Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Login

Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using
 

Email

 

Rudaw

Opinion

Kurdish Gains Against the Islamic State

By DAVID ROMANO 26/12/2014
-
-

The past week saw Kurdish forces take back most of the territory they lost to the Islamic State (IS) in Iraq. In Western (Syrian) Kurdistan, the defenders of Kobane have enjoyed slower, but consistent, gains as well. Those who claimed air power alone would never defeat the Islamic State once again appear stuck in the old habit of ignoring the Kurds. Air strikes combined with a determined and even lightly equipped local force seems to be doing quite well, thank you very much. They will do even better if the West sends the Kurds more weapons – at present Kurdistan is only getting a small fraction of what goes to Baghdad.

Speaking of Baghdad, the southern front against the IS is not faring nearly so well. According to the latest reports, much of the Baiji oil refinery recently fell back into IS hands. According to The Long War Journal, “More than six months after the Islamic State launched its offensive to take control of northern and central Iraq, the northern Baghdad belt remains contested between the Iraqi military and allied Shiite militias on one side, and the Islamic State and its Sunni allies on the other.” A few days ago IS fighters also routed the Hezbollah Brigades just north of Baghdad.

It probably does not help that newly revived Shiite militias stand accused of brutalizing Sunni Arab populations in areas they capture from IS. Pictures even emerged of militia fighters beheading people, making such Shiite volunteers difficult to distinguish in practice from their IS enemies. Under such circumstances, Iraqi Sunni Arabs would have an incentive to support IS fighters to the bitter end. No similar reports of atrocities have emerged from Peshmerga liberated areas.

If the Kurds keep reassuring Sunni Arabs not directly implicated in IS crimes that they will be dealt with mercifully (the foreign fighters are another matter however), one could expect an easier Kurdish campaign in the north. Supportive air strikes, tenacious Peshmerga fighters on the ground, and increasing numbers of Sunni Arab allies – such as Mosul governor Atheel al-Nujaifi has been trying to rally – should make a very effective combination as the battle moves southwards.

Many question whether or not the Peshmerga should push their fight against the IS beyond Kurdish lands, however. Even the likes of Governor Nujaifi were bitter foes of the Kurds not long ago, and advancing into hostile Sunni Arab population centers feels like a bad idea. Precisely this kind of serious concern underpinned Kurdistan Region President Barzani’s recent comments to al-Arabiya TV regarding the recapture of Mosul: “The Peshmerga would only play a supporting role, because the Kurdistan Region doesn’t want the start of a Kurdish-Arab war.” A few days ago Rudaw also reported that “Kurdish leaders, including President Barzani, have said that the priority is defending the Kurdish autonomous region against ISIS and that they are not willing to fight in Iraq’s Sunni areas.”

Three principal factors will pressure the Kurds to take their fight against IS jihadis beyond Kurdistan’s soil, however. First, Baghdad, Iran, the United States and others will do whatever they can to convince Erbil to keep up the offensive. If major Kurdish operations against the IS come to an end as the Kurds secure all the lands they claim, outside actors’ incentive to arm and supply Erbil will also decline accordingly. 

Second, capturing more land from IS control offers many benefits. It gives Erbil something to trade back to Baghdad in return for its recognition of Kurdish acquisition of disputed territories like Kirkuk. It would also make IS pay a higher price for its decision to attack the Peshmerga last summer. This would in turn improve Erbil’s deterrent posture against all potential attackers in the future.

Third, holding a strictly defensive position vis-à-vis the IS over a more than 1,000 kilometer long border would represent a strategic and tactical nightmare. The jihadis would effectively be ceded back the initiative in the war. They could attack Kurdish lines wherever and whenever they detected weakness, much as they did last August. If the defenses proved too strong they could comfortably retreat to Sunni Arab areas under their control -- until a better target emerged.

Under such conditions, the best Kurdish strategy might be to avoid taking the lead on large Sunni Arab cities such as Mosul, but to make big forays into IS territory elsewhere – keeping the Jihadis wondering when and where the next offensive might appear – and handing captured territory to allied anti-IS Arab fighters – at a price, of course.

David Romano has been a Rudaw columnist since 2010. He is the Thomas G. Strong Professor of Middle East Politics at Missouri State University and author of The Kurdish Nationalist Movement (2006, Cambridge University Press) and co-editor (with Mehmet Gurses) of Conflict, Democratization and the Kurds in the Middle East (2014, Palgrave Macmillan).

The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the position of Rudaw.

Comments

 
Data pager
Previous
12
Page size:
PageSizeComboBox
select
kurt basar | 26/12/2014
The end of all these savage Muslim religion wars as well as tyrants of the Middle east, will come to the end once Democratic and independence Kurdistan is become reality. Because the future Kurdistan is going to respect and protect all the minorities regardless of their ethnicity and religious believes and this alone will be revolution itself. Because people of the Middle East are tired of these wars, at the present Syrian civil war, so far 300 hundred thousands of people lost their life and 3 millions of people become refuge with their children because of this Sunni Crusade (Jihad) which is very sad. Because of that Kurd's shouldn't be part of this barbaric religion war other than liberating their land, and they should defend every part of the Kurdistan including the city of Kerkuk and surrendering areas because it is stained with the Kurdish blood.
The Kurdish Fire Wall | 26/12/2014
The choice is not easy,however.For the matter is quite complex.Another article in Rudaw is arguing the opposite.Yet, there is a third option: the search for some understanding with either sides of no agression,-of course once the Kurdish gains are consolidated and our military capabilities are boosted .Now the question is how much wisdom does the West have to stick to our position.The West must understand that Iraq is dead,as dead as a coffin nail, and that the resolution of this Shia versus Sunni conflict is,truly, beyond its reach.This war has been reignited and the West will never be able to change its course.We have to convince the West that it is in its best interest to commit to defence agreements with Kurdistan,Rojava included,creating thus a natural and effective fire wall in face of the conflict.It is impossible to influence otherwise the course of this war.Turkey,on its turn, should come to its senses and do not think that it is out of the reach of this conflict,and to avoid that from happening it should strengthen the Kurdish defences instead of collaborating with the IS as it is actually doing now.
journeyman | 26/12/2014
Well done Mr. Romano.
MALCOLM | 26/12/2014
Far too woolly a wargame seems to have been presented here, and far too bitchy an account of the motives and enduring good intentions of the US/EU. I do not believe you will be subject to permanent abandonment on the pretext of your military victories. If you have a substantial border town in your grasp, don't ignore the possibility and subsequent gains to be had from your posession of it. It seemed to matter in relation to the English/Scottish and English/Welsh border towns when we went through our bloody history!
Kurdistani | 26/12/2014
Arab allies? There is no such thing. We the Kurdistani have to start simplifying things. We need a free an independent Kurdish state. We need to build an army so powerful that all Arabs will never dare to even consider attacking us. All Kurdish parties and religious groups, all Lurdistani united under one flag for freedom and independence!!
Tags :
4873 Views

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

Argushi, USA | 10/19/2017 9:47:07 AM
Wow this young men has made history. this is why the world respect kurds. but unfortunately when when we need the world they are no where to be seen...
Atsiravla Ekroy | 10/19/2017 2:19:56 PM
At least he stands for something!
Young man who defied police by taking down Iraqi flag: I was ready to die for Kirkuk
| 12 hours ago | (7)
duroi | 10/19/2017 1:58:33 PM
Baghdad will gradually implement all the anti Kurdish tested policies of Iran and the Kurds in Iraq are slowly sinking in this swamp because of ...
Iraqi PM orders arrest of security guards for violations in Khanaqin, State TV
| 8 hours ago | (1)
A. | 10/19/2017 11:33:42 AM
Has Iraq a court? wow what kind of justice do they have there? Lol! Shut uuup Iraqi bullshiters. /Sincerley everyone on this planet
Long live Kosrat | 10/19/2017 12:28:28 PM
God bless Kosrat Rasul, Iraq's high court should issue an arrest of Al Abadi for letting Hashed to loot, rape, murder and humiliate Kurds in Kirkuk,...
Iraqi court issues arrest warrant for Kurdish Vice President Rasul
| 43 minutes ago | (7)
Darwin | 10/19/2017 12:22:01 PM
Really tragic how hatred can disolve all countries.. there is no point , just harrassing on the only damn planet we even see any sign of life. What...
Erdogan: Iraqi border may soon close on condition Baghdad meets KRG needs
| 9 hours ago | (1)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

KRG welcomes initiative by Abadi for dialogue 3 hours ago |

KRG welcomes initiative by Abadi for dialogue

Abadi said dialogue is the solution to begin a more
Anfal survivor: My house set on fire following Iraq’s takeover of Khurmatu 5 hours ago |

Anfal survivor: My house set on fire following Iraq’s takeover of Khurmatu

I used to live in a small house in Khurmatu. They more
0.329 seconds