Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Login

Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using
 

Email

 

Rudaw

Analysis

Mosul operation will drag on into early, mid-2017, analysts predict

By Paul Iddon 1/1/2017
An Iraqi soldier with a rocket-propelled grenade in Mosul. Photo: Ahmad al-Rubaye/AFP
An Iraqi soldier with a rocket-propelled grenade in Mosul. Photo: Ahmad al-Rubaye/AFP
As the campaign against ISIS in Mosul entered its second phase on Thursday, analysts consulted by Rudaw English estimated that the entire operation to retake the city will continue into mid-2017 at the latest. 

This comes shortly after the commander of the US campaign against ISIS, Lt. Gen. Stephen J. Townsend, said that the entire war against ISIS, the recapture of both Mosul and Raqqa, will last as long as two years. 

“People need to rest,” Townsend told The Daily Beast. “They need to assess how things are going because they are not going as fast as we thought.” He went on to add that this was something they warned the Iraqis about beforehand.  

“The general seemed to be referring to the entire campaign,” said Michael Knights, the Washington Institute's Lafer Fellow, “so nobody has suggested Mosul's liberation will take two years. I can see Mosul's liberation lasting until mid-2017.”

“East Mosul will likely be recaptured by January, February and West Mosul by February, April or May,” he added. 

Joel Wing, an Iraq analyst who runs the Musings on Iraq blog, echoed Knights' estimate. 

“I would think that summer 2017 would be the long estimate on recapturing Mosul,” he said. “I'm thinking more like the spring but you never know.” 

Wing’s uncertainty stems from the upcoming offensive against ISIS in Mosul's west. 

“There doesn't appear to be any consensus on how Western Mosul will be like compared to the east,” he explained. “Heavy fighting, future pauses could all lead to the campaign being finalized by the summer.” 

Launched on October 17, the Iraqi Army's push into Mosul was paused as part of a pre-planned “operational refit” for nearly a month before the second phase kicked off on Thursday. To date the battle has seen Iraqi forces, with US-led coalition air and artillery support, pushing into the city's eastern districts. So far they have captured approximately a quarter of the city from the militants.  

US military advisors are embedding more directly with the Iraqis to oversee the operation. The coalition has also bombed the remaining bridge over the Tigris River connecting east and west Mosul to make it more difficult for ISIS to resupply and reorganize its forces between the two sides of the vast metropolis.

Unlike previous operations to recapture the much smaller and less-populated cities of Ramadi and Fallujah in Anbar province, this operation is seeing much more fighting on the ground. 

Continuous coalition fire support in Mosul as seen in those past battles would displace far more civilians, potentially destroy more of the city, and add to the already enormous population of displaced persons in the neighbouring Kurdistan Region. Baghdad urged the civilians of Mosul to remain in their homes throughout the course of the operation, partially in order to avoid another humanitarian crisis. 

Mosul is the last major urban stronghold ISIS has left in Iraq and the largest city the group has ever managed to conquer. Iraq's Prime Minister Haider al-Abadi had previously expressed hopes that the city will be recaptured by the end of 2016. He recently backtracked on this estimate in light of the aforementioned pause, saying it will likely take another three months, indicating that it will be liberated around springtime. 

“I think the operation to retake Mosul will take longer than first thought, but not as long as two years,” said Dylan O'Driscoll, a fellow at the Middle East Research Institute (MERI) in Erbil who has written critically and extensively on the lack of pre-battle plans for the operation. 

“It is a different battle to that of Raqqa,” he elaborated, “with everyone collaborating in reaching the common goal of defeating the Islamic State.” 

“The operation is now reaching difficult city terrain and has slowed down significantly, but I think there are too many probabilities to make estimates of completion at this time,” O'Driscoll reasoned. 

“However, for the people of Mosul, the operation needs to happen as fast as possible, whilst taking their safety into account, and one would hope that it does not drag out too far into the year,” he concluded.

 

Comments

 
duroi | 2/1/2017
The Mosul battle is actually like two battles, the east side and the west side. And the operations are much more difficult than Ramadi and Fallujah put together and the overextended logistic supply lines for west of Mosul are very exposed. East of Mosul will fall by summer, but the west of Mosul will be more difficult than the siege of Aleppo.
waveshaper | 2/1/2017
Something for all these Battle of Mosul experts to keep in mind; Folks don't realize how long it took us to secure Mosul when we had 150,000 plus U.S. combat troops on the ground in Iraq. After the first Battle of Mosul ended in November 2004 the Sunni/AQI/ISI insurgents moved right back into Western Mosul in December of 2004. For the next 43 months the bad guys controlled Western Mosul and attacked coalition forces every single day. During these 43 months there was a stalemate, Eastern Mosul/Mosul airport was controlled by U.S. forces/Peshmerga/Iraqi Army and Western Mosul was controlled by Sunni insurgents/AQI/ISI. We didn't take control of Western Mosul until July 2008. Ref; 2004 Battle of Mosul, Ninawa Campaign, etc, etc.
PenGun | 4/1/2017
This is the same Michael Knights who said it would be much easier and quicker than we expect. He knows very little, like most of the 'wish tanks' these days.

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

Adstar | 7/25/2017 3:38:26 AM
She made her own bed.. Now she can sleep in it.. You can be assured most Germans will not want her back.. They do not support the death penalty but...
green activist defector | 7/25/2017 12:22:14 PM
joshcka fischer the "green activist" and turkish lobbyist in berlin maybe can talk to his boss in ankara to solve this girls situation.
German girl who joined ISIS wants to leave Iraq, return to family
| yesterday at 11:45 | (10)
Gorran is betrayal | 7/25/2017 11:31:12 AM
Russia recognizes the right of the Kurds on indpendence , but Gorran denies the Kurds the right to hold the referendeum on independence.
kurd | 7/25/2017 11:33:27 AM
when he talks to turkish and iranian newspapers, he condemns kurdish independence. some of these comments show how many are naive
Sergey Lavrov to Rudaw: Referendum is expression of Kurdish people’s aspirations
| yesterday at 08:55 | (8)
Gorran is betrayal | 7/25/2017 11:22:49 AM
Gorran is treason , is anti-kurdish .
alan | 7/25/2017 11:29:41 AM
A new leader who is not family member of the former leader? If KDP or PUK gets a new leader he will be from the same family. Thanks we have Gorran...
New Gorran leader: We can achieve party’s objectives through dialogue
| 10 hours ago | (2)
Dana | 7/25/2017 10:47:59 AM
All that useless repetition of obvious information made the article horrible to read, not to mention that it missed the most important detail, which...
Al-Qaida in Syria close to snuffing out competition in north
| 16 hours ago | (1)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

NRT TV owner announces vote-no campaign for referendum 5 hours ago |

NRT TV owner announces vote-no campaign for referendum

He called referendum a “dangerous gamble with more
Kurdish official says US role essential in post-IS Syria 6 hours ago |

Kurdish official says US role essential in post-IS Syria

Americans " must continue until a democratic more
PM Abadi: I won’t deploy tanks to Kurdistan in response to referendum 7 hours ago |

PM Abadi: I won’t deploy tanks to Kurdistan in response to referendum

PM Abadi: “I mean, what I will do? Will I deploy more
0.328 seconds