freedom | 10/8/2015
Were do people get this stupid things from? PKK being run by Iran, Turkey or some other kurdish enemy. Nobody says a thing about KRG being influensed by neighboring nations. What about KDP being close to Turkey and PUK being Close to Iran? PKK is not perfect, and has done many misstakes but they are more kurdish than any other party.
Ozgun Akkaya
Ozgun Akkaya | 17/8/2015
I'm curious as to why us Kurds are trying to divide ourselves. The PKK is very Kurdish, as they've made the most developments for Kurdish rights in Turkey, created the KCK and Ocalan's canton model is by far the most brotherly form of democracy in the world. Everyone looks up to PYD for their ethnic, religious and gender tolerance. I think it's fair to ban any news outlet from Rojava currently as media has a habit of reporting sensitive material like troop positions, ammunition supply and morale for the sake of news. Several times Rojava has asked the news outlets to stop reporting these and focus on less sensitive material but it was ignored. If you don't believe me, look at the news from Kobane and Tel Abyad.
Truth | 18/8/2015
pkk sets up roadblocks in bakur and makes life very difficult for kurds. Yesterday PKK killed a bus driver (in Van I think). The bus full of people was driving on the road then the driver noticed the pkk roadblock so he made a u-turn (why would anyone drive straight into a roadblock with armed, masked men?) So the PKK opened fire and killed him. some passengers drove the bus to safety. do you think people like the pkk care 1% about democracy? Its ONLY about personal power
Rodi | 18/8/2015
pkk is owned & operated by Iran. Remember demirtas going on hezbollah-tv al manar and praising the 'axis of resistance'!! Remember hezbollah mullah getting anxious when pkk got bombed?? Ye, I remember.
Tags :
5282 Views

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

pedo | 6/23/2018 4:02:18 AM
thanks
Registration opens for party alliances in KRG elections
| 18/6/2018 | (1)
not armed! | 6/18/2018 9:31:36 PM
I suppose KRG will be happy to take up arms against the Kurdish freedom fighters to protect Iran? Brilliant!!!!!
OneNation | 6/22/2018 11:42:26 PM
Kick them out KRG, bunch of grandpa led communist terrorists. Iran will not tolerate tribalists, racists and children of landowners/khans b...
KRG won’t let armed parties harm ties with Tehran: spokesperson
| 17/6/2018 | (2)
Mehdi giudarzi | 6/22/2018 7:38:35 PM
Ok
To many trolls | 6/22/2018 9:04:13 PM
As usual no shortages of Turkish and Iranian trolls here, most times they post under Kurdish sounding names lashing out at the US Israel etc. other...
World Cup 2018: Who is Iran’s Kurdish goalkeeper?
| yesterday at 10:07 | (10)
Frank | 6/22/2018 10:40:20 AM
No up until now the US has upheld all it's commentment to the Kurds of Rojava, they defused the situation in Manbij and prevented a Turkish assault...
US Patriot for Kurdistan | 6/22/2018 2:08:07 PM
Sorry, the US never had a presence in Afrin and they never promised the Kurds in Afrin that they would come there to provide help in any way,...
We are staying in Manbij: US general
| yesterday at 07:03 | (6)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

Iran at OPEC: Kirkuk pipeline would increase current oil exports 10-fold 9 hours ago |

Iran at OPEC: Kirkuk pipeline would increase current oil exports 10-fold

we need to increase the level of this swap more
Coalition drops leaflets of ISIS leaders over eastern Syria: monitor 9 hours ago |

Coalition drops leaflets of ISIS leaders over eastern Syria: monitor

"We are in al-Zibah village at the moment more
Burned Kurdish schoolgirls to appeal to President Rouhani for care abroad 11 hours ago |

Burned Kurdish schoolgirls to appeal to President Rouhani for care abroad

Thirty-seven of the girls were injured more
0.234 seconds