Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment


Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using





Erdogan and Trump: Birds of a Feather?

By DAVID ROMANO 25/11/2016

Your humble columnist spent much of the last week discussing with friends how Donald Trump won the election in the United States. Mr. Trump capitalized upon rural conservative voters’ anger at the secular establishment that continuously insults them and looks down on them, their affection for a macho strongman image, their desire for change, and similar factors.

Then it dawned on me where else this occurred recently: Turkey. Searching various news sites, it did not take long to find others who noticed the parallel. Steven Cook, writing for the Politico news site, offers the following:

Like Erdogan’s supporters, the predominantly middle-class and rural voters without college degrees who delivered the White House to Trump are deeply suspicious of the elites. When Erdogan’s Justice and Development Party, also known as AKP, first came to power in 2002, it represented voters from the Anatolian heartland, Kurds and pious Turks, many of whom had felt shunned and repressed by the Istanbul and Ankara elite. The members of the Turkish establishment—educated at the exclusive Galatasaray Lisesi high school and Bogazici University (which might as well be Vassar on the Bosphorus), Ankara University’s Faculty of Political Science and Economics or, of course, the military academy—looked down on the AKP’s constituents.

Another well-known American political scientist and strident Trump critic, Stephen Walt of Harvard, compares Trump’s personality and manner to that of Erdogan and Putin. He then goes on to warn his readers about how to recognize dictatorial tendencies in a Trump administration. This very thought – that an elected leader can be a dictator – sends Mr. Erdogan into a rage every time he hears it, of course. For the likes of Erdogan (and perhaps Trump), if you win the election you get to do what you want. That’s democracy. So it came as no surprise that Mr. Erdogan this week told his audiences to “stop calling Trump a dictator.”

Professor Walt warns his readers that Mr. Trump seems to be a vindictive man “who will go to extreme lengths to punish his opponents and will break a promise in a heartbeat and without remorse.” That sounds familiar to those of us who have been watching events in Turkey, of course. He also accuses Trump of having “little respect for existing norms and rules.” Familiar again. Then he describes Trump supporters as believing their country is under siege from “liberal elites, people of color, immigrants of all sorts, and shadowy foreign influences.” If “people of color” can mean Kurds (and there are a lot of parallels), and “immigrants” can mean any foreigner, then it might as well be a typical Anatolian AKP voter he is describing – especially if we add a lot of emphasis to “shadowy foreign influences”. He might have added something about misogynistic statements from both men too.

I would add that just as Mr. Erdogan surrounded himself with some questionable assistants and advisors (including one who famously claimed that “shadowy foreign powers” were trying to “kill Mr. Erdogan via Telekinesis”), so too with Mr. Trump. And before Mr. Erdogan gets unduly upset about a Trump administration’s discourse  regarding Muslims, they might recall how they themselves speak of Armenians, Jews and Alevis.

Returning to Professor Walt, he also lays out ten signs to look out for in case of a budding Trump dictatorship. Perhaps Dr. Walt simply looked at today’s Turkey for the list: 1) Systematic efforts to control the media; 2) Building an official pro-Trump media network (just replace “pro-Trump” with “Anadolu Agency” or the seized Zaman media); 3) Politicizing the civil service, military, National Guard, or the domestic security agencies; 4) Using government surveillance against domestic political opponents; 5) Using state power to reward corporate backers and punish opponents; 6) Stacking the Supreme Court (replace “Supreme Court” with “Constitutional Court”); 7) Enforcing the law for only one side; 8) Really rigging the system (your humble columnist is not sure about this one, unless suspicious power failures during ballot counting and “security” operations in opposition districts on voting day count); 9) Fearmongering; and 10) Demonizing the opposition.

In Turkey, of course, we know that media freedom rankings have now fallen behind the likes of Zimbabwe and Russia. We know that after firing some 200,000 civil servants in the last year, they were replaced with Erdogan loyalists. We know that the Turkish spy agency – the MIT – is now only answerable to President Erdogan himself, and that it spies freely on his opponents at home and abroad. We know that judges even at the highest levels have been replaced with loyalists too, thanks to new legislation allowing Mr. Erdogan to do so.

We know that if someone insults Sunni Islam in Turkey (or Mr. Erdogan), prosecutors will be beating on one’s door within hours – while being nowhere to be found followings insults towards ethnic Kurds, Armenians, Christians, Jews, Alevis or others. We have our doubts about ballot counting, power failures, and security operations in a few key districts during the last elections. We have no doubts about fearmongering and demonizing of opponents, however. Soon it will be difficult to find even a single elected Kurdish opposition politician who is not behind bars, so dangerous and evil are they…

Your humble columnists does not think something like this will happen in the United States, however. Strong institutions, a vigilant population and a soon to be President Trump who is probably not nearly as bad as he sometimes seemed during the election campaign, will prevent it. Turkey, unfortunately, is another matter.


David Romano has been a Rudaw columnist since 2010. He holds the Thomas G. Strong Professor of Middle East Politics at Missouri State University and is the author of numerous publications on the Kurds and the Middle East.

The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the position of Rudaw.


Data pager
Page size:
duroi | 25/11/2016
David, writing these types of articles on a Kurdish site is not helpful to Kurdish cause and damaging to Kurdish American relations. Trump has been working with Dogan group in Turkey and I am sure Dogan and his son in law have told him enough stories about Erdogan.
zeko | 25/11/2016
prepar for the worse, hope for the best. bring your own popcorns. its show time.
ibo | 25/11/2016
You are so stupid. You just blame Trump and Erdogan but do not question why their opponents are disliked and why they are popular. Just claiming their voters are under educated is so much absurd. Why are not your elite able to convince people to vote for them? Weren't they clever? They could get more votes with so high (!) wisdom
Shoresh barzinji | 25/11/2016
If we look realistically at the authoritative class system societies and its states anywhere at anytime in history, we find that the ruling classes produced and elected thousands of psychopath dictators like Mustafa Kamal (so called Ataturk ) Erdogan, Trump, Saddam, Putin,Stalin, Mao in China,Winston Churchill, Hitler and the list goes on and on.when the majority of ordinary people are fooled and brainwashed for centuries by religions and dictatorial personality worshipping based of course on irrational ideas like racism and religion, then these fooled people will elect through sham elections anyone to represent their irrational egos and ideas, for example in Germany in 1930s the Nazi party came to power through an election which was supported by big German business industries.Elections are the modern game of the ruling classes in many countries when the ordinary peoples accept and digest their poisonous lies, their aggressions and their interests as normal. An American woman writer and activist wrote nearly a century ago if elections can change anything then the governments will make elections illegal.
pre-Boomer Marine brat | 25/11/2016
@Shoresh barzinji "psychopath dictators like...Winston Churchill" ---- Document that, please. Back up that assertion with hard facts.
Tags :

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

Renas | 4/25/2018 8:12:21 PM
Its your job Mr Barzani, to unite Kurds, at least in Basur. So if Kurds are not United it means you have not Done your job well!
Hejar | 4/26/2018 2:23:23 AM
Kurds are not United so stop selling. If Kurds were united, they would've fought together in Kirkuk, Nineveh and Afrin. You are now slaves of your...
Without unity, Kurds will achieve nothing in Baghdad, warns PM Barzani
| yesterday at 10:45 | (2)
Rogério Porfírio da Silva | 4/26/2018 12:41:52 AM
hope for prosperity, this nation has suffered greatly. union and peace.
love peshmerga, AK USA | 4/26/2018 1:16:23 AM
Don't believe a word he is saying? he is lying and look he went to Sulaimani to thank Heero and her son for giving him a key to heart of kurds and...
Abadi campaigns in Sulaimani, ‘here to listen’ to Kurds
| yesterday at 12:25 | (6)
Dungeons and dragons 🐉 | 4/25/2018 10:01:15 PM
Yes makes total sense while turkey is breastfeeding about 72 terrorist organizations all those who dares not to aid them will be blamed as ...
Turkish court convicts Cumhuriyet journalists on terror charges
| yesterday at 10:42 | (1)
Kurdistan and USA | 4/25/2018 12:50:06 PM
We understand tour concerns, you are right. The USA could control the entire Middle East if they would spend 50% on the Kurds for what they spend on...
Ant man | 4/25/2018 3:02:40 PM
A ant is bigger therat than failed Pesh
The Peshmerga pose no threat to Iraq
| yesterday at 08:30 | (3)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

Family of Kurdish King Mahmoud disowns member campaigning on Arab list 4 hours ago |

Family of Kurdish King Mahmoud disowns member campaigning on Arab list

my brother Mustafa who has joined the Hikma more
10 Qs: KIU campaigns on nationalist ticket 6 hours ago |

10 Qs: KIU campaigns on nationalist ticket

'we want to resume our struggle in Baghdad and more
Abadi's campaign stop in Duhok cancelled until further notice 10 hours ago |

Abadi's campaign stop in Duhok cancelled until further notice

“It is not unclear when will Abadi pay the more
0.203 seconds