Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Login

Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using
 

Email

 

Rudaw

Analysis

What does Turkey have to fear about Kurdish independence?

By Paul Iddon 8/7/2017
Kurdistan President Masoud Barzani (L) and Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan. Photo: AA
Kurdistan President Masoud Barzani (L) and Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan. Photo: AA
The Kurdistan Region's announcement that it will be holding a referendum on independence on September 25 was met with opposition from Turkish officials, with the Turkish Foreign Ministry calling it a “grave mistake.” Despite the thaw in relations between Ankara and Erbil over the course of the last decade Turkey still contends that independence for the Kurdistan Region would be a negative development. 

“Turkey continues to oppose Kurdish independence,” Joel Wing, an Iraq analyst who runs the Musings for Iraq blog, told Rudaw English. “With the heightened conflict with the PKK [Kurdistan Workers' Party] inside Turkey and then the Syrian Kurds, having Iraqi Kurdistan declare independence would just be an added headache for Ankara.” 

Wing points out that this is so “even though the PKK and its affiliates in Syria do not call for independence but rather a form of autonomy.” 

“I'm not sure Erdogan really sees any distinction,” he reasoned. “They are all means to self-determination and Turkey sees that as a threat to its nation-state and the region. That's especially true now as Erdogan is becoming more and more autocratic.”

Kurdistan President Masoud Barzani is welcomed as a respected statesman by Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan when he goes on state visits to Turkey. In recent years Ankara has made a point of displaying the Kurdish flag during these visits, even flying it prominently over Ataturk International Airport in Istanbul. Erdogan's own visit to Erbil in 2011, the first time a Turkish leader visited the Region, saw Turkish and Kurdish flags flown alongside each other in the Kurdish capital.

“We have an historic relationship with Iraq and with this beautiful region,” Erdogan said in a speech at the time. He also went so far as to declare that, “The security of Erbil means the security of Turkey.”

While Turkey did not send forces to defend Erbil when it was threatened by ISIS in August 2014, it has since treated wounded Kurdish Peshmerga soldiers, an act which shows how clearly it distinguishes the Kurdistan Region to its Kurdish enemies: the PKK and the Syrian Kurdish People's Protection Units (YPG). 

The thaw in relations is remarkable considering that Turkey long viewed the Kurdistan Region's autonomy as a possible threat to its own security. Ten years ago it frequently threatened to militarily intervene if Kirkuk was incorporated into the Region. At that time Barzani invariably said such a move on Turkey's part would be disastrous, repeatedly affirming that the rights of the Turkmen in Kirkuk would be respected and that Turkey had no right to march its forces over Kurdistan's borders. 

“If Turkey thinks it can bring fire into our home they have to know they'll also be caught by fire,” Barzani once warned, a statement which clearly indicated that his region has no intention of meddling in the affairs of its neighbours provided they did not first do so in Kurdistan. This is a stance that even the most neutral countries on the planet would take if facing the prospect of coming under unilateral military attack.

Today the Kurdistan Region is the only neighbour Turkey has genuinely friendly relations with. 

“Perhaps the KRG [Kurdistan Regional Government] remains the only entity in our immediate region that Ankara feels at ease with,” wrote Cansu Çamlibel, a Turkish journalist with the country's prominent Hurriyet newspaper, earlier this year.

Barzani also hasn't supported the PKK in its campaign against Turkey. In recent years he has invariably called for a negotiated settlement to the three-decade conflict. In his visit to Turkey in February, Barzani raised the issue of imprisoned members of the Kurdish Peoples' Democratic Party (HDP) when meeting with Erdogan and also expressed his willingness to help restart the peace process, which collapsed in the summer of 2015. 

Turkish officials may be opposing independence for the Kurdistan Region in public while quietly telling Erbil it will accept a declaration provided it is achieved following extensive negotiations and agreements with Baghdad, which is exactly what the Region is doing. If not, they may risk undermining the fruitful and historic headway made in its bilateral relationship with the Kurdistan Region, along with another historic opportunity of having the only independent Kurdish nation state in the world as a peaceful neighbour whose record demonstrates that it understands Turkey's legitimate concerns and interests in the Region. 

Kurdistan would also be a neighbour with which Ankara could broker effective settlements to end its own conflicts with Kurdish groups in the southeast and in Syria. Such a development would be beneficial for all parties involved.

Comments

 
Dler | 8/7/2017
You know what Turkey US Europe Trump Erdogan all the same shit united against Kurdish indipendence. I dont think they secretly accept Kurdish indipendence they are realy against it. If its about Kurds the whole world will be against us. So at least we should unite.
KurdPerwer | 9/7/2017
No one builds a roof without walls to hold it firs. I hope that Kurdish government has thought about this. Get millions of rounds of anti-tanks and anti-air crafts. Have a team of volunteer village guards in every Kurdish village. Spread points of defence along the border with the enemies and within Kurdistan itself. Fellow peshmergas, your fingers should be on the trigger constantly when you carry a gun.Train even your children to shoot and stab the enemy. Erdogan, the father of ISIS, might release his ISIS dogs at any unexpected border points to unleash havoc on Kurdish villages and towns. Stop letting Arabs come and live in Kurdistan. No one with the right mind lets their enemies to come and live in their house.Are you guys sleeping? Do you have any idea how these Arabs talk and behave towards Kurds outside Kurdistan? Have you forgotten the blood of Kurdish citizen on their hands? Any Kurd with even a slight piece of brain will remember what these savages have done to our people(women, girls, kids, the elderly and rest)..enough is enough. Enemies of Kurds can go to H.E.L.L.
Realist Kurd is here | 9/7/2017
The Kurds in the Middle East should get together and make a united front against those of that who are opposing Kurdish independent. This is the only solution for a Kurdish state. However, the Kurds including some of our traitor leaders are far from accepting each other and still are very good at fighting each other and selling out their next of kin in other countries in the Middle East to their enemies.
Mehrdad | 11/7/2017
Dont fall for a second for the Turkish thugs up north; it is no honor to be accepted in the arms of the Islamist thug fascist Erdogan; unite with PKK,PUK,YPG,PJAK, and create a country open TO THE WORLD, NOT THE ISOLATED TURKISH JUNTA IN POWER AT THE MOMENT. This, and not Erdogan support, is the key to our success; stop demonizing the lions and brave women defending Kobane, and made Rojava a reality, and open Semelka River to the people wanting settlements in basur; these are our brothers and sisters.
Post a New Comment
Comment as a guest or Login for more enhanced interactive experience

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

bain | 7/22/2017 7:56:22 PM
This guy is mad! he has funded dozens of these shia militias and they now outnumbering the Iraqi army 5:1, most are loyal to a foreign cou...
Iraqi PM Abadi: Hashd al-Shaabi is from us and we are from them
| 9 hours ago | (1)
Wisdom Siayor | 7/22/2017 7:02:29 PM
CIA and America should stop toppling government in the world for humanity sack. A lot of lives have been lost due to these reckless endeavours, but...
US officials: Foreign ISIS fighters won’t leave caliphate; Baghdadi alive
| 12 hours ago | (1)
Persian Milf | 7/22/2017 4:41:37 PM
@alavi foundation...check out "imam foundation"..they are "aiding" in the states...
IranMan | 7/22/2017 5:55:41 PM
@Yam, the Iranian-American community has the right to ensure Iran will not follow the same fate as Iraq, Libya, etc. That is very different from your...
US threatens Iran with 'serious consequences' if American citizens not released
| 21 hours ago | (5)
Muraz Adzhoev | 7/22/2017 5:54:14 PM
If Gorran was "serious", they would have started negotiations with the KDP before their new leader is elected. Is not Gorran a "democratic" party...
FAUthman | 7/22/2017 5:55:30 PM
Gorran wants to to torpedo the referendum. That much is clear.
Gorran may speak with KDP on independence, parliament after new leaders set
| 11 hours ago | (2)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

Businessman first to open Kurdish bread factory in Germany 7 hours ago |

Businessman first to open Kurdish bread factory in Germany

The owner of the factory has plans to expand more
EU official calls Germany’s new policies towards Turkey ‘understandable’ 8 hours ago |

EU official calls Germany’s new policies towards Turkey ‘understandable’

Erdogan: You do not have the power to defame more
Iraqi PM Abadi: Hashd al-Shaabi is from us and we are from them 9 hours ago | (1)

Iraqi PM Abadi: Hashd al-Shaabi is from us and we are from them

Abadi stressed "it is our duty to protect them." more
0.141 seconds