Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment


Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using





The state of Kurdistan and fates of minorities

By Bakhtyar Karim 20/4/2017


How can we be free without violating freedoms of others? This is an important question which every Kurd should ask themselves. It is an intrinsic question to any cause of statehood as a philosophical concept. 

The history of building a state goes parallel to the history in legitimizing the practice of inclusion or exclusion of different social components in the state apparatus. A state shouldn’t comprise framework within which power is monopolized solely by a legal establishment. 

Rather, it is a framework within which distinctions are made between citizens and noncitizens, us and others. Some kind of nationalism is inherent in every state. And nationalism dictates the principles of inclusion and marginalization, which differ according to the type of nationalism at play. 

Ethnic nationalism marginalizes those outside the ruling ethnicity in some way or form. The Kurds have been the greatest victims of this kind of nationalism since the beginning of the 20th century. 

However, civic nationalism strives to broaden the framework of inclusion and narrow that of marginalization. Kurdish politicians and intellectuals pride themselves on the existence of an unparalleled coexistence of different social and religious components in the Kurdistan Region. This, to a large extent, is the case. 

It is this coexistence that accounts for some minorities showing support for independence for the Kurdistan Region, though doing so cautiously. But this kind of peaceful coexistence in the region is not only attributable to the kindness of the Kurdish leadership.

The real reason behind this, is that many of these different components are apolitical. And they themselves, in their own ghettos, have marginalized themselves. This kind of self-marginalization or distancing from broader political and greater social life is ascribable to a historical fear of the Kurdish and Muslim majority in the region. 

The participation of these different social and religious components in the region’s political process has been conditioned to some prerequisites set by the Kurdish leadership. However, this participation hasn’t yet been fixed within a strategic framework. 

The participation of minorities in the political process is different from creating equal opportunities for such participation. The notion of ‘participation’ involves some kind of ‘giving’ from a linguistic perspective. 

It appears there is consensus among politicians and intellectuals in the Kurdistan Region to delay the question of equal rights of citizenship for minorities and protecting their distinct identity, until after a state is built. 

Deferring this, and other important questions until after a state is built, is a big problem. Doing so implies that current mentality is that of delaying these matters, and hasn’t been able to demarcate between its intellectual parameters and those of its past oppressors. It is also a reference that the Kurdistan state enterprise based on this mentality will lead to the constitution of a state that deepens ethnic and religious nationalism. 

Kurdish nationalism could be employed differently in this regard. The history of coexistence in the Kurdistan Region might be used as evidence for a tolerant Kurdish nationalism in the region. However, its history in governance places its nationalism in a difficult position, between being unlimitedly tolerant and completely closed in its definition of citizenship. 

In their endeavors to build a state, all Kurdish political parties in the Kurdistan Region are trying to replace the very monster they are fighting against (with something similar), instead of attempting to build something different to what they have been suffering from. 

Kurdish nationalism has, since its emergence, been under the influence of the experience and nationalism of the countries which have split the Kurdish territory. The survival of state as an end justifies all kinds of means for Turks, Persians and Arabs. Similarly, the Kurds are doing everything they can to build a state of this character. 

The Kurds’ legendary love affair and endeavors for statehood should benefit from Friedrich Nietzsche’s advice that people fighting a monster shouldn’t themselves become monsters in the end. 

Thus, the task of the Kurds shouldn’t only be the building of a state. Rather, it should aim at constituting a state that is different from the ones which the Kurds have fought against. The model of state which the Kurds are striving to build shouldn’t be like the monster models which committed genocide against the Kurds. It shouldn’t be a state that perpetrates genocide against its minorities. 

Last year, Rand Corporation, an American policy think tank, issued a report on the implications of building a Kurdistan state. One of the important areas which the report touches upon is the question of minorities fearing to live in a Kurdish state, but not having problems living within the framework of a state whose majority is determined by agreement as Kurdish. This subject should be of importance to us. 

The majority of population in the Kurdistan Region is Kurds and the majority of these Kurds is Muslim. But being a Kurd and a Muslim shouldn’t be the basis of citizenship, nor should they be used as a means by the majority to monopolize power. 

In civil states, citizenship is a legal concept and has no relation to identity. The establishment in these societies creates equal opportunities for political involvement. Therefore, every citizen is entitled to participate in the political process irrespective of identity. 

The Iraqi model is of use for the Kurds. They should neither run away from it, nor should they build an exact replica of it. The Kurds should strive to build a state that doesn’t impose identity, language or a particular religion on other components. 

The model of a future Kurdish state should be such that incorporates all the components of the region without any ethnic or religious constraints. Hence, it is vital that the minorities of the Kurdistan Region are involved in discussions on the future of the region. 


Bakhtyar Karim is an instructor in the University of Salahaddin's philosophy department in Erbil, Kurdistan Region.

The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the position of Rudaw.



Eugene | 20/4/2017
What is the solution?...a...for unity-sake(for the sake of unity) everyone would have to be a member of South a priority.Secondly...could they could have duel citizenship cards(or 2 cards)coins side..kurdistan,one-side minority, bills one side kurdistan,one side minority,flags...kurdistan flag,then minority flag,military..serve two years kurdistan,then 2 yrs. minority military..language learn kurdish & their own language at young age..this would have to be worked out with the KRG...
Method Man | 20/4/2017
What the hell is this author yapping about? the minorities in Kurdistan have every cultural linguistic and religous rights there is! I dare him to mention any other country in the Middle East and beyond that can match Kurdistan region in this regard. As for political rights the minorities in Kurdistan are allocated parliament seats way beyond their population nr.! they've also been given minstral and department posts in every KRG government since 1992! Why the HELl are you taking something postive and turning it into a problem? The only thing you got right is despite unprecedented rights most of the minorities isolate themselves and some are even skeptical towards Kurdish indipendence e.g. the turkmen of Kirkuk
brilliant idea | 21/4/2017
A Kurd in exile | 21/4/2017
In principle, I agree with the author. As long as a person residing in Kurdistan (regardless of his/her race, religion, language, etc.) considers himself/herself a citizen of Kurdistan and pledges allegiance to the Kurdish State, he/she should have equal rights with everybody else and enjoy every opportunity that everybody else enjoys. Period! And those rights and equal opportunities should be guaranteed in the Nation's Constitution (like the U.S. Bill of Rights). This is the only way that will guarantee having a peaceful and prosperous nation that we the Kurds deserve. We are not Turks, nor Arabs nor Persians! We are the Kurds. We are Noble. We cannot and should not treat the minorities in our country in the same way that the Turks, the Arabs, or the Persians treat minorities their countries. We are better than them!

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

KRG | 5/26/2018 4:51:39 PM
No unity with a partys like kdp puk dividing Kurdistan.
Salim | 5/27/2018 5:09:32 AM
Its not possible I think
On party anniversary KDP urges Kurdish unity in dealing with Baghdad
| yesterday at 12:35 | (3)
Azad | 5/27/2018 2:21:11 AM
Clearly an ignorant lying individual who's clearly living in a different universe talking like she knows everything. We don't play by the rules of...
Hama | 5/27/2018 2:49:30 AM
This is what happens when an arrogant american works in Slemani and is brainwashed by Gorran fanatics. What's scary is not that she holds these...
Trump appoints KRG critic Denise Natali to top job – but who is she?
| yesterday at 01:14 | (7)
Yilmaz | 5/23/2018 10:18:09 AM
@Renas It's great to see someone on here who doesn't support the terrorist PKK. Respect for you. But Erdogan is a president of a sovereign nation and...
Guru | 5/26/2018 11:54:20 PM
Forget Erdogan he is the symptom not the cause. The cause is that all Turks are deeply rooted/ brainwashed fascists nationalists and terrorists but...
HDP: AKP is after our 80 seats but we will not give them away
| 22/5/2018 | (3)
Outsider | 5/23/2018 10:04:34 PM
Rudaw may want to publish also how many PKK fighters were (using Rudaw's term) killed since the Turks entered and in the immediate aftermath of the...
Guru | 5/26/2018 11:46:11 PM
Some dickheads in Ankara decide to attack and murder the Kurds and send their worst and poorest sons hoping those will die so they can have more of...
Two Turkish soldiers killed in PKK attack in Kurdistan Region
| 22/5/2018 | (5)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

PUK open for talks with all political parties: politburo 3 hours ago |

PUK open for talks with all political parties: politburo

"The PUK, right after the election, said we more
Iran officials stop deaf girls’ sign language song, say it resembles dancing 4 hours ago |

Iran officials stop deaf girls’ sign language song, say it resembles dancing

Dancing is outlawed in public spaces in the more
Russia forces among dozens dead in IS east Syria attacks 5 hours ago |

Russia forces among dozens dead in IS east Syria attacks

Moscow said Sunday four of its servicemen were more
0.375 seconds