Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Login

Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using
 

Email

 

Rudaw

Culture & Art

28/4/2013
Erbil’s miniskirt schoolgirls
6358 Views
Don’t you just love sensationalist titles? I can just imagine the hot headed teenager rushing to open this link, only to be disappointed that I don’t have a photo gallery of what is now popularly referred to as “Erbil’s miniskirt schoolgirls”. Last week, we were all stuck on Ahlam al-Shamsi’s comment on the Kurdish contestant in the Arab idol singing competition, this week it seems our attention has been captivated by things more local, and closer to home.




Perhaps I should indulge the reader by giving some background information. A few days ago, the annual Festival of secondary schools was held in the city of Hewler. No one took notice, local media outlets barely took interest in the event – it happens every year, a bunch of schoolgirls walk around the stadium representing their school. It was never a big deal until, Lo and behold! A picture emerged of schoolgirls, wearing skirts that are just “too short” for the conservatives, and way to appealing for others.



Receiving dozens of shares, hundreds of likes, and thousands of comments – the picture has become a controversial topic. From Islamists criticising schools for allowing girls to be depicted in such a sexual way at a considerably young age, to liberals running to their defence in the name of freedom of expression. What intrigued me are not the skirts, it is a matter of personal choice, and since these girls are quite young, I believe it is a matter of parental guidance. However, the comments received are eye opening, and give an insight to Hewler.



Some people praised the young girls for defying what some see as the normative conservative attitude that is prevailing in this city; others were distasteful both in their comments and the delivery of such comments.




I found the comments shocking, someone replied to the picture posted by saying “They have no shame, I spit on them, how unfortunate for it to come to this” another said “And we criticised Silemani!” referring to another city which is often referred to as the most liberal out of the region. The comment that really got under my skin was “What is this, a school or whorehouse?”




It is unclear to me what the people were objecting to in the pictures – that girls can wear miniskirts or their own evil thoughts that prevailed upon seeing those pictures – all these children at the festival have guardians or parents, they did not leave their house without their parent’s consent, and their participation in the festival was consensual, therefore if the parents of these girls don’t object, why should other people, who have no relations to them whatsoever make a huge fuss?



It makes little sense for people to be overtly critical of something, in the most ill-mannered form possible when they are not even related to the incident.
My disappointment is with people who believe they are God-sent saviours of Hewler city, but unfortunately they are the worst examples of piety themselves. Once people follow the principles they want to shove down other people’s throats, then we will see a real change in our society.

Comments

 
Data pager
Previous
Page size:
PageSizeComboBox
select
Shkar Kider | 28/4/2013
Another great article. Keep it up. You've gone straight for the jugular. It is sad that our community is so blighted by what others think, far more than those affected by the incident.
Ruwayda Mustafah
Ruwayda Mustafah | 28/4/2013
Thanks for reading Kak Shkar.
Bakir Lashkari
Bakir Lashkari | 28/4/2013
Please, Please, Kurdistan is not Iran and not the Islamic extremists region. Let the schools, students and its the culture to cultivate in stead of of opressing and obliging the Kurdish people with a normative social control, based on the shariha relegious elements. Freedom form and from to the relgious supressions.
Raber Y. Aziz | 28/4/2013
Agreed. There were very distasteful comments on both sides, not only those who attacked it, but also those who supported it. Usually I avoid reading comments whenever there is a fuss over anything, I know they can be pretty nasty and the less I read comments the better. But sometimes you just can't help reading comments. Bottom line: Good job for the article. Everyone is free what they wear, do, think, regardless of their implications. As they say "No one will enter anybody else's tomb"
Dler | 28/4/2013
I total agree, unfortunately our society doesn't know the concept of "privacy", "personal choice" and "personal life"

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

Ashour Malek. Lebanon | 3/22/2017 3:20:30 AM
The entire north Iraq belongs to the Assyrian people, yet they live in their own ancestral land as a second class citizens, and deprived from any...
Mesopotamia | 3/22/2017 5:22:17 AM
Statement made in 2:03 has no historical basis and it's a total nonsense. Hopefully the person is not a historian. Medes entered Iran ~ 1200 BC and...
3,000 year old tombs unearthed at Erbil construction site
| 20/3/2017 | (3)
JPL | 3/22/2017 1:19:54 AM
Those are not tourists you dumb ass. Those are Kurds from Rojhilat. The only non Kurdish tourists that venture into Kurdistan are Arab IDP and ISIS...
abc | 3/22/2017 3:47:14 AM
Kurdistan could get 1 million tourists with the right planning.
Kurdish tourist industry slowly recovering after two years of decline
| yesterday at 10:50 | (3)
Terence Mc Mahon | 3/21/2017 11:16:44 PM
Wow, that's sounds fantastic. I love the idea that the fires would be lit up with no regard to borders. Stay strong Kurdish brothers and unite. From...
Newroz | 3/22/2017 3:37:11 AM
Newroz piroz be
VIDEO: Centuries of Newroz fire fueling Kurdish spirit of resistance, survival
| 20/3/2017 | (2)
Kajik | 3/21/2017 10:23:15 PM
UN is an corrupt organization that only benefits the best paying country's. Why aren't UN concerned about the non implementation of article 140?...
Rebwar | 3/22/2017 1:44:16 AM
The UN is concerned about raising Kurdish flag in a Kurdish city? Why isn't the UN concerned about Turkey committing war crimes in Kurdish cities and...
UN cautions against flying Kurdish flag in Kirkuk
| yesterday at 06:54 | (7)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

Kurdish vocalist Aynur Dogan receives prestigious award for excellence 15/3/2017 | (1)

Kurdish vocalist Aynur Dogan receives prestigious award for excellence

Her music focuses on the life and suffering of more
UPDATED: Iraqi forces control New Mosul, struggle to enter Old City 14/3/2017 | (2)

UPDATED: Iraqi forces control New Mosul, struggle to enter Old City

They are facing a scaled-up, aggressive use of more
PUK and Iraqi PM Abadi agree to keep Kirkuk’s oil flow to Turkey 8/3/2017 | (8)

PUK and Iraqi PM Abadi agree to keep Kirkuk’s oil flow to Turkey

Oil ministry has added a processing unit with 10k more
0.5 seconds