Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Login

Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using
 

Email

 

Rudaw

Opinion

Arming Gorran? A blow to democracy

By 26/6/2018
Flags of Iraq, the Kurdistan Region, and Gorran fly near the Change Movement's headquarters in Sulaimani. Photo: Rudaw TV
Flags of Iraq, the Kurdistan Region, and Gorran fly near the Change Movement's headquarters in Sulaimani. Photo: Rudaw TV
by Abdullah Reshawi

After fraud allegations of May 12 election and after the Change Movement left the government on October 12, the idea to arm the movement emerged inside and outside the party organs. But, is this a good idea or an emotional and ill-thought reaction?


Arming Gorran or any other unarmed parties in the Kurdistan Region, including the KDP and PUK is unwise. Moreover, we should think about ways to force these two parties to lay down their weapons. Moreover, the idea of arming other parties gives legitimacy to the armed status of the KDP and PUK.

Gorran and other political parties instead should pursue legal, constitutional, and parliamentary measures to force the KDP and PUK to lay down their guns. The electoral body should make it conditional that only unarmed parties are eligible to participate in elections.

The flaw of arming Gorran is that it reduces the concept of ‘force’ to ‘guns’ — force can be achieved without guns.

Developing thousands of dedicated and volunteering democratic cadres is one way to give power to any political party. This area, Gorran and other parties should explore, but history shows in many cases civilians overpower and prevail over armed forces. In modern history, armed revolutionaries were eventually forced to lay down their weapons in order to continue.

Another drawback of the idea of armament is that the purpose of a political party fundamentally changes. If a civilian party aims to enforce democratic and civilian principles in the country, by arming itself, the party would then be concerned solely with working to protect and maintain itself.

For example, a party like Gorran should make compromises to enforce real democratic principles, rather than working to maintain the party as an objective. Perhaps Gorran could protect itself if it is armed, but this would be at the expense of the democratic principles they have espoused.

We should ask why Gorran was expelled from the government. It wasn’t only because they didn’t back down on their demands to the dominant party. The reason why there wasn’t civil war when Gorran was uncompromising was because it wasn’t armed.

Gorran was adamant in its position and didn’t compromise on the Kurdistan Region’s presidential law because the party was not armed. If Gorran was armed at the time, reaching an agreement or waging an internal war would have been the party’s only choices, just like the PUK, which has strategic agreements with the KDP because both parties are armed.

Those who uphold the idea of arming unarmed parties in order to protect democratic principles argue that by being armed, these parties can prevent voting fraud, injustices, and ensure protestors are not beaten when they take to the streets.

This is easier said than done and difficult. In reality it ends purely civilian endeavors, will lead to internal war, and restricts space for civilian endeavors. Becoming an armed party would only allow Gorran’s opposition to criticize the very values it was founded upon and has democratically struggled against.


The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the position of Rudaw.
2457 Views

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

End this war | 11/14/2018 4:10:01 PM
Obviously this war is in the best interests of Turkey, and probably it is Turkey who command secretly the PKK with the aim to destroy Kurds...
PKK has gone quiet in Duhok after US bounties: local official
| 9 hours ago | (1)
Unite | 11/11/2018 12:44:42 PM
Let me tell you the rest of the above story. Nothing really has changes, the show is still goes on. Only the scale of the war with basic weapons has...
Tron | 11/14/2018 3:28:47 PM
Ww2 and world war 1 are actually one single war with slightly different alliances namely the Italians were with and not against the Nazis. It was...
Europe, Middle East map redrawn by World War I
| 11/11/2018 | (2)
Hansi Oemerian | 11/14/2018 1:41:57 PM
I wish the little man not suffered from these sanctions but to most peacefully topple an incredible corrupt and a hostile regime like the Iranian...
Iran, feeling sanctions bite, looks for outlet in Iraq
| 16 hours ago | (1)
Richard | 11/14/2018 6:31:39 AM
Some information about where this book can be purchased would be helpful
Young author shines spotlight on child victims of ISIS
| yesterday at 09:31 | (1)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

Kurdish chop shop builds homemade Lamborghini 12 hours ago |

Kurdish chop shop builds homemade Lamborghini

It cost $40,000 to build using parts chopped from more
Syrian refugees in KRI want to return – but first need guarantees 12 hours ago |

Syrian refugees in KRI want to return – but first need guarantees

"No place is like your birthplace" more
Kurdish beardsman wins top Swedish hairdressing prize 14 hours ago |

Kurdish beardsman wins top Swedish hairdressing prize

Chia won first prize in Sweden's World Beard Day more
0.484 seconds