Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Login

Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using
 

Email

 

Rudaw

Opinion

Kurdish perspective: Will the creation of an independent Kurdistan destabilize the Middle East?

By Zana Kurda 17/9/2017
--

The Kurdistan Region in will hold a referendum on independence from Iraq on 25 September. In this podcast series, Zana Kurda, the director of European Affairs at the Kurdistan Regional Government’s Mission to the EU, presents the Kurdish perspective and explains why the Kurds are determined to hold the referendum.

 

No, Kurds believe it will not. This is an argument that has been brought up frequently in recent times. While the Kurds understand those concerns, they believe it is not a well-founded argument.

 
First of all, it is only about the Kurdistan Region in Iraq. Secondly, this argument implies that the current Iraq somehow contributes to the regional stability in the Middle East, which one really could argue the opposite. In fact, one could ask if Iraq has ever been a source of stability in the Middle East. If you look at the history from an objective point of view, the answer seems to be no. 
 
Iraq fought a bloody war with Iran. Iraq invaded Kuwait, threatened to invade Saudi Arabia and Jordan, had shaky relationships with Turkey and Syria, and Iraq also played a very negative role in the Arab-Israeli conflict often perpetrating attacks on Israel. The current Iraq is not in the state of being a military threat to its neighbors any longer, but Iraq continues to be a regional threat in a different way. And, again, it all has to do with the fundamental problems mentioned earlier. The current Iraq has been a battlefield in the regional Shia-Sunni conflict and as result of this the country has become a breeding place for terrorist groups like Al-Qaeda, ISIS as well as recently some extremist elements within the Shia forces. 
 
Kurds often point to their achievements in the last decade and their contribution to regional and global security as well as on the humanitarian field; Kurdistan’s Peshmerga has been among the most effective fighting forces in the war against ISIS, while the Kurdistan region has been hosting almost 2 million displaced Iraqis and Syrian refugees. Over the last decade, Kurdistan has manifested itself as a constructive partner of the international community, Kurds argue. 
 
The KRG has also reached out to its neighbors Turkey and Iran in a positive way. The KRG Prime Minister Nechirvan Barzani has been known to have played a mediator between the Turkish government and the PKK for a long time. Those efforts nearly led to a permanent settlement of the Kurdish issue in Turkey. However, the war in Syria and the lack of commitment of the two rival parties has led to resurgence of violence. The Kurdish problem in Turkey has not, however, impacted the relations between the KRG and Turkey. Both Turkey and Iran have massive investments in Kurdistan Region’s economy and they are unlikely to risk their economic interests in the KRG. 

 
Based on that, Kurds believe the claim that an independent Kurdistan would destabilize the region stems from a rather ill-informed view of the historical facts as well as present-day reality in Iraq, while it also disregards, they say, the constructive role of the Kurds in countering many challenges in the region.

Comments

 
Rizgar | 18/9/2017
Nothing can destabilize Middle East from what it is now. Middle East and stability are on opposite poles. What destabilizes Middle East are creatures like Erdogan and the Arab thugs who are kings and rulers, not to mention the Iranian terrorists, Hizbollah, ISIS, Al Qaeda, and all the millions of Islamists (terrorist in waiting). Kurds have always been a voice of reason. It's the other crooks that cause troubles.
J. Perez | 18/9/2017
Everybody and every part must understand now and TAKE the advice that an attack on the kurds is an attack on Israel and it will be responded massively and heavyly... Don't forget the 6-days war!! The kurdish nation is not alone any more !
Kurdistanian | 18/9/2017
Middle East is F***d any way😂 Why should we e worried about it... it is nothing to do with us. The 1921 mapping of the area proven to be a big mistake.
3321 Views

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

Outsider | 7/15/2018 4:39:09 AM
@peshmerger4life: I have to disagree... and before putting out such claims... how would it be if you get rid of your own diktatorship????
Peshmerga | 7/16/2018 3:18:55 AM
@outsider,1 it is true that the Turkish goverment was behind giving aid to isis.united states even said thay(look up joe Biden turkey on youtube)2...
Turkey at NATO: Russia understood YPG is a 'real terrorist organization'
| 11/7/2018 | (8)
Caesar | 7/15/2018 10:27:47 PM
I believe Kurds don’t know how to make use of human capital, of their own human capital at all while for instance Turks Arabs and Iranians are much...
Kawa | 7/16/2018 2:45:10 AM
This is a very poor piece that lacks factual information and is based on speculations and obviously views that are preserved by Dr. Ghassemlou’s...
Ghassemlou: Assassinated KDPI leader was a flower – with thorns
| yesterday at 08:11 | (4)
Trump | 7/16/2018 12:09:22 AM
Mogherini looks more like a waitress than a politician. It’s disturbing that Eu parliament is full of housewives, magazine sellers horrible teachers...
Conditioned support for preserving Iran nuclear deal remains
| 6/7/2018 | (1)
UN? | 7/13/2018 8:30:33 AM
I wonder where these clever people are getting their ideas and figures from. I am not sure their ideas and figures are set to fool the people or they...
Zeki | 7/15/2018 11:56:46 PM
Guterres must be smoking bad Afghan shit. The hole Muslim world was first backstabbed and raped by Turks and since a century by Europe and since the...
Stability of Iraq is vital to regional security: UN’s Guterres
| 12/7/2018 | (2)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

EU protects firms as it fights US bid to isolate Iran 3 hours ago |

EU protects firms as it fights US bid to isolate Iran

The EU vowed to fight to preserve the Iran more
Yezidi village school to become genocide museum 4 hours ago |

Yezidi village school to become genocide museum

ISIS gathered 1,202 Kocho residents in the more
Fire sweeps Afrin forestland: White Helmets 6 hours ago |

Fire sweeps Afrin forestland: White Helmets

The White Helmets recently arrived in Afrin more
0.922 seconds