Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment


Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using





A Very Different Ideology in the Middle East

By DAVID ROMANO 29/1/2015

Several years ago, my wife and I traveled to the Qandil mountains in Iraqi Kurdistan. We went to interview members of the Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK) and the Group of Communities in Kurdistan (KCK). We had a lengthy discussion with Remzi Kartal, one of the top leaders there at the time, who received us very graciously up in the high mountains. 

The interview left me feeling frustrated, however. His answer to every one of my more difficult questions seemed the same: “The application of the correct ecological democratic paradigmatic will transform society to overcome this problem,” or something along those lines. It all sounded to me like what the Turks call “Ocalanspeak,” a jargon only intelligible to fellow believers within the movement. It felt like someone was trying to sell me an old product in a new package.

For months after the interviews in Qandil, I made light of the whole thing. Whenever my wife would ask me a question I did not really feel like answering (“Why didn’t you take out the garbage last night?” or “Who left all the dirty dishes in the sink?”), I would reply that “The application of a democratic ecological paradigmatic will resolve this problem;” or “We will elect a committee of men and another committee of women to investigate the issue;” or “Do you have any relatives in prison who can tell us what to do about this?”

Nowadays I think I was mistaken, however. The discourse spreading from Qandil to northern Kurdistan, Rojava and even Western Turkey (via the People’s Democratic Party) is different from the Marxist-Leninism and militant nationalisms of the past. It also stands in the starkest possible contrast to the ideology of the Islamists, whether of the Islamist State variety or the somewhat less extreme variants. It just takes a bit of time and effort to see this, especially given confusing labels and jargon (which I will try to avoid), and also the dearth of polished diplomats that would normally explain such things. 

Free of jargon, the idea is to pursue a bottom-up, Athenian-style direct form of democratic governance. Local communities from the village level upwards take on as much self-government as they can, eschewing the strong central government model so favored in the region. Elections form councils whose members can be recalled at any time. The states people live under would thus become increasingly less relevant as each community seeks out its own preferred arrangements. 

In this new thinking, it is a mistake to fight to replace authoritarian and repressive Turkish, Arab and Persian mono-ethnic states with a Kurdish one, a state also at risk of falling prey to the same tendencies. The PKK’s founder, Abdullah Ocalan, thus came to criticize himself for past behavior:  “It has become clear that our theory, program and praxis of the 1970s produced nothing but futile separatism and violence and, even worse, that the nationalism we should have opposed infested all of us. Even though we opposed it in principle and rhetoric, we nonetheless accepted it as inevitable….dogmatism is nurtured by abstract truths which become habitual ways of thinking. As soon as you put such general truths into words you feel like a high priest in the service of his god. That was the mistake I made.”

A short column such as this cannot adequately explain much about such an alternative political program, of course (especially when the columnist is only now reappraising it). Readers might also legitimately point out that such rhetoric may sound great, but just like the fine-sounding constitutions of many states in the region, it may mean little in practice. Deeds count more than words. 

In their deeds the KCK have done some remarkable things, however, and in the most difficult of circumstances. The same movement that motivates so many and just liberated Kobane from the Islamic State empowers women both on the battlefield and in in its political institutions. A 40% quota for women’s participation and a co-chair system ensures that women play a role in every leadership position, rather than serving as objectified passive vessels of men’s honor. In both Syrian Kurdistan and Turkish Kurdistan, KCK municipalities include a diverse array of ethnicities and religions. They insist on celebrating not just Kurdish culture and language, but that of Assyrians, Armenians, Arabs, Turks and other local communities. This stands in remarkable contrast to the exclusionary secular nationalisms that took root in the region for so long. It is the polar opposite of the intolerant Islamist wave that swept through the past twenty years and proved so destructive to religions minorities, from Christians and Yezidis to Bahai’ and atheists. 

Given that the other ideological offerings in the Middle East appear to consist of authoritarianism, oligopolistic crony capitalist democracy and Islamism (or in the case of Turkey, an unlikely combination of all of the above), perhaps the world should help people like those of Kobane pursue their own, different path. While they may not be perfect and they may well disappoint, they certainly earned some respect and good will in the struggle against the Islamic State and other intolerant forces. The United States took a positive first step in this direction when it provided some arms and many air strikes to help the defenders of Kobane. Washington should do more, recognizing that this movement probably represents a much more progressive ally than others it has worked closely with in the past.

David Romano has been a Rudaw columnist since 2010. He is the Thomas G. Strong Professor of Middle East Politics at Missouri State University and author of The Kurdish Nationalist Movement (2006, Cambridge University Press) and co-editor (with Mehmet Gurses) of Conflict, Democratization and the Kurds in the Middle East (2014, Palgrave Macmillan).

The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the position of Rudaw.


Data pager
Page size:
FAUthman | 29/1/2015
If you can provide your people with a minimum of prosperity, security, human rights, and self rule, for starters, then call it whatever you may, Athenian democracy if you like. I was wondering where in some of the Rudaw comments I have read the language of "the application of the correct democratic ecological paradigmatic...etc." came from. Now I know. I recall hearing some of that in the mountains of Iraqi Kurdistan years ago. I think it comes from the isolation of the Kurds and their attempts to cloak nationalism in intellectual jargon when Marxism was popular. Glad we do not hear much of this anymore.
RCS | 29/1/2015
Hope the KRG will pour oil money into lobbyists and political contributions which will change the way the "oligopolistic crony capitalist democracy" in Washington currently operates. If enough money is poured in, US foreign policy probably will still originate in Tel Aviv but may swing by Erbil on it's way to Washington.
mepc | 29/1/2015
Is this same PKK in Sinjar?
Eco Critique | 29/1/2015
A very naive assessment of the PKK and its structure. Who is the leader of PKK? Ocalan is the leader since 1978. Who is the KCK leader? Cemil Bayik is the male leader. Bese Xozat is just a side kick. Who are the leading people in the KCK? Cemil Bayik, Duran Kalkan, M. Karasu, M. Karayilan, Sabri Ok, etc. These are all men; the rest is just window dressing. As to ecological revolution of the KCK, read Gunay Aslan (pro PKK columnist) and listen to Altan Tan about the situation in Kurdish cities such as Diyarbekir: unemployment, prostitution,and problems in shanty towns around the cities. Eco critique
You Sulphurus Fires ... | 30/1/2015
They do not utter words like'Kurd,Kurdish',let alone 'Kurdistan'.Instead,everything else.However,we assume that we are oppressed and denied of any rights only because we are Kurds and kurdish.True?. Is it a sin to claim being Kurd?.Curious how coincidently both Erdogan and the new PKK insist on Middle East identity and M.E.brotherhood.As a Kurd,I renegate from Islam and from Middle East altogether.Curse on the M.E. and on Islam.From the depth of my Kurdish heart,I cry:-Blow,winds,and crack your cheaks!rage !-You cataracts and hurricanoes,spout-Till you have drencht our steeples,drowned the cocks!-You sulphurous and thought-executing fires,-Vaunt-couriers to oak-cleaving thunderbolts,-Singe my white head !.
Tags :

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

Leon | 3/24/2019 8:03:06 AM
Sistani is not the governemnt, so get fucked. Iraq should use force to remove him.
Iraqi PM proposes parliament sacks Nineveh governor
| yesterday at 11:47 | (1)
Adam | 3/23/2019 2:49:50 PM
I wander what the Saudi royal family would say.
Gunrash | 3/24/2019 3:10:11 AM
Golan is Israeli just like Kirkuk, Amed, Mehabad and Afrin are Kurdish! Enough with the hypocrisy and selective indignation. UN is a joke.
Trump’s Golan statement draws strong regional condemnation
| yesterday at 08:49 | (4)
Adam | 3/23/2019 2:40:05 PM
Now the west especially America have the duty to reward the Kurds with real protection.
Kurde Canada | 3/24/2019 1:41:08 AM
God is no more with ISIS. They were just being used by him. They were betrayed.
SDF declare ‘total elimination’ of ISIS caliphate
| yesterday at 09:32 | (4)
TerraNova | 3/23/2019 10:02:06 PM
And now you show the world that The United States of America stands by it's allies and dose NOT abandon an ally that sacrificed thousands of brave...
Dutchman | 3/23/2019 11:18:00 PM
Trump is right when he sais that the US together with it's allies defeated ISIS. And it is also good that he wants to continue to work with his...
Trump: ISIS ‘are losers, will always be losers’
| 16 hours ago | (3)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

Mosul mourns victims of the ferry disaster 4 hours ago |

Mosul mourns victims of the ferry disaster

Grieving Mosul is not celebrating victory over more
Iraqi fishermen flounder on the Shatt al-Arab 15 hours ago |

Iraqi fishermen flounder on the Shatt al-Arab

Iran and Kuwait prevent them from fishing further more
Trump: ISIS ‘are losers, will always be losers’ 16 hours ago | (3)

Trump: ISIS ‘are losers, will always be losers’

"We will remain vigilant" more
0.235 seconds