Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment


Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using





Judge questions plan to release US detainee into Syrian war zone

By AFP 9/6/2018
In this undated photo, captives are held at a security facility. Photo: Shane T. McCoy | US Navy
In this undated photo, captives are held at a security facility. Photo: Shane T. McCoy | US Navy
by Paul Handley

WASHINGTON, D.C. — A federal judge questioned on Friday the US military's plan to dump a US citizen alleged to have joined the Islamic State group back into the Syrian war zone, a plan his lawyers said equalled a death sentence.

The Justice Department announced late Wednesday that US forces were preparing to release the man, a dual US-Saudi citizen identified only as "John Doe," into territory controlled by allied Syrian Democratic Forces as early as Saturday, after having held him as an alleged "enemy combatant" for nine months.

The plan is to give him food and water "for several days", a new cellphone, and the $4,210 he was originally captured with, but no identification, and leave him on his own in northeastern Syria where the SDF dominate.

In a hearing in the Washington federal court, Judge Tanya Chutkan asked Justice Department lawyers why there was a "rush" to release the man into a country so dangerous that the US State Department has warned against any travel and even advised potential visitors to "draft a will" first.

"We are in uncharted territory," she said. After months of battling over the man's rights as an uncharged battlefield detainee with US citizenship, "what is the urgency in this case?" she asked.

Government lawyer James Burnham defended the plan, saying the SDF is "a trusted local partner" of the US forces and the area is "much better, much safer" than where he was taken prisoner by the SDF last September.

The American Civil Liberties Union lawyer for "John Doe," Jonathan Hafetz, disputed this, saying the US still contends the man was a fighter for Islamic State before he was detained, and so the SDF would consider him an enemy.

According to the laws of war, Hafetz argued, "you can't release an alleged enemy prisoner into a place that is unsafe."

"It's like they are releasing him into a burning building," he said, calling it a "death warrant."

The case has become a test of the Trump administration's plan for handling Americans captured abroad fighting for jihadist groups.

The government spent months fighting in court against giving him legal representation, and has never charged him or offered evidence that he was a fighter for IS.

The man was born in the United States to Saudi parents. He denies having joined Islamic State and claimed he was in the area to do reporting, according to the ACLU.

The government first moved to transfer him to Saudi Arabia.

But his lawyers persuaded the court to block that, arguing that the US government has no right to summarily hand a US citizen over to another government with no charges or extradition proceedings.

Hafetz said the government could release the man in Iraq, where he has been held, giving him a chance to request a new passport at the US consulate there.

"He doesn't want to stay in prison but he doesn't want to go out where he is in grave danger," Hafetz said.

In the end, Chutkan, stressing the untested legal questions involved, persuaded the government lawyers to agree to hold off on the release until another hearing on June 20.

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

John Bird | 11/13/2018 6:35:32 AM
The Kurdish share in the budget is only $10 billion. That’s the Kurdish demand. If you declare independence today, even without Kirkuk, and modernize...
Iraqi MPs fail to pass gov’t proposed budget, will hear party complaints
| yesterday at 09:05 | (1)
INDEPENDENCE | 11/13/2018 6:06:11 AM
The KDP has won the elections but is being blackmailed by an armed group which is the PUK. The PUK is an armed group going after money and position....
Scant progress on government formation – months after KRG election
| 12/11/2018 | (1)
Unite | 11/12/2018 10:26:54 PM
If only posters are made out of every statement in this article and wallpaper every walls, billboards,buses and trains round the world with them. And...
Guest | 11/12/2018 11:00:14 PM
Martin Luther King Jr. once said, "People fail to get along because they fear each other; they fear each other because they don't know each other;...
World Order Without Kurdistan, Oops America!
| 12/11/2018 | (6)
Unite | 11/12/2018 10:43:59 PM
Whether Turkey telling lies, not telling the truth or playing political game; what is the difference? To me, it is all the same. Erdogan is a hard...
Turkey, France spar over Khashoggi killing
| yesterday at 11:56 | (1)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

Kurdish chop shop builds homemade Lamborghini 3 hours ago |

Kurdish chop shop builds homemade Lamborghini

It cost $40,000 to build using parts chopped from more
Syrian refugees in KRI want to return – but first need guarantees 4 hours ago |

Syrian refugees in KRI want to return – but first need guarantees

"No place is like your birthplace" more
Kurdish beardsman wins top Swedish hairdressing prize 6 hours ago |

Kurdish beardsman wins top Swedish hairdressing prize

Chia won first prize in Sweden's World Beard Day more
0.5 seconds