Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Login

Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using
 

Email

 

Rudaw

Opinion

Ankara’s ISIS Conundrum

26/9/2014
-
-

By Mustafa Gurbuz

“Mr. Barzani has not had a conversation with me about Kurdish independence. We are against the division of Iraq,” Recep Tayyip Erdogan said in his first visit to the United States as Turkey’s President.

What Erdogan did not mention, however, was that the Turkish government had quietly pledged to defend the Kurdistan Region’s Peshmerga if they were attacked but “broke its promise” after the Islamic State (IS) advanced on Iraqi Kurdistan, President Massoud Barzani’s Chief of Staff Fuad Hussein said during a talk at the United States Institute of Peace in Washington.  

The Kurdistan Regional Government’s (KRG) frustration with Ankara comes as the Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK) emerges as an ally in the war on IS. Ankara and Erbil’s strategic agreement emerged from the Syrian crisis and was expected to be further strengthened given the turmoil in Iraq.

Declining bilateral trust, however, raises serious questions about the future of Erbil-Ankara relations. Despite the fact that both deeply value their economic partnership, Turkey’s peace negotiations with the PKK is a critical dynamic that will influence Ankara’s long-term security strategy.

Turkey now finds itself at a crossroads. In Washington, Ankara’s unwillingness to cooperate against IS is facing heavy scrutiny, particularly after IS released Turkish hostages who were held in Mosul for months.

Prime Minister Ahmet Davutoglu has promised to join US efforts to cut the extremists’ revenue sources, especially oil smuggling via the Turkish border.

At the United Nations in New York, Erdogan recently indicated that Turkey is open to boosting military cooperation by making a strong statement: “We will continue to work against Al-Qaeda in the region and ISIS is an outgrowth of Al-Qaeda…We’re not weak. We’ve fought terrorists.”

Yet Ankara faces an unprecedented challenge as its two designated enemies, PKK and IS, recruits sympathizers from Turkey to fight in Syria. The PKK’s call for action against IS not only boosts its organizational base but also its global legitimacy.

Some western officials believe that it is only a matter of time before their governments, which label the PKK a terrorist organization, drop the designation and create formal ties with the PKK despite Turkey's objections. Turkey’s Justice and Development Party (AKP) government recommitted to peace negotiations with the PKK after Erdogan’s electoral victory; however, recent developments signal a bumpy road ahead.

Two elements appear critical to solving Turkey’s conundrum: creating a buffer zone in northern Syria and the use of Turkey’s Incirlik air base in military operations against IS.

A buffer zone could provide relief for Turkey, which hosts more than 1 million Syrian refugees ¾ a number that is rapidly climbing and creating tension in border cities.

While Erdogan pushes for this so-called “safe zone,” the United States is trying to find ways to convince Turkey to allow the US military to use Incirlik.

Given that it has underground cells in Istanbul and few other Turkish cities, IS remains a formidable domestic threat to the country. The creation of a safe zone in Syria might prompt the Turkish government to allow the US or other forces to use its Incirlik base. A stronger Turkish presence in the Syria war could also help stabilize Syria’s Kurdish region, a key factor in the long-term fight against IS.

American officials, however, are concerned about Erdogan’s overall vision for the region. Beyond the IS crisis and offering humanitarian protection, a buffer zone could be used as a training ground for anti-Assad forces.

The US and Turkey have long been divergent about the future of Syria, particularly over how to arm opposition groups and carry out diplomatic strategies. The buffer zone is likely to be rejected by Iran, Russia and China, and will not be easy for the US to implement unilaterally.  

The release of Turkish hostages provided an ample opportunity for the US and its allies to get Turkey on board against IS. Erdogan’s goal, to keep the AKP government strong before the 2015 national elections, is a significant factor in his willingness to cooperate.

How to navigate under these complex circumstances, however, is really up to his vision of the Middle East. Unless he convinces US diplomats that he is not obsessed with removing the Assad regime, the region will remain hot. As Kerry bluntly stated, “The proof will be in the pudding.” 

Mustafa Gurbuz is a policy fellow at Center for Global Policy at George Mason University and a research fellow at Rethink Institute in Washington, DC. He is the author of Transforming Ethnic Conflict: Rival Kurdish Movements in Turkey (Forthcoming, Amsterdam University Press).

 

Comments

 
Data pager
Previous
123
Page size:
PageSizeComboBox
select
Murat Karayilan | 26/9/2014
Here is a win win situation: Create a confederate Turkey with Kurds and Turks on equal basis and Rojava will join this federation and get rid of Arabs. In fact an alliance between Kurds and Turks is the most logical thing to do. Problem is that Turks are paranoid schizophrenic people and have a hard time to see the ever fast changing realities.
kurt bashar | 26/9/2014
Presently Mr. Talip Erdogan is the voice of the Muslim brotherhood as well as their leader & soldier, today's Turkey is the only country in the world where the Muslim brotherhood can walk freely & operate for their agenda thanks to the Mr. Erdogan. Syria was most secular Muslim state in the Middle east, because of the B. Assad religion who is Alevi not the Sunni, all the Sunni dictators of the middle East (the Emirs & Kings) hate him which is very hypocritical. Mr. Talip Erdogan with using his power trying to unset the Mr. Bashar Assad, with doing that he want to become the hero of the Muslim Brotherhood. If he succeed the Massacres of the Alevis, Druze, Kurd's & the Christians will be very bloody which never seen before & the Middle east will never be the same. Because of that Mr. Erdogan don't want to go against his Sunni ISIL brothers, because ISIL is his creation with the Saudis, Qataris & the Jordanians. The world nations must stop this insane religious war of the Syria as well as the people like the Mr. Erdogan for good. So far in this Syrian civil war well over 300 thousands of common people lost their life & well over 3 millions of people become refuge because of these Muslim savages & that is the Justice of the Muslim religion who are believers of the Jihad at this Space age.
Josep Catalonia | 26/9/2014
I absolutely agree with Murat. Turks and Kurds have to cooperate, and they will have to from now on, for the mixture of arabs plus Islam is a lethal one and it will always be so.
AttilaTheHun | 26/9/2014
Turks and kurds are not partners... kurds can not stop 5,000 ISIS militans if USA did not bombing them Erbil is ISIS control now.. and kurds claim independence state.. who are you? kurds can live by supports of other nations only..Like USA, Germany -isrel.. oil sale over Turkey ....northern iraq is an industrial area?
EnverPasha | 26/9/2014
Turkey said that 3 yeas ago to west.. "support free syrian army ,declareted no fly zones, bombing esad. if that stuation prolongs more then radical groups can take the control"
Tags :
5939 Views

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

Kanee ayoub | 12/17/2018 11:49:14 PM
Thank you
pre-Boomer Marine brat | 12/18/2018 1:00:13 AM
According to Reuters late Monday, Erdogan is saying Trump "gave a positive response" to Turkish plans to move east of the Euphrates.
Turkey offensive in Syria ‘a bad idea’ warns US rep Jeffrey
| 23 hours ago | (4)
guest2002 | 12/17/2018 8:11:42 PM
Why apologize?? For telling the truth???
Coalition spokesman apologizes for sharing tweet ‘insulting’ Turkey
| yesterday at 10:56 | (1)
FAUthman | 12/17/2018 4:55:36 PM
Erdogan hints at possible "room for negotiation with the US", according to VOA!.....hmmmmm!"Although Erdogan said that Turkey could start an...
FAUthman | 12/17/2018 7:16:25 PM
Erdogan says US should "fulfill its promises" to Turkey. But he leaves us guessing at what these promises could be by not telling us what they are....
How feasible is a no-fly zone for Rojava?
| 15/12/2018 | (12)
Unite | 12/17/2018 11:56:57 AM
I beg you unite put down your pride and unite put down your differences and unite this is the chance dont forget kobane we standed with you and will...
alfred | 12/17/2018 3:49:20 PM
kurds should not be stupid to have wrong pride. and for sure - all fractions ,parties of the kurds from all regions must stand together for their...
UPDATE: SDF rejects Peshmerga offer to bolster Syria-Turkey border: monitor
| 16/12/2018 | (13)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

German FM Heiko Maas arrives for talks in Erbil 7 hours ago |

German FM Heiko Maas arrives for talks in Erbil

He earlier met with Iraqi President Barham Salih more
Why doesn’t Iraq do more to prevent Turkish airstrikes? 8 hours ago |

Why doesn’t Iraq do more to prevent Turkish airstrikes?

Iraq’s foreign ministry summoned the Turkish more
Iraq’s political deadlock grinds on as ministerial posts remain unfilled 8 hours ago |

Iraq’s political deadlock grinds on as ministerial posts remain unfilled

All the while, the problems of Iraqis are going more
0.266 seconds