Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Login

Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using
 

Email

 

Rudaw

Analysis

Can Turkey drive a wedge between the US and YPG?

By Paul Iddon 3/5/2017
This AFP photo shows US officers from the US-led coalition when visiting fighters with the Kurdish People’s Protection Units (YPG) at the site of Turkish airstrikes near northeastern Syrian Kurdish town of Derik on April 25, 2017.
This AFP photo shows US officers from the US-led coalition when visiting fighters with the Kurdish People’s Protection Units (YPG) at the site of Turkish airstrikes near northeastern Syrian Kurdish town of Derik on April 25, 2017.

 

Continued US support for the Syrian Kurdish People's Protection Units (YPG) against Islamic State (ISIS) will undoubtedly be on top of the agenda for Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan when he visits Washington this month. 
 
The US plan to use the YPG-led Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF) coalition remains unchanged as tensions between Turkey and the YPG intensify, in light of Turkey's April 25 attack on the group in northern Syria and the tense situation on the border. 
 
Despite alarming the US by failing to provide it adequate warning for the April 25 strike the Turkish government is adamant that it might attack the YPG again anytime it chooses. US armored vehicles flying American flags were dispatched to the border to try and prevent both sides from clashing. It's unlikely to succeed if Turkey launches more attacks and border clashes ensue. 
 
The US doesn't have enough forces on the ground in Syria to prevent both sides from clashing. Furthermore, it is unlikely to risk actually trying to force YPG fighters back from the border during clashes – since it would then be accused by that group of aiding Turkish attacks against them – and is even more unlikely to set up some kind of no-fly zone against a NATO ally. Even if it did go so far as doing the latter most major Kurdish areas in Syria could still be targeted in cross-border Turkish artillery strikes. 
 
For its part Ankara needs to avoid accidentally hitting and killing US forces in these areas when carrying out future attacks on YPG positions. 
 
For years now the US has sought to reassure the Turks about the nature of their cooperation with the YPG. Anytime Turkey and the YPG have clashed Washington has urged them to cease and desist and focus their efforts on fighting ISIS. This delicate balancing act is unlikely going to prove sufficient indefinitely, especially now that tensions between the two sides are increasing. 
 
Turkey has long suggested that it could partner with the US to capture Raqqa while sidelining the YPG and using armed Syrian groups as proxies instead – groups such as the Free Syrian Army (FSA) forces Turkey backed against ISIS in al-Bab earlier this year or Arab groups in the SDF, provided they sever their ties with the YPG. Ankara's recent attack on the YPG seems geared toward goading that group into aborting the Raqqa operation in favour of fighting off the Turkish military on the border. This would be the perfect outcome for Ankara, since it could expand its attacks against the YPG while urging Washington to accept it and its allies as a substitute in the Raqqa operation. 
 
US failure to deter Turkey from hitting YPG targets is bound to lead that group to distrust the United States and its intentions. If they believe they have no guarantees of protection now before Raqqa is captured they are unlikely to logically conclude that Washington will go out on a limb to pressure Turkey to cease attacks on them after ISIS's demise – when the US military will likely draw-down, if not completely withdraw, since their primary objective there will have been achieved. 
 
Ankara has always been happy to militarily combat ISIS when they can simultaneously achieve their primary objectives of confronting or containing the Kurdistan Workers' Party (PKK) /YPG. It permitted the US-led coalition to use Incirlik Airbase against ISIS in Syria after forbidding them from doing so between the summer of 2014 and 2015, when the war between them and the PKK recommenced. 
 
Additionally Ankara's recently concluded Euphrates Shield operation in northwest Syria had the dual objective of removing ISIS from its border while ensuring the YPG were unable to move into that region – and in doing so link-up their far-flung and isolated Afrin Canton with their contiguous northeastern territories, stretching from the Iraqi border to the east bank of the Euphrates River. 
 
Erdogan will certainly welcome the prospect of using Turkish military forces to help capture Raqqa if it served the purpose of sidelining the YPG and ensuring the group doesn't control Raqqa after ISIS. The Turkish president is also likely calculating that helping eradicate the ISIS threat would greatly lessen, if not remove completely, the YPG's ad-hoc usefulness to the United States as well, giving him a free hand to forcibly subdue them.

Comments

 
Data pager
Previous
12
Page size:
PageSizeComboBox
select
Help the Ezidis | 3/5/2017
The YPJ- and YPG-forces are so numerous and if the Kurdish friends in Turkey and Iran go on with entering and helping their Syrian Kurdish allies, it is for the US very clear that they cannot abandon these Syrian force. Do not forget that the USA remembers very well that the Turks blocked the assault on Northern Iraq during Saddams dictatorship and that Turkey wants to buy Russian air missiles although it is a hated NATO- member. So heroes of the YPJ- and YPG and all your allies go on with your excellent battle and ask for a no-fly zone inside Syria!!!
Dutchman | 3/5/2017
Ever since Kobani no one can drive a wedge between the US and YPG. Turkey not, Russia not, Iran not and Assad not. The SDF is the only hope for Syria and the YPG is leading it like the US is leading a broad coalition for democracy.
Hal | 3/5/2017
The Kurds of Rojava must NOT fall for Turkeys trap, ISIL is even a bigger threat to Kurds than Turkey. ISIL in Syria turned all it's resourses on taking Rojava, they ethnically cleansed big chunks of Roajava with Turkeys help the first year, if they're not destroyed and get stronger again (or merg with Al-Qaeda as that's what seems to be happening now) they'll turn most if their attention on Kurds, NOTHING should deter Kurds from destroying ISIL! Other forces like PKK can step up and keep the Turkish army busy in case they attack.
Erdal | 3/5/2017
Since the clown Donald Duck Trump who has no idea about the international affairs he will buy any B.S that the new Turkish Messiah will sale him.
pre-Boomer Marine brat | 3/5/2017
Unless I'm mistaken, the Turkish miltary is using ONLY aerial munitions and artillery against ISIS. No Turkish troops have gone in on house-to-house fighting against ISIS. (If I am correct) why is that? ... In Korea, Chinese commanders had serious morale problems among their infantry facing the Turkish Brigade. ... Why does that no longer seem to be the case?

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

altani | 7/23/2017 4:46:13 PM
I don't care what happens in Syria, Iraq or Iran. However I do care what happens in Turkey. Turkey will never, ever be divided. I rather would have a...
Kobane-senah | 7/24/2017 4:11:39 AM
@Gerbert d'Aurillac Im kurdish american and love america however warn you put too much trust in amis politicians. Lets keep in mind our worst enemy...
KRG independence wouldn’t stir up separatism in other Kurdistans
| yesterday at 09:39 | (6)
FAUthman | 7/24/2017 2:19:58 AM
These guys need to lose some weight around their middle. With a pot belly like that as defense minister for Iraq and the other guy who is a spokesman...
Kobane | 7/24/2017 4:03:14 AM
Its disgusting all these bullshit of unity while no one asked kurdish people what they want. These full should know being poppets of big powers to...
Peshmerga to Iraqi defense chief: We defend ourselves in face of any possible threats
| 18 hours ago | (8)
FAUthman | 7/23/2017 12:44:31 PM
Looks like Putin is using Maliki to get the Americans out of Iraq when ISIS is defeated and to bolster Maliki to defeat Abadi in the forthcoming...
Jagerxin derashy | 7/24/2017 4:02:09 AM
If anyone is responsible for rise of Isis and fall of Mosul is you nori almaliki you treated sunnis like dirt and abused them!! you sad bastard if it...
Iraqi VP Maliki on official visit to Moscow, scheduled to meet President Putin
| yesterday at 02:00 | (2)
Bilal | 7/23/2017 11:02:00 PM
Shia Iran should just rename Iraq as a province of Iran its a vassel state of Iran at best not a nation partition is the only way forward.
History | 7/24/2017 1:26:23 AM
As much as I like Kurds to be independent country .. Turkey, Iran, Iraq and Syria will never allow it. Obviously to have freedom and respect the...
Kurdistan cannot secede from Iraq, predicts former PM Maliki
| 21/7/2017 | (13)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

Journalists from Turkish daily face trial today 3 hours ago |

Journalists from Turkish daily face trial today

The 17 include reporters and administrators more
Army stays out of referendum dispute: Iraq defense chief 5 hours ago |

Army stays out of referendum dispute: Iraq defense chief

Iraq Defense minister: As for the referendum, the more
German girl who joined ISIS wants to leave Iraq, return to family 6 hours ago |

German girl who joined ISIS wants to leave Iraq, return to family

"I just want to go home to my family more
0.219 seconds