Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Login

Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using
 

Email

 

Rudaw

Opinion

What happens on September 26th?

By Paul Davis 16/9/2017
-
-
Kurds in Iraq and around the world will vote in less than 10 days on a referendum on independence for Iraqi Kurdistan. There has been a lot of analysis about the vote, timing, impact, underlying reasons, etcetera. There has also been some discussion on what happens after. The outcome of the vote is not really in doubt, Kurds will vote overwhelmingly for independence. The Kurdistan Regional Government will then send a delegation to Baghdad to negotiate the separation. Then what?

Two areas remain in doubt, what will the reaction of the region be in accepting the vote and what form of government will we see in Erbil. The governments in Baghdad and Ankara have made no secret of their opposition to the referendum and concern of a new country forming. 

Does Baghdad have the constitutional authority to refuse the Kurds independence. They just voted to reject the referendum as unconstitutional as well as voting to remove Kirkuk Governor Najmaldin Karim from office. The question is then does the Iraqi constitution allow parliament to do anything about the referendum or have the power to remove a governor without cause. The answer is that constitutional experts who have read the constitution have said they do not. Baghdad has no authority to impede a referendum in a designated federal region nor can it remove an elected official without specific charges. 

Regardless of the specific legal authority, the actions do not bode well for any fair and open negotiations between Baghdad and Erbil.  Baghdad has violated the proscriptions of their constitution that any argument as to unconstitutionality is to ignore reality. Even had Baghdad not violated its own constitution so egregiously, the constitution itself does not allow Baghdad to interfere in the referendum. According to Professor Branden O’Leary, Lauder Professor of Political Science at the University of Pennsylvania, “By virtue of the conjunction of Articles 141, 110, 115 and 121 (2) (of the Iraqi constitution) it is entirely lawful and constitutional for Kurdistan to hold a referendum on any subject it pleases.” 

Regardless of the legal arguments and diplomatic work, it is unlikely that Kurdistan will have the pleasure of a Czechoslovakian style “velvet” divorce. To what degree Baghdad is willing to try to use force to retain the Kurdish region is unknown. Another fear is to what degree Turkey and Iran are willing to go to stop Kurdish independence.

The actual actions others may take will be dependent on the actions of the western nations. The statement by US Special Presidential Envoy for Global Coalition to Defeat ISIS, Brett McGurk, that the referendum is “not something that we can support” must be taken with a large grain of salt as McGurk is not likely empowered to make such pronouncements. It must be pointed out to McGurk that such statements are counterproductive and will lead to the problems he supposedly is there to stop.

The second part of “What Happens on September 26th” is what form of government the new Kurdistan will adopt. The current Kurdistan Regional Government is a good place to start, however over the years some objections have arisen. To understand as well, the KRG does not have a constitution. The constitution that was written is only a draft as it was never ratified. The new Kurdish government will have an opportunity to start fresh and move forward. Some of the concerns are valid some are not. A political consideration that has been raised in the past is to change the way the president is elected. Currently it is by direct election of the people, some want to change that to parliamentary appointment. 

President Barzani has also indicated that the new Kurdistan will be a federalist system with much power devolved to the governates. This is a tricky problem and can work, provided enough power is retained in the central government or it can be a disaster if there is no clear authority between the various localities. For clarity on this I suggest the reader study the United States under the Articles of Confederation. 

A new constitution can help define the new government and should be worked on primarily with Kurds and limited assistance from the outside. This government must be Kurdish in mind, body and soul to work. The best-intentioned outsider will not fully understand the culture and needs of the population.

I hope that when September 26th  comes a new day will dawn and a new country will be born. It will take work and solidarity and a little luck, but it can and will happen.

 

Paul Davis is a retired US Army military intelligence and former Soviet analyst. He is a consultant to the American intelligence community specializing in the Middle East with a concentration on Kurdish affairs. Currently he is the president of the consulting firm JANUS Think in Washington D.C.

The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the position of Rudaw.

Comments

 
Data pager
Previous
12
Page size:
PageSizeComboBox
select
FAUthman | 16/9/2017
"Interestingly, a number of sub-state entities that held independence referenda without the consent of the national states did in fact eventually become independent states" Baghdad may object but Kurdistan Iraq as an independent state will eventually get international recognition . It may have to start with a unilateral declaration of Independence soon after the referundum. Kurds should not delay this process. "Iraq's problems " of Shia /Sunni divide, ISIS, Iran, is not their problems to solve and as long as they are viewed as a vassal race inferior to Arabs in Iraq, which they will be no matter what, they have no place in Iraq. US is implying "you can be a state but just postpone it for a while until we clean up ISIS". That does not make sense, Kurds are effective fighting ISIS now and can be more effective to keep ISIS out if they are treated like an independent state. In the long term good relations with the rest of Iraq esp. Baghdad are indispensable. Seperation as two sovereign states but not total divorce is the answer.
FAUthman | 16/9/2017
Another great column by Paul Davis. Read his second to last paragraph carefully, there is a lot of wisdom in that paragraph!
kardox | 16/9/2017
Relying upon the legal expertise evaluations, Paul Davis’ writing makes a strong and realistic assessment of legal points of the view, pertaining to the issue of referendum and independent Kurdistan. One also can, unequivocally, add that the self-determination right for nations has well long been imbedded in UN Charter which gives the ground for practising that rights to every known nations which therefore gives further legitimacy to referendum, based on international laws and rulings. Dilemma that western powers in general and USA in particular, facing, in regard of the current referendum in Kurdistan, stems from the fact that there is no hint as to the timing of exercising self-determination rights. All the political hustle and bustle relating to the timing of referendum reflect the political crisis in the region and worldwide as well. White House and Trump administration are in a chaos and disarray domestically and internationally. This fact, in fact, gives the Russian and their allies the most favourable and wanted room to endeavour their political and strategic manoeuvres both locally and globally. Russian is advancing well in their strategic direction and western power and USA are in a disadvantage position in comparision to the Russian. This reality is the major cause of western power in their seemingly futile and unrealistic opposition to the referendum in Kurdistan, in obvious contrast to the Israel that should have been grasped as significant point of difference, both politically and strategically.
zoran | 16/9/2017
thank you sir for another eye opener and great observations ahead of everyone else. as usual.
Pliny The Kurd | 17/9/2017
Let's keep firm and united ahead and after our glory day of September 25. Let's be confident that when September 26 comes a new day will dakwn and a new country will be born. Blessings and best wishes for the Kurdish State .
3620 Views

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

kurt basar | 12/13/2017 7:27:05 AM
Yes. it was & it's, except there is no such thing exist as an independent Iraq, but from now on you can call it the Southern Iran, with blessing of...
duroi | 12/13/2017 9:34:58 AM
Let's see who will replace him next month.
US: Implementation of Iraqi constitution addresses Kurdish grievances
| yesterday at 09:30 | (2)
Hander | 12/13/2017 9:00:39 AM
Very interesting. Thank you.
Pilgrims visit ancient church named for Christian convert
| yesterday at 08:45 | (1)
guest2002 | 12/12/2017 5:31:10 PM
From all the speech , the printer messed up when it got to the Peshmarga!!! These shiia jihadis are idiots!!!
Jagerxin derashy | 12/13/2017 6:31:48 AM
Bullshit! They all all heard the word that come out of Iraqi officials mouths including PM abadi,! They never mentioned peshmerga’ abadi wasn’t...
Baghdad claims 'printing error' for omitting Kurdish Peshmerga
| yesterday at 12:45 | (5)
Yassir Fekaiki
Yassir Fekaiki | 12/12/2017 7:27:38 PM
they should start with Prime Minster and Deputy Prime minister offices and salaries as they have gained enough and do not need to be on any salary in...
Azad | 12/13/2017 5:57:41 AM
What a joke. 1.2 million employees in a krg that has a population of 4.5m . Thats a whoppping 26% of the total population. In contrast, most...
KRG to make more salary cuts in 2018 after losing Kirkuk oil
| yesterday at 09:51 | (2)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

Europe is not safe for Iranian opposition, daughter of slain leader 1 hour ago |

Europe is not safe for Iranian opposition, daughter of slain leader

“We came here to be safe but we don’t feel safe. more
Time for Baghdad, Erbil to turn a new page, says Maliki 2 hours ago |

Time for Baghdad, Erbil to turn a new page, says Maliki

Nobody can disband Hashd al-Shabai, not even the more
YPG claim they killed 2 Turkish soldiers near Kobane 11 hours ago |

YPG claim they killed 2 Turkish soldiers near Kobane

Turkish soldiers wanted to cross the border into more
0.531 seconds