Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment


Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using





US-PYD rapprochement: a shift in Washington’s strategy?

By Mustafa Gurbuz 24/10/2014

After the US airdrops over Kobane, Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan said he has a hard time understanding why the town is so strategic for the United States. Erdogan also may have a hard time grasping the myriad US national security interests at stake in a post-Bashar Assad Syria.

Only a day before the ammunition airdrops to the Kurdish fighters in Kobane, Erdogan repeated that the Democratic Union Party (PYD) is equal to the Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK) -- a “terrorist” organization that cannot be bolstered with arms.

"It would be wrong for the United States — with whom we are friends and allies in NATO — to talk openly and to expect us to say 'yes' to such a support to a terrorist organization," Erdogan said. Within 48 hours, the Turkish government declared it would grant the Kurdistan Region’s Peshmerga forces passage to Kobane, as a response to Washington’s approval of arms transfers to PYD.

For the first time, the White House publicly stated that PYD is different from PKK, thus not considered a terrorist group by the United States.

Does US-PYD cooperation signal a change in Washington’s grand strategy in the war on the Islamic State (ISIS)?

The US-PYD rapprochement is aimed at sending a clear message to Ankara to negotiate a road map in Syria. The Obama administration seems to prove that it is Turkey which has more to lose in the case of non-cooperation.

Eric Edelman, former US ambassador to Turkey, is among many in Washington’s opinion circles who called for a benign neglect in the past few months. “We have communicated by what we’ve said and what we’ve done over a decade that we think Turkey is absolutely essential to what we do and that is irreplaceable and that we need Turkey more than Turkey needs the United States, NATO, and the West,” Edelman told Washington’s Bipartisan Policy Center earlier this month. “I think that’s a mistake and I think that we continue to do this at our own peril.”

Edelman’s comments are especially worth considering when analyzed next to 2013 report on the issue, “US-Turkish cooperation toward a post-Assad Syria.”

It highlights the significance of Turkey but also notes dire challenges as American and Turkish interests are diverging. The main issue at stake is how a post-Assad Syria looks.  “The Erdogan government has not shown much concern for Syrian minorities. Indeed, its support for Muslim Brotherhood-allied rebels in Syria would seem to indicate that Turkey is pursuing a sectarian agenda,” the report says.

For nearly two years, Erdogan and his Justice and Development Party (AKP) government have failed to allay such suspicions in Washington.  The AKP government’s stubborn insistence on removal of the Assad regime increasingly backfires, as the Obama administration pays grants urgent attention to the Iraq crisis.

Kobane has become a significant battlefield primarily because of its symbolic importance in the larger war in Iraq. Thus, it is not realistic to expect the Obama administration to push hard against the Assad regime in the near future.

Syria is a microcosm of the larger regional competition between Sunnis and Shiites. Northern Syria is already a failed state. Simply removing Assad, therefore, is not enough to introduce stability in the region. Preventing anti-Western militants from gaining yet another haven is a major priority for Washington.    

In order to gain Western trust, the PYD has capitalized on its secular identity, especially through promoting women in its ranks. Kurdish women fighters who are dying for freedom have been represented in Western media next to ISIS cruelty against women. The PKK’s accumulated repertoire, due to its Marxist heritage, has proven to be effective in helping the PYD’s public image.  The PKK ideology has long reconstructed “Kurdish women” through a utopian symbolism. In its early stages, the PKK narrated the enslavement of Kurds through images of captive women under tribal patriarchy. Since the early 1990s, the emancipation of Kurdish women has become a dominating discourse in the movement. In a conceptual perspective, it is not surprising: any nascent form of nationalism depicts free women to symbolize a free motherland.

Yet, there is more than meets the eye in the PKK case. Through its images of women, the PKK and the PYD aim to convince the West that they are pro-democracy and thus reliable partners in the region against Islamist extremists.    

The PYD’s success in Syria, however, depends on its broader strategy of power-sharing among Kurds. Without a strong Kurdish unity and some form of a democratic parliament, Washington would remain reluctant to support Kurdish autonomy in Syria. Such a power-sharing project would also ease Turkey’s position against PYD in the long-run.

On Wednesday, the PYD and Syrian Kurdish parties reached a settlement in Dohuk. A previous attempt, known as the Erbil agreement, was not successful in removing mistrust among Kurds. Yet, this time, under the pressure of ISIS threats, Kurds may succeed in overcoming long-standing challenges. The current deal now includes a joint military force, a hard step towards unification.

Recent developments make Kurdistan Region President Massoud Barzani more than ever critical in shaping the regional politics. By being at the epicenter of US-PYD-Turkey relations, the Kurdistan Regional Government needs to capitalize on this moment of opportunity.

Mustafa Gurbuz is a policy fellow at Center for Global Policy at George Mason University and a research fellow at Rethink Institute in Washington, DC. He is the author of Transforming Ethnic Conflict: Rival Kurdish Movements in Turkey (Forthcoming, Amsterdam University Press).



Data pager
Page size:
Schkak | 24/10/2014
Thoughtful and accurate analysis in depth.It has become obvious to everybody now that the only boots on the ground willing to fight the Islamists are Kurds.The Arabs and Turks are failing and they have their own agendas which are different or opposed to the West,and the West is for now aware of this fact.If the Kurds unite and put aside their rivalries and differences they will deserve the respect and support of the Weast and they will be able to turn this war ,successfuly,in thier war for independence.
jeff jones | 24/10/2014
A good step in reducing (for a westerner)a complex socio/political dynamic to it's component parts and thus allowing a greater depth and bredth of understanding. With understanding empathy and action are more likely to follow.
M Gonzales
M Gonzales | 25/10/2014
My biggest problem with the Syrian Kurds is the YPG and how they dominate the government and how they it seems make every attempt to dominate the government and kurds in Syria. Salih Muslim really needs to ease up and form a Democratic government and a Rojava Peshmerga Military, not a YPG militia. Im not saying the YPG cant be part of the Rojava Peshmerga, they could have a Rojava patch on one arm and a YPG patch on the other but the Other Syrian Kurdish parties should not be sidelined. At some point it would be nice for the Rojava Peshmerga to not have any ties to any political party but thats a fight for another day. Please for the sake of your people, form new Syrian kurd military units but with no ties to the PKK, YPG just a Rojava Peshmerga battalion. That way the West would feel a bit easier when it comes to giving them weapons. Your only shooting your own foot with all this political power playing and divisions. If the YPG is so great, let them win at the ballot box and dominate via a honest vote, not with 40k troops watching how you vote if you even get a vote.
NH | 25/10/2014
The truth always comes up at the end. Now we know that Turkey stands for bigotry and Kurdistan stands for humanity.
John in America | 25/10/2014
Tell President Erdogan to look up " The Alamo" if he wonders why the American People support the Kurds in Kobane.
Tags :

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

Kanee ayoub | 12/17/2018 11:49:14 PM
Thank you
pre-Boomer Marine brat | 12/18/2018 1:00:13 AM
According to Reuters late Monday, Erdogan is saying Trump "gave a positive response" to Turkish plans to move east of the Euphrates.
Turkey offensive in Syria ‘a bad idea’ warns US rep Jeffrey
| 23 hours ago | (4)
guest2002 | 12/17/2018 8:11:42 PM
Why apologize?? For telling the truth???
Coalition spokesman apologizes for sharing tweet ‘insulting’ Turkey
| yesterday at 10:56 | (1)
FAUthman | 12/17/2018 4:55:36 PM
Erdogan hints at possible "room for negotiation with the US", according to VOA!.....hmmmmm!"Although Erdogan said that Turkey could start an...
FAUthman | 12/17/2018 7:16:25 PM
Erdogan says US should "fulfill its promises" to Turkey. But he leaves us guessing at what these promises could be by not telling us what they are....
How feasible is a no-fly zone for Rojava?
| 15/12/2018 | (12)
Unite | 12/17/2018 11:56:57 AM
I beg you unite put down your pride and unite put down your differences and unite this is the chance dont forget kobane we standed with you and will...
alfred | 12/17/2018 3:49:20 PM
kurds should not be stupid to have wrong pride. and for sure - all fractions ,parties of the kurds from all regions must stand together for their...
UPDATE: SDF rejects Peshmerga offer to bolster Syria-Turkey border: monitor
| 16/12/2018 | (13)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

German FM Heiko Maas arrives for talks in Erbil 7 hours ago |

German FM Heiko Maas arrives for talks in Erbil

He earlier met with Iraqi President Barham Salih more
Why doesn’t Iraq do more to prevent Turkish airstrikes? 8 hours ago |

Why doesn’t Iraq do more to prevent Turkish airstrikes?

Iraq’s foreign ministry summoned the Turkish more
Iraq’s political deadlock grinds on as ministerial posts remain unfilled 9 hours ago |

Iraq’s political deadlock grinds on as ministerial posts remain unfilled

All the while, the problems of Iraqis are going more
0.406 seconds