Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Login

Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using
 

Email

 

Rudaw

Analysis

Is Iraq prepared for the day after ISIS in Mosul?

By Paul Iddon 10/5/2017
Iraq's elite Counter-Terrorism Services (ICTS) advance towards the Yabasat neighbourhood in West Mosul on March 23. Photo: AFP
Iraq's elite Counter-Terrorism Services (ICTS) advance towards the Yabasat neighbourhood in West Mosul on March 23. Photo: AFP
As Iraqi forces continues to advance against ISIS militants in West Mosul, their defeat is inevitable, which raises the salient question about Iraq's readiness and preparation for administrating the city after the militants’ removal. 

Analysts on Iraq, while worried, do believe there are some glimmers of hope that the city can be substantially stabilized after it’s completely pried from the caliphate's grip. 

“There are no real plans, it is all improvisation at the moment. Resources are being thrown piecemeal at needs as they become available,” said Michael Knights, the Lafer Fellow at the Washington Institute and noted Iraq analyst.

“A patchwork of road, water and electricity reconstruction is evident,” he added.

When asked if Baghdad will be able to secure, stabilize and rebuild Mosul long-term after ISIS's removal Knights responded in the affirmative, but added that “the long-term is a long way away.”

Dylan O'Driscoll, a former analyst the Middle East Research Institute (MERI) think-tank in Erbil who now works at the Humanitarian and Conflict Response Institute (HCRI) at the University of Manchester, warned of ill-planning before the Mosul operation began. Political timetables in both Baghdad and Washington saw both powers overlook the importance of anticipating how to deal with the long-term situation in Mosul, as opposed to just the immediate military task of removing the militants.  

Before the beginning of the operation last October he wrote a report on Mosul and the future of the wider Nineveh region published by MERI which outlined the shortcomings of current plans, or lack thereof, for that area’s future. O'Driscoll compared this to the poor post-conflict planning following the 2003 American-led invasion of Iraq, and the instability which subsequently plagued the country ever since, and warned that if Mosul's “liberation is devoid of long-term planning it will likely result in the resurfacing of a number of issues responsible for the rise of ISIS in Iraq in the first place.” 

“I still share the same concerns I had when my report on the future of Nineveh was published before the military campaign began last year,” O'Driscoll told Rudaw English. “I don't see adequate preparation for the governance of the province post-ISIS and the necessary institutional restructuring is widely being ignored.

“At the same time, there is very little development of coordinated localized security solutions allowing for the long-term security of the province. On the development side, things are also moving slow, particularly with regards to restarting the economy.”

O'Driscoll fears that a combination of these factors will see Nineveh quickly “becoming a geopolitical playground where multiple entities are competing for influence.” 

He does nevertheless see some positive indicators for the future of the region. 

“The resilience of the local people has been immensely impressive and in my opinion Haider al-Abadi has grown as a leader,” O'Driscoll concluded.

Joel Wing, an Iraq analyst who runs the Musings on Iraq blog, is also anxious about the city's future. However, he already sees some positive developments on the city's east side, which was completely recaptured in January.

“When east Mosul was freed some residents started complaining that they were not getting any help from the government to rebuild,” Wing said. “Nineveh officials told the press that they had a plan for reconstruction as well as Baghdad. Now that tune has changed. Nineveh officials admit that they are working on a plan right now, but they say there's no money for it.”

Wing says this is a huge problem given the fact that “Mosul is such a large city with so many needs.” 

“East Mosul has some areas there were heavily damaged, but most of it looks pretty good, and already some services are being restored slowly,” he added. “The west however looks pretty devastated. If there's not a serious rebuilding plan that could cost Baghdad the support it has won from the residents for liberating them.”

Wing also points out that stabilizing and rebuilding Mosul is a process which will have to “include a large security component.” 

“The contracts have to be policed and investigated because the Islamic State is going to try to exploit them to raise money and rebuild,” he concluded.

Comments

 
Telh | 11/5/2017
The vagaries of Islamic loyalties will muddy the waters no matter what is proposed. They will never find lasting peace - there are too many scriptural interpretations - a grab-bag of justifications for eliminating ones neighbor. Until they either abandon or fix their incoherent texts it will be hatred as usual
FAUthman | 13/5/2017
The best blueprint plans for the future of Mosul will prove to be inadequate. Your best approach for Mosul and its problems after or even during the on going war with ISIS is to be flexible and resilient, deal with each problem as it comes up the best way you can. Some call that "disjointed incrementalism" or "strategic clarity with tactical flexibility", or whatever. But solve the obvious physical problems first such as security, sanitation, water and electricity move on then to getting the IDPs back, the City Council members identified, the economy going and getting schools to open and so forth. Don't bother with the so called visionary master plans for the future of Mosul.
truthsayer | 24/5/2017
Prepared for what? There will be open rebellion due to corruption. That's just been shelved, there is going to be allot of political blood spilled, metaphorically but also high probably - physically. I wouldn't be a bit surprised if the people started cutting off hands of crooked ministers or hanging them from the lamp post. Also you have the Kurdish and you had the sunnis both disenfranchised segments. It will be 1 year before it's safe enough and 5 years before the economy begins to work again. Consider the whole country is on welfare and there isn't even one job per every extended family. Between no work and the fact most Iraqi's are realistically unemployable, and the official who are supposed to help the country, but are in fact stealing the country blind, the fun has just begin. ISIS leaves and the next unpleasant chapter will begin. I don't even see a crack of sunshine and I have money invested there.
5694 Views

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

boris fanclub | 11/23/2017 10:30:04 AM
i will not complain as long uk is bitch slappin iranian mullahs left right center. GOD SAVE THE MIGHTY AWESOME QUEEN.
Kurd supporter for a good while longer | 11/23/2017 12:09:17 PM
Boris Fanclub - the Queen is 91 I don't think anyone is going to save her that long. Seriously though nice to see someone NOT criticising the UK for...
Boris Johnson: 'Serious effort' underway to bring Erbil, Baghdad to table
| yesterday at 09:25 | (6)
Shkak | 11/23/2017 7:22:49 AM
They are still dividing and conspiring in the search of power and greed. They are traitors.
Discussions | 11/23/2017 7:39:44 AM
The two parties are discussing how to distribute among themselves the benefits of their treason of October 16 .
Gorran and PUK discuss 'interim government' in meeting
| yesterday at 11:18 | (3)
IranMan | 11/23/2017 2:41:15 AM
I certainly agree with the commneter above. This pic shows one of Khamenei's rent-a-crowds cheering him on. Instead we should have been looking at a...
Kurdo | 11/23/2017 7:21:23 AM
IranMan why the separist thinking? Joomori eslami e Iran was founded by Israel. They even supported you against Saddam. Mullah Iran is a zionist...
More must be done to aid earthquake victims, says Iran's Supreme Leader
| 20/11/2017 | (4)
Outsider | 11/23/2017 4:59:03 AM
At the end of the day... just speculations... if the peshmerger do not want to talk about them.. my understanding would be they know who this group...
dan | 11/23/2017 5:39:38 AM
What group? you found nothing. You have not one shred of evidence. could be aliens, could be germans, could be anything.. we and you will never know...
Rudaw’s field investigation into unknown armed group which emerged in Tuz Khurmatu
| yesterday at 01:43 | (3)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

KRG asks Baghdad to respect Federal Court ruling on referendum 3 hours ago |

KRG asks Baghdad to respect Federal Court ruling on referendum

KRG: court rulings commits Baghdad to cancel more
Report: Iraq blocked German FM diplomatic visit to Erbil 7 hours ago |

Report: Iraq blocked German FM diplomatic visit to Erbil

Chancellor Merkel phoned PM Abadi to resolve more
Boris Johnson: 'Serious effort' underway to bring Erbil, Baghdad to table yesterday at 09:25 | (6)

Boris Johnson: 'Serious effort' underway to bring Erbil, Baghdad to table

PM Barzani received a letter from UK FM, more
0.406 seconds