Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Login

Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using
 

Email

 

Rudaw

Analysis

After Afrin Turkey cannot continue to play 'Kurdish card' in Rojava

By Paul Iddon 11/3/2019
A column of armoured Turkish military vehicles drives on a patrol along a road in the de-militarised zone in Syria's northern Idlib province near the town Saraqib on March 8, 2019. File photo: Omar Haj Kadour | AFP
A column of armoured Turkish military vehicles drives on a patrol along a road in the de-militarised zone in Syria's northern Idlib province near the town Saraqib on March 8, 2019. File photo: Omar Haj Kadour | AFP
The Turkish government has repeatedly tried to stress that it distinguishes between ordinary Kurds on the one hand and the Kurdistan Workers' Party (PKK) and Syrian Kurdish Peoples’ Protection Units (YPG) on the other.

It has sought to stress this as it simultaneously threatens to launch another cross border military campaign into Syria against the YPG in Syrian Kurdistan's (Rojava) cantons, but how long will Ankara’s rhetoric stand?

"This organization never had the aim to defend the rights of our Kurdish brothers or any group in the region," said Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan on March 8. He was referring, in this case, to the PKK.

Erdogan often denies that his government targets its "Kurdish brothers", insisting that it solely focuses on combating PKK "terrorists." Some Kurds argue that Turkey not only targets the PKK, but in the process kills civilians and non-PKK elements. This was demonstrated when Turkish airstrikes killed five Peshmerga from the Kurdistan Region in Shingal in 2017 and most recently killed at least half a dozen civilians in Shiladze in January.

When US Secretary of State Mike Pompeo, in early January, underscored the "importance of ensuring that the Turks don't slaughter the Kurds" of Syria, Ankara responded angrily — denying that it has any such intention.

"Minister Pompeo's equating the PYD/YPG terrorist organization with the Kurds, even if not deliberate, indicates a worrying lack of knowledge," stated Hami Aksoy, the spokesperson for Turkey's Ministry of Foreign Affairs.

Turkey, Aksoy added, "will continue to oversee the protection of the rights of Syrian Kurds in efforts to achieve a political solution to the Syrian conflict."

Ankara has the support of a small Kurdish entity in Turkey which also condemns the PKK and YPG and supports Ankara's actions against them.

The self-styled Independent Kurdish Coalition of Syria portrays itself as an alternative for Syrian Kurds to both the leading Democratic Union Party (PYD), the political wing of the YPG, and the Kurdistan National Council (KNC/ENKS), which is backed by the Kurdistan Region and has had cordial ties with Turkey. These two parties, the Kurdish Coalition claims, do not represent the Syrian Kurds. 

According to Al-Monitor, the Kurdish Coalition displays Turkish flags at its gatherings and has even held a conference in Turkish-occupied Afrin, which one could interpret as an endorsement of Ankara's unprovoked invasion and occupation of that Rojava canton.

The group's latest meeting consisted of 300 members.

"Turkey has never fought against the Syrian Kurds but against the PKK. Our common enemy with Turkey is the PKK," the Kurdish Coalition's president, Abdulaziz Temo, told Al-Monitor.

Echoing the Turkish government he described the YPG as a terrorist organization, stating that everyone in the Coalition's last meeting agreed with this designation and wants to see the group removed from Rojava.

"They don't represent us and should get out of our land," Temo declared.

It is unclear if this entity is promoting itself as a possible alternative to the PYD in northeast Syria following a Turkish operation there. The fact it held a meeting in Afrin may be its way of suggesting that it could help play such a role.

However, historically groups of this kind installed by foreign armies to govern in the Middle East have had a very poor track record. Ahmed Chalabi's Iraqi National Congress (INC) was a very good example of this.

Turkey's actions in Afrin seriously undermine its claim that its objectives in Syria are solely aimed at destroying the YPG and are not intended to harm Kurds in general.

Erdogan has said once the Turkish military clears YPG from east of the Euphrates, Rojava's heartland, it will return it to its "rightful owners".

This is the exact same terminology the Turkish president used on the eve of the Afrin invasion in early 2018.

The invasion of Afrin displaced hundreds-of-thousands of Kurds. Many of them have not yet returned since Turkey's Syrian militiamen proxies occupy the whole area. Those militiamen have committed several documented crimes against Afrin's residents throughout their occupation which Turkey has turned "a blind eye" to.

Many of Afrin's displaced Kurds are, consequently, still languishing in camps in the nearby Shahba Canton, too fearful for their lives to even attempt returning to their homes. Afrin's occupiers have resettled displaced Syrian Arabs from across the country in vacated Kurdish homes in a clear attempt to create new demographic facts on the ground.

It's clear that the engineered demographic change, or Arabization, of Afrin was what Erdogan meant by returning that region to its rightful owners. One can logically deduce from this precedent that Erdogan intends to do the same in Rojava's primary regions in northeastern Syria if Turkey conquers them, or gains control over large swathes of them under the proposed safe zone along the border where most of Rojava's major cities are incidentally situated.

The KNC/ENKS, whose officials were jailed by the PYD and its political activities suppressed in Rojava by the PYD for years, oppose any Turkish military operation east of the Euphrates. It's likely that it too has concluded that any Turkish incursion into Rojava would not end in the military defeat of the YPG but could also see the uprooting of hundreds of thousands more Kurds from their homeland.


Neither Turkey's grandstanding rhetoric about protecting innocent Kurds and only combating terrorists or having the support of a tiny Kurdish entity changes this observable reality.

Comments

 
Data pager
Previous
123
Page size:
PageSizeComboBox
select
Stop the Kurdish Genocide | 11/3/2019
Turkey intends to ocupy Kurdish lands ,kill and destroy everyone and everything Kurdish. It is conducting a systematic war on Kurds inside and oiutside its border. The PKK is used as a pretext and an instrumentr to kill Kurds.PKK does not fight for Kurds, it fights for Turkey and for the total destruction of Kurdistan.The 300 traitors of the so-called Independent Kurdish Coalition are miserable slaves of the ruthless Turkish invadors... US Secretary Pompeo well knows which are the intentions of Erdogan who wants to commit genocide against all Kurds not only the PKK. The best thing America can do is to stop Turkey/PKK war and save the Kurds from the Turkish planned Kurdish genocide.
Erdal | 11/3/2019
As we know the Turks and specifically ErDOGan are the master of manipulation and twisting their words as is suit them An occupation is an occupation.
Outsider | 11/3/2019
I can understand from where the author is coming... it is also compelling obvious that he is a YPG supporter... however I will not go into much detail of this YPG material... completely disregarding that Afrin is administered by a coalition of Kurdish organisations... etc... etc... the only question I have is... from where does the author know that this "Kurdish entity" is tiny? Not that I have different information... or support Erdogan... all this sounds to me like a typical PKK/YPG probaganda piece... claiming that the PKK are the only (true) organisation who protects and represents the Kurds... NO this surely not true Mr author...
Alex Aaron | 12/3/2019
The PKK is a political party that emerged in 1979 but decided to take arms in 1984 only when Turkish fascistic violence was multiplying against defenseless Kurdish people and when Turkish racism was hurrying to eradicate Kurdish identity. Between October 29th, 1923, the establishment of the Turkish state, and 1984, the PKK’s decision to take up arms, the state of Turkey committed atrocities against non-Turkic and non-Sunni entities even outside of Turkish territory.
Alex Aaron | 12/3/2019
Now, people with political knowledge around the world know that the violence in Turkey did not start with the PKK’s decision to take up arms in 1984. Turkey has been practicing fascistic violence since the very first day of its establishment back in 1923. The extermination war, including prohibiting languages, cultures, music, national dresses etc., against Armenians, Assyrians, Kurdish people and others started with the aim of Turkifying everyone who happened to be a part of new Turkey.
Post a New Comment
Comment as a guest or Login for more enhanced interactive experience

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

Luigi Palermo | 3/26/2019 6:41:01 AM
America is already preparing for a Turkish occupation of Rojava letting Turks kill Kurds and occupy their land. America is responsible for any...
After ISIS – what next for the SDF?
| 23 hours ago | (1)
Sayjee | 3/26/2019 5:38:43 AM
Lets not blame all turks for these comments, but the biggest threat to "safety" since the crusaders has been turkish and tatar mamluks.
Stop killing Kurds | 3/26/2019 6:32:14 AM
America and the world used and abused the Kurds as sacrificial animals : 11000 Kurds killed, other 22000 wounded suffering without health care in...
‘No YPG forces’ in Syria safe zone with Turkey: US
| 21 hours ago | (5)
Heshmat | 3/26/2019 5:17:11 AM
Good, iraq always been inseparable part of iran for millenniums. Lets celebrate when iraq gets annexed to iran empire
Bridge linking Iraq to Kurdistan Region ‘may collapse at any moment’
| 20 hours ago | (1)
Jarrett | 3/25/2019 9:03:10 PM
As if there are really roads in Kurdistan specially between Dohuk Erbil and Erbil Suleimani, for some 20 years corrupt officials have embezzled...
Heavy rains block roads, damage homes in Kurdistan Region
| yesterday at 12:00 | (1)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

ISIS caliphate pounded with strikes in final 2 weeks: US-led coalition 2 hours ago |

ISIS caliphate pounded with strikes in final 2 weeks: US-led coalition

"In Syria, CJTF-OIR conducted 193 strikes more
Bridge linking Iraq to Kurdistan Region ‘may collapse at any moment’ 20 hours ago | (1)

Bridge linking Iraq to Kurdistan Region ‘may collapse at any moment’

"This may bring a catastrophe for us" more
‘No YPG forces’ in Syria safe zone with Turkey: US 21 hours ago | (5)

‘No YPG forces’ in Syria safe zone with Turkey: US

"Turkey feels very nervous about the YPG and more
0.422 seconds