Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment


Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using





Kurds and the equity of land swaps in Iraq and Syria

By Paul Iddon 12/1/2016
Kurdish Peshmerha south of Kirkuk.Photo: Rudaw
Kurdish Peshmerha south of Kirkuk.Photo: Rudaw
The Kurds of Iraq have from time to time being accused of demarcating de-facto borders for a future independent state by digging trenches on their front-lines against Islamic State (ISIS) terrorists. Some of these trenches extend over territories that were once considered disputed between the Kurdistan Region and Iraq. However they are a sure and practical way of preventing those same territories from falling into the hands of ISIS which would be bad for both Baghdad and Erbil for obvious reasons.

Ethno-sectarian fissures are ripping both Iraq and Syria to shreds and clearly the current configurations are no longer practical. Even if the Kurdistan Region remains part of a federal Iraq it must be recognized, and appreciated, that its population has increased massively as a result of the war against ISIS. Since June 2014 it has taken in nearly two million outsiders and has become what will likely amount to the permanent home for Kurds who previously lived outside of the autonomous region as well as Iraq’s remaining Christians, especially those who fled Nineveh. Remember ISIS has essentially cleansed Mosul of its non-Sunni Arab minorities, including Kurds.

 Over half-a-million of that cities minorities have fled, many seeking sanctuary in the Kurdistan Region. In recognition of this reality the Kurdistan Region should therefore be given sovereignty over swaths of the Nineveh plains, Kirkuk province and other areas that are disputed as part of a land swap undertaken in recognition of these new realities and the extremely low possibility that Mosul’s minorities will ever return to their former homes.

In neighbouring Syrian Kurdistan (Rojava) the necessity of land swaps is even greater. Until June 2015 Rojava was divided into three cantons until the two major ones, Kobani and Jazira, were connected through the border city of Gire Spi (Tal Abyad). The westernmost canton of Afrin is completely cut off from Kobani-Jazira by the 68-mile stretch of territory that is the Jarablus-Azaz line, swaths of which are occupied by dangerous Islamists like ISIS and Jabhat al-Nusra. Turkey objects to Kobani linking-up with Afrin along its border since it doesn’t believe that the Kurds can administrate a territory consisting of up to half-a-million non-Kurds. Which is a fair point.

 Nevertheless Syria’s Kurds should be permitted some kind of land corridor that would make their territories loosely contiguous and enable them to travel freely from Afrin to Kobani-Jazira. Have no doubt: Kurds in Aleppo’s Sheikh Maqsood neighbourhood may well have to relocate, abandon their homes, like the Kurds of Mosul and Gire Spi, and what little is left of their lives there and go to either Afrin or Kobani.

Afrin’s villages are currently being bombarded by Nusra terrorists and Kurdish fighters from elsewhere in Syrian Kurdistan are unable to go there to reinforce them and protect their civilians. Such a situation is untenable and urgently needs to be rectified.

A land corridor stretching from the south of the Jarablus-Azaz line in mostly unpopulated areas would not see the Syrian-Turkish border dominated by the Syrian Kurdish Peoples Protection Units (YPG) group. On the contrary. Even in Gire Spi the Syrian Kurds have delegated authority to an autonomous administration in recognition of the areas multi-ethnic composition.

All they need is to travel freely and safely between their communities. And since the disintegration of the Syrian state makes that scenario currently impossible they should be permitted to broker deals with those who reside in the territories which divide their territories. These divisions were a result of ethnic cleansing and brutal Arabization programs carried out by the Syrian Baath Party since the 1960’s in ways reminiscent to how the Iraqi Baath sought to Arabize Kirkuk.

Kurds should be permitted to at least partially rectify these grave historic injustices and be allowed the freedom of movement on their own homeland. Given that is no longer safe nor possible in the current conditions new conditions urgently need to be created. The United Nations and the world community should therefore, as part of their broader efforts to end the conflicts in Iraq and Syria, dedicate resources towards solving these unjust and untenable status quos before they lead to yet more inevitable strife and bloodshed. 

Paul Iddon is a Rudaw reporter based in Erbil, Kurdistan Region.
The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the position of Rudaw.


Data pager
Page size:
dutchnational | 12/1/2016
This sounds reasonable and some of the corridor is already inhabited by kurds
Carl | 12/1/2016
Most of these Iraqis and Syrians don't mind fleeing to Kurdistan for safety and even to settle in the tens of thousands, but they don't want Kurds to hold on to parts of their own land. Equally we never hear any objection from any about the demographic changes and ethnic cleansing done against Kurds in areas outside Kurdish controlled areas such as Mosul Salahdin Aleppo etc etc. tens if thousands of Kurds have been
sidney | 12/1/2016
The Syrain Kurds should be left alone, and not at any time interfeared with by the KRG. As for Nnewa, do the deals you always do with corrupt Nujafis
qalla | 12/1/2016
Wow someone mentioning the forcefully displaced Kurds in Iraq and Syria, a fact never mentioned or talked about. Most Arab majority provinces in Iraq and Syria are completely ethnically cleansed of Kurds, we're talking about many thousand families. The new Kurdish borders must not only be drawn along Kurdish land like now, they must allocate land for all those displaced Kurds and the 2 million refugees we've taken in.
Dryasiulia | 12/1/2016
If I had to choose I certainly would choose even the PKK over Daesh and I do not politically agree with PKK. PKK certainly would be far far safer even though they are politically wrong. I'd certainly remind them at every opportunity, (when they were in a good mood of course).
Tags : Kurdistan, Kurd, ISIS

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

Guest | 10/16/2018 5:19:46 PM
I agree with you Mr. Romano. Except, I don't think Turkey is an emerging threat, it's conversion to a totalitarian style government along with its...
Masque du Furet | 10/17/2018 4:54:08 AM
Well, as hostage diplomacy seems efficient, it is time for Tutkey to find new hostages (mormons, popists might be interesting). OTOH, if US do not...
Time for US to reassess Turkey's support for extremists
| yesterday at 10:22 | (5)
Baban | 10/16/2018 8:47:00 PM
A cruical milestone in the history of our homelands, a beautiful insight in the work of uncovering important artifacts that i hope will take shape...
haluk | 10/17/2018 4:53:04 AM
Around 1200 BC, different factors such as climate change, volcano eruptions, earthquakes and large scale migrations (the mysterious "sea people")...
Ancient lost city of Mardaman slowly gives up its secrets
| yesterday at 07:13 | (2)
Kdp sold kirkuk | 10/17/2018 3:28:43 AM
Both sold kirkuk. Kurdistan will never be indipendent with kdp puk. Why kdp join iraq govermentare they not against iraq or are they just liars?
Shawn | 10/17/2018 4:21:31 AM
This PUK guy is blaming KDP for the mess the KirKuk in!!! Are you kidding. This PUK dude needs to get his head out his rear and shut the F****k...
KDP, PUK in row over Kirkuk governorship
| yesterday at 08:05 | (8)
Y. A. | 10/16/2018 11:28:54 PM
May Allah Khode help The Kurds and make their enemies taste occupation so they would feel it as they have made the Kurds feel it
Kawan | 10/17/2018 1:44:33 AM
A dark day in kurdish history
The fall of Kirkuk: Flashbacks of October 16
| yesterday at 12:00 | (10)
5.093 seconds