Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Login

Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using
 

Email

 

Rudaw

Analysis

US balancing act between Syrian Kurds and Turkey cannot last

By Paul Iddon 10/11/2016
Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF) troops firing a mortar. Getty Images.
Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF) troops firing a mortar. Getty Images.
The US is delicately trying to balance its long-term strategic relationship with Turkey and its current ad-hoc relationship against ISIS with Syrian Kurdish forces opposed by Ankara as the US-backed Kurdish-led Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF) launch their offensive against the extremist group in Raqqa, according to observations from analysts.

“The United States needs Turkey as an ally and does not want to force it into Russian President Vladimir Putin’s embrace by supporting the [Syrian Kurdish Democratic Union Party, PYD] too aggressively,” Professor Joshua Landis, a Syria expert at the University of Oklahoma, told Rudaw English.

This, Landis explained, has seen the US devise a plan to capture Raqqa in two phases.

“The first phase is using the army that it has, the Syrian Democratic Forces which are dominated by Kurds to surround and cut off Raqqa,” Landis explained, “Second is the devising of a plan to take Raqqa that will include Turkey’s preferred Arab militias.”

Landis sees this as a clear attempt to mitigate Turkey’s repeated concerns about an offensive against Raqqa led by the PYD, which essentially created and leads the Arab-Kurdish coalition that is the SDF.

“Of course squaring this circle will not be easy,” Landis added, “But Obama insists on moving quickly and launching the battle for Raqqa before his term is over. He cannot wait four or five months, as the Turks have asked him to do.”

Turkey had proposed that the US exclude the SDF from the Raqqa offensive – since Ankara views the Kurds who lead it as nothing more than members of the Kurdistan Workers Party (PKK) and therefore a threat to its national security – and instead work with Turkey to capture that city together. However, Washington knows the SDF are better suited and positioned as a ground force to attack and capture Raqqa than the Free Syrian Army (FSA) rebels Turkey has been using as its proxies in northwestern Syria in its two-and-a-half month old Euphrates Shield operation against ISIS and the PYD.

“Turkey's Arab allies are in no condition to take Raqqa,” Landis stated. “Turkey is finding that the Arab militias are fractious, badly led, badly armed and chaotic. It is learning the lesson that the US learned over the last five years. It is hard to unify or count on Syria's Arab rebels.”

“The SDF is the only force ready to move and capable of taking on the Islamic State,” Landis concluded.

Haid N. Haid, a Syria researcher and Chatham House Associate Fellow also outlined the precarious nature of Washington’s balancing act in this operation.

“The US is trying to avoid confrontation with any of its allies by sending mixed signals,” Haid told Rudaw English. “According to recent statements by Turkish officials, American officials have assured the government of Turkey that, while the Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF) is largely Kurdish fighters, the Kurds will not take on the main role of liberating the Islamic State ‘capital’ of Raqqa, Syria.”

This, Haid explained, might work in the short-term but will have destructive effects in the long-term.

“The US has been able to avoid addressing the elephant in the room, however, this can’t continue forever,” he explained. “The frequency and intensity of military confrontations between Turkish-backed forces and the SDF in Syria is increasing and will likely rise as the groups come into further contact along shared front lines.”

Since the launch of Operation Euphrates, Turkey and its FSA proxies have increasingly clashed with US-backed SDF forces in northwest Syria. None of these clashes have yet escalated into a full-fledged war between them. Washington invariably responds to these incidents by urging both sides to turn their guns away from each other and focus their efforts on defeating ISIS.

Haid also estimates that continued US support of the PYD and SDF will result in Turkey increasing its ties with Moscow and distancing itself from the US and its traditional western allies.

“This US policy is creating secondary conflicts in Syria and creating mistrust with its strategic ally, Turkey, which is pushing the latter further towards Russia,” Haid warned.

Comments

 
Data pager
Previous
123
Page size:
PageSizeComboBox
select
Canlast | 10/11/2016
It can last. First US should remove it airforce from Incirlik airbase to one near Qamisli. Then they can threaten Turkey if Erdogan interfere in Syria affair. Turkey might have the biggest army in the middle east but they are no match for the American air power. Turkey army and airforce are only good for fighting terrorists but no good if they have to fight somebody who can shoot back with greater force.
Rebaz | 11/11/2016
Idont know why SDF fight for Raqqa its not part of Rojava. And you gotta be stupid to trust US soecially Obama and democrates double standards. Good thing hillary didnt win. Democrats days in USA is over they lie none stop to people.
Luigi | 11/11/2016
Why the Trump factor is not bring discussed ?
pre-Boomer Marine brat | 11/11/2016
"The United States" in this context refers to a political Administration which has just had its teeth (ie, reputation) kicked in at the polls. Obama spent 8 years flushing competence out of the top level of America's military command structure. Anyone still in there is a clock-puncher, a time-server, trying to make it to retirement. My father served with Chesty Puller. The ones there now don't pack the gear to do that.
Dana Bekas | 11/11/2016
Let's see if we understand this, the United States support for Syrian Kurds is the main factor behind Turkey leaning towards Russia? right?. But the reality is Turkey broke rank with the Unites States a decade before YPG even existed, it started when Erdogan came to power back in 2002 and the first thing his government did was to refuse the United States to use Turkish soil (and even their own base incirlik) to take out Saddam's forces in northern Iraq. Lets name just a few of those steps Turkey took even before the Syrian war: 1. They undermined the sanctions the United States had put on the Ayatollah regime in Iran by doing all kind of business with Iran 2.They started to negotiate with Chinese and Russian ballistic companies to buy their new defence system 3. They launched hundreds of big and small joint projects with Russia Iran and China 4. Every opportunity he got Erdogan would (and still) bad mouths the United States NATO and the EU, he keeps repeating that Turkey should leave NATO and join Shanghai 7. 5. Their covert support for ISIS, Al Qaeda and every other jihadi group in Syria. These and many other things ALL happened before the United States started to support Kurds so if this "expert" thinks Turkey will change policy and turn away from Russia if the United States drops support for Kurds then he belongs in a mental institution. The Russians will immediately fill any gap the United States leaves in Syria so go right ahead and drop support for Kurds, the reality is that the Kurds are America's ONLY true ally in the region.

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

Rojhelati Kurmanc | 4/28/2017 6:04:24 AM
NATO and Israel should attack Iran, you will also get support from Kurds, Baloch, Arabs, Majority Iranians and Gilaki in Iran. Entire arab sunni...
Iran’s Kurdish opposition call for boycott of May elections
| 4 hours ago | (1)
michel.kinnis | 4/27/2017 3:21:49 PM
POTUS Trump is not Housein Obama !! He will help the Kurds in both Syria and Iraq to Prevent Iran to come through to Syria and Lebanon. Israel says...
Rojhelati Kurmanc | 4/28/2017 5:48:43 AM
Turkish trolls working hard, how are you doing "Berivan".
After Turkey struck YPG positions, US says it's asked Ankara to stop
| yesterday at 12:07 | (11)
Dutchman | 4/27/2017 1:27:18 PM
Israel has a right to defend itsself against terrorist groups like Hezbollah and its parners in crime: the Assad regime, Iran and Russia. Putin knows...
Rojhelati Kurmanc | 4/28/2017 5:45:05 AM
The kurds in Libanon have no rights in Libanon. Israel should remove the arabs in Israel and put in the kurds instead. Arabs never took the deal to...
Israeli warplanes strike Lebanese Hezbollah weapons cache near Damascus, reports
| yesterday at 12:52 | (3)
T.I. | 4/27/2017 11:18:15 PM
Merkel knows that the EU can't influence or contain Turkey (Erdogan) through "engagement", what she's really saying here is no matter how bad Turkey...
Mohamedzzz | 4/28/2017 5:12:34 AM
Angela Merkel is right, all Muslim countries look guidance from Turkey and an upset Turkey can bring a lot of trouble, with or without adhering to EU.
Merkel calls it a mistake for the EU to turn its back on Turkey
| 13 hours ago | (3)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

Kurdish MPs ask European parliament to support reactivation of their parliament 13 hours ago |

Kurdish MPs ask European parliament to support reactivation of their parliament

Kurdish parliament has been blocked since October more
Kurdish referendum needs parliamentary mandate, PUK and Gorran 22/4/2017 | (5)

Kurdish referendum needs parliamentary mandate, PUK and Gorran

KDP insists the referendum doesn't need a more
Surviving two genocides: Families escaped Halabja attack only to face Anfal 21/4/2017 | (2)

Surviving two genocides: Families escaped Halabja attack only to face Anfal

“How can I not be worried? My heart burns in pain more
0.187 seconds