Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment


Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using





What makes a Jewish woman fight for the Kurds?

By Benjamin Kweskin 15/11/2014

No one except Gillian Rosenberg knows her true motivations for allegedly traveling from her adopted home in Israel to join the Kurdish Women's Protection Units (YPJ) in Syrian Kurdistan (Rojava).

In an Israel Radio interview, she said she had flown to the Jordanian capital of Amman and then to Erbil in the Kurdistan Region, before joining people she had been in contact with over social media and making her way to a training camp in Syria. 

Speaking in the interview in fluent Hebrew a few days ago, she claimed she was a mere “3,000 meters from Da'esh,” referring to the Islamic State (ISIS) terrorists who have inflicted fear and unbridled violence upon their victims in Syria and Iraq alike. 

Several former American and European soldiers -- and even bikers -- have joined the Syrian Kurdish fighters in Rojava or Peshmerga forces in Iraq’s Kurdistan Region. But if Rosenberg’s claim of joining the YPJ is true, this is the first time a foreign-born non-Kurdish woman has joined either of the two forces.

What makes this unfolding story additionally unique is that she is a Canadian, and a self-identifying Orthodox Israeli Jew who served in the Israel Defense Forces (IDF), trained in search and rescue missions. As Israel does not maintain diplomatic relations with Syria or Iraq, upon her assumed return it is expected she will be arrested for entering two states technically at war with the Jewish state. If that happens, it would not be Rosenberg’s first brush with the law: she was arrested in 2009 and extradited to the United States, where she was reportedly jailed over a phone scam. 

For most people there is no logical leap between serving in the IDF and then joining the Syrian-Kurdish force, known for its avowed stance supporting secular ideals and gender equality, in addition to being recognized as a bulwark against ISIS.

In recent days the Democratic Union Party (PYD), the political wing of the YPJ and its male counterpart the People’s Protection Units (YPG), outlawed polygamy and mandated that women need to be 18 years old in order to marry within the three cantons it controls in Syria. That is a far cry from their ISIS and Islamist-allied enemies, who have sold enslaved women and used them as sexual objects. 

Though these platforms may be appealing to many, it still does not explain what would possess an Israeli to physically put her own life in danger and fight alongside Kurds. Yet, there are several aspects that would appeal to Americans, Canadians, or Israelis who support Kurdish objectives in both Syria ad Iraq.

There is a long, shared history between both oppressed and persecuted peoples. Ms. Rosenberg herself is quoted as saying: “Kurds are our brothers. They are good people. They love life, a lot like us, really.”

Perhaps she learned that those same individuals and states that seek the destruction of Israel and the Jewish people also seek the destruction of Kurdistan and the Kurdish people. Both historically oppressed minorities have struggled for survival for centuries and closely share the same cultural values, which strongly emphasize family, community and education. As these groups became assimilated and exposed to the outside world, these values became inclusive of secularism and progressive ideals. 

While some are content with the premise that “the enemy of my enemy is my friend,” there are deeper and longer-lasting ties between Jews and Kurds that should not be neglected. Both peoples are known as perpetual victims; however, in response to such far-reaching persecution, both have taken the position that they will defend themselves against their (often mutual) enemies.

It should also be remembered that in the 1950s many Kurds helped Jewish families -- perhaps even their neighbors -- escape to Israel from Iraq through the mountains. It is also recalled that the Mossad assisted Kurds in Iraq as the Peshmerga fought against Baghdad in order to secure greater rights.

While the majority of Kurds are Muslims, they are not nearly as prone to extremism, as “Kurdayati” or Kurdish national consciousness is of paramount importance and supersedes religious affiliation. Jews and Kurds share a sentiment that they only have one homeland. As it is often expressed in Israel, “En Li Eretz Aheret” -- I have no other country.

Ey Reqib, the Kurdish national anthem, echoes the same sentiment: “Kurdistan is my religion, our creed.” 

Rosenberg's actions send a powerful message across the Middle East that the fight against ISIS transcends race, religion, ideology and creed.



Data pager
Page size:
?? | 15/11/2014
You call YPG, syrian rebels?
guest | 15/11/2014
I am proud of you Gillian. Not to forget that it was Cyrus the great (himself from the Medes: ancestors of today's kurds) who saved the jews from the onslaught of the Assyrians
Kurdish God | 15/11/2014
Whenever you sit on the top of any mountain in Kurdia, looking at the valley below you, the first thing you feel and sense is the presence of “God”. You just can’t escape its natural beauty and divine whisper. No wonder the Kurdish poet Dildar wrote and said our religion is Kurdistan. Have you ever been to a spring field of poppy flowers of Kurdia? The vibrant redness colour of the flowers screaming, “Please be beautiful like me”. Kurdia is my religion. What is religion anyway? They say it’s a relink or a path to God. There is no path to God. God = Love is the present moment. Gillian you are the present moment and a living rainbow. There is a God. You are her :).Freedom and independence for KURDIA now.
Hafez Shirazi | 15/11/2014
As a Kurd,I salute Ms. Gillian Rosenberg and all the Jewish people in the world who support the Kurdish cause!
Mariachi | 15/11/2014
Fighting the gangs in Kobane or working in the Yizidi refugee areas to bring relief, is a worthy vocation. Those who do this seek redemption and become more holy. It is outsiders who should thank the Kurds for allowing us to help.
Tags :

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

Anthony | 2/23/2018 2:24:40 AM
As far as the USA is concerned they have lost a huge amount of trust in the eyes of the YPG/J Syrian Kurd's due to it's very tame almost silent...
Anthony | 2/23/2018 2:46:03 AM
@FAUthman I have seen you comment on many sites and I know you are a Turkish bot!To fix your lies and hopefully folk will understand that Afrin has...
Assad in Afrin: Possible ramifications of Damascus' deployment
| yesterday at 08:15 | (8)
Beltor | 2/22/2018 12:06:35 PM
There goes more Kurdish land. I thought turkish intervention would lose kurds soil in only Afrin. Looks like everythings gone in sheik maqsood. Talk...
kurd | 2/23/2018 2:21:27 AM
hooora, Rojawa kurds got their independence, these trolls of PKK who are happy for teh arrival of syrian and irani forces in afrin, are...
Syrian-regime loyalists enter Kurdish-held areas of Aleppo city
| yesterday at 01:54 | (2)
Outsider | 2/22/2018 9:13:42 PM
There may have arrived 100, max 200 shia militias in Afrin. And they will not really assist the YPG at the front but try to defend 2 Shia dominated...
Turan | 2/23/2018 12:16:00 AM
Everyone knows that the convoy was carrying terrorists and weapons hostile to Turkey. Since when 30 busses carry civilians middle of the night? they...
YPG deployed to Afrin, leaving Aleppo for Damascus
| 18 hours ago | (5)
Muraz Adzhoev | 2/22/2018 9:13:06 PM
What does “the administration of border crossings” mean in accordance with the Constitution? What about the border security and defense matters? How...
dilan | 2/22/2018 9:43:31 PM
customs falls under KRG control, otherwise anyone can smuggle out anything out of south kurdistan and KRG gets the blame.
Initial agreement exists for federal authority at Kurdistan borders
| 16 hours ago | (2)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

UN to vote on amended draft 'demanding' ceasefire in Syria 2 hours ago |

UN to vote on amended draft 'demanding' ceasefire in Syria

'demands' a ceasefire, instead of 'decides' more
In pictures: People raise Assad, Ocalan portraits side by side 3 hours ago |

In pictures: People raise Assad, Ocalan portraits side by side

Pro-Assad forces have arrived in waves more
McGurk in or out as special envoy to the anti-ISIS coalition? 4 hours ago |

McGurk in or out as special envoy to the anti-ISIS coalition?

“Brett McGurk isn't going anywhere more
0.219 seconds