Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment


Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using





Russia and Rojava autonomy

By Paul Iddon 5/10/2017
A man with a flag of the Syrian Kurdish People's Protection Units (YPG). File photo: AP/ Serkan Gurbuz
A man with a flag of the Syrian Kurdish People's Protection Units (YPG). File photo: AP/ Serkan Gurbuz
After Islamic State (ISIS) is finally defeated in Syria, Damascus says it is open to negotiating with the country's Kurdish minority over recognizing the country's de-facto autonomous Kurdish territories. It's the interests of Russia, a key backer of Damascus, to help make these negotiations a success. 

Presently the Kurdish-led Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF) group has removed ISIS from most of Raqqa, its so-called capital, and has also forced the militants from large swaths of Deir ez-Zor. The regime also advanced into Deir ez-Zor in a separate campaign. The Euphrates River has acted as an, albeit imperfect, demarcation line for the separate areas of responsibility in that province. The risk of these two campaigns, where US-backed SDF and Russian-backed regime forces are in very close proximity to each other, clashing were apparent last month when Russian warplanes bombed SDF positions. 

But a war between Damascus and the SDF is in the interests of neither Damascus or Moscow, argues Professor Joshua Landis, a Syrian expert and head of Middle East Studies at the University of Oklahoma. 

“If Syria goes to war against the Kurds who have US backing, it could be ruinous to the government,” Landis told Rudaw English. 

“The government's situation is already facing many challenges,” he added. “Russia has been trying to encourage Damascus to talk to the Kurdish authorities about autonomy for over a year without any success. Russia looks on the Kurds as allies and hopes to head off a war between the two.”

Back in January Russia put forward a draft constitution for Syria which notably included provisions for Kurdish autonomy and language rights. 

Timur Akhmetov, a researcher at the Russian International Affairs Council, argues that Russia's policy towards the Syrian Kurds “are shaped by several factors.” 

“Kurds are now in control over large swaths of territory, they have effective and rigid military units in their disposal,” Akhmetov told Rudaw English. “Several times Russian officials pointed at the Kurd's physical control over territories as a prime reason why they should have participated in the Geneva negotiations.”

The fact that the Kurds have successfully avoided war with Damascus, of which Russia is the primary military backer, means that Russian interests are not at stake in dealing with them and even making concessions with them to avert further conflict in Syria – where the regime has retaken most of the country with decisive backing from Moscow. 

Akhmetov calculates that the SDF advance into Deir Ez-Zor, which accelerated earlier this month mere days after the aforementioned major regime offensive against ISIS into the same province began, “might be driven by plans to either seize control over the oil fields to trade them during talks with Damascus.”

“Alternatively,” he went on to suggest, “Kurds may want to keep the fields to support its polity in the long run under substantial support of the US.”

Either way, the “ultimate goal” of these Kurds “is to gain autonomy, and by proposing mediation in their talks with Damascus, along with limited international support, Russia may want to keep initiative.”

“Besides, by keeping the autonomy issue on the agenda Russia may want to encourage Kurds to participate in the Geneva talks as a part of the opposition without being substantially hostile to the central government,” Akhmetov added. 

When it comes to autonomy for Syria's Kurds the elephant in the room is obviously Turkey. Ankara is staunchly opposed to the ruling Syrian Kurdish Democratic Union Party (PYD) in the Syrian Kurdish territories and has attacked them numerous times in recent years arguing that this group as no different than the Kurdistan Workers Party (PKK). 

“The best way for Russia to convince the Turks about autonomy will be if the US is brought into the negotiations,” Landis said. “Turkey is likely to listen to both Russia and the US.”

Akhmetov suggests that Russia might be trying to make a case “whereby any form of Kurdish autonomy is a given fact, leaving Turkey with two options: either watch how the Americans arm and invest in the Kurds and turn them into their proxies in the region or keep cooperating with Russia, who eventually genuinely may acknowledge Turkish concerns and channel autonomy talks in a tolerable way for them.”


kurt basar | 5/10/2017
They are going to get their autonomy regardless of what the Turkish terror state's ISIL/Muslim barbarians or Iranian savages and Ayatollahs say or do. Because it's land of their ancestor well before arrival of the Turkish barbarians, Arab & Iranian savages. Kurd's are ones who named the landscape (pour-hat river, Golan, Mare, Kumani river, Rastan, Char-chemi, ETC, AND ALSO WHERE THE GARDEN OF THE EDEN "E-DEN" HOUSE OF DIVAN IS LOCATED) before British named the Syria because of the past Assyrians empire.
Riha | 6/10/2017
Disband the SDF, kick the Americans out and bring Russia in. Same to Iraqi Kurds. If they can use their God given brains..........
Nonviolence | 6/10/2017
As they say : the Kurds have no friends but the mountains. The negative reaction to the Kurdish referendum of world and regional powers proved and confirmed that, unfortunately, the kurds have no friends. It is time for all Kurds to unite and forget their diffrences. I hope the kurds in Syria, Turkey, Iran and especially Iraq will recognize that and work together no matter what different ideology they have.
Masque du Furet | 17/10/2017
"the Kurds have no friends but the mountains. " Rojava are mostly plains (so are Arbil and Kerkuk...) and mountains could be efficient a century ago (no drones, no satellite). With Iraqi Kurdestan crisis, Iran seems to be great again, making strategic role of Rojava bigger ... if US understand it (it means : not only limited -not to upset Erdogan- military support, but economic (Raqqa seems very destroyed) and politic support.). If US do not understand (on the European side, a lot of European money was spent trying to support peace in Palestine .. and wasted : European are likely to be fed up with Middle East), worse conditions than those leading to the expansion of ISIS will go on (and I do not know whether Arab tribes, whose houses were destroyed by US air force, will keep being US friendly for a long time). I think US wonot understand (US help to poor countries decreases: Iraq and Syria are almost ruined , due to war) ... and make Iran great again...

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

K H | 1/17/2019 3:34:52 AM
How can the USA say they will protect the Kurds when, under Obama, they signed an agreement with Turkey which allowed Turkey to go on the offensive...
Gulen Turk | 1/17/2019 5:11:12 AM
they should politely ask Turkey to stop helping ISIS ...
Masrour Barzani discusses protection of Syrian Kurds with US general
| 16 hours ago | (4)
Outsider | 1/16/2019 10:22:15 PM
The best is.... UN forces to control and administer the area... insuring the rights of all ethnic groups and political views (not just YPG/PYD)......
Russian | 1/17/2019 5:08:48 AM
This guy is a perfect picture of hypocrisy , he is full of dishonesty , he is a product of a bankrupt country ....
Assad must take control of northern Syria: Russian FM
| 22 hours ago | (6)
pre-Boomer Marine brat | 1/17/2019 1:24:10 AM
Trump, Pence and their political company are making the mistake of thinking of ISIS as a political-military organization which sees itself as...
Tracy | 1/17/2019 5:04:55 AM
If you want to destroy ISIS ..destroy Turkey first , Turkey is keeping ISIS alive ...God bless the USA
US stays committed to ‘destruction’ of terrorism: Pentagon
| 11 hours ago | (3)
UK | 1/17/2019 5:01:18 AM
Why ISIS is still alive ? Turkey is their main supporter ....
Sulaimani security arrest ‘dangerous’ ISIS militant
| 12 hours ago | (1)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

Iran FM says Tehran wants to rebuild Iraq after ISIS fight 2 hours ago |

Iran FM says Tehran wants to rebuild Iraq after ISIS fight

But an Iranian company could help rebuild at "low more
Shiite militiamen clash with federal police in Kirkuk hospital 19 hours ago |

Shiite militiamen clash with federal police in Kirkuk hospital

Three Hashd militants were injured and the others more
Coalition targeted in Manbij explosion, US and civilian fatalities 20 hours ago | (10)

Coalition targeted in Manbij explosion, US and civilian fatalities

ISIS has claimed responsibility, saying coalition more
1.156 seconds