Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment


Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using





Did Iraq's takeover of Kirkuk give ISIS breathing room?

By Paul Iddon 13/1/2018
The Iraqi flag replaced the Kurdistan one on Kirkuk’s Peshmerga statue, guarding over the northern gate to the city, when control of the city was taken over by Iraqi forces in October. Photo: Hiwa Hussamadin/Rudaw
The Iraqi flag replaced the Kurdistan one on Kirkuk’s Peshmerga statue, guarding over the northern gate to the city, when control of the city was taken over by Iraqi forces in October. Photo: Hiwa Hussamadin/Rudaw
Despite the fact that Iraqi Prime Minister Haider al-Abadi has declared the defeat of ISIS in Iraq, remnants of the group are reemerging in Kirkuk Province where Iraqi forces have, so far, proven unable to adequately fill the vacuum left by the hasty withdraw of Kurdish Peshmerga forces in mid-October. 

On December 9, Abadi announced ISIS's defeat in Iraq. The physical caliphate the group had erected on captured Iraqi territory has indeed been successfully destroyed. However, they are already reverting to their roots as a non-state terrorist group which uses guerrilla tactics against their many adversaries. One area where they have had some limited success in carrying out such hit-and-run attacks is in Kirkuk following Iraq's ouster of Kurdish forces from there almost three months ago. 

A mere week after the Iraqis drove ISIS from Hawija in Kirkuk on October 8, in an operation made much easier for them by prior Peshmerga efforts in securing routes into that town, they stormed into Kirkuk and seized it from the Kurds. The Patriotic Union of Kurdistan (PUK), whose Peshmerga constituted the largest and predominant Kurdish military force in Kirkuk, promptly withdrew all their forces from the entire province on October 16. 

The Kurds defended Kirkuk against ISIS since taking complete control over it in June 2014 when the Iraqi military fled, following the infamous ISIS takeover of Mosul the same month, and left the region undefended. The rapid October 16 evacuation of tens of thousands of Peshmerga and security forces – who had a very good three-year track record of locating ISIS sympathizers and sleeper cells and foiling their terrorist plots – predictably created a security vacuum the militants are attempting to exploit to their advantage.

"The October federal takeover of Kirkuk has led to new instability in the province," Musings on Iraq author Joel Wing told Rudaw English. "There are continued attacks by the Islamic State [ISIS], but also plenty of political violence as well. The Turkmen Front, for example, has had its offices bombed and shot at several times in various locations."

"Islamic State is also taking advantage of the situation because the Peshmerga and Iraqi forces are more concerned about facing off against each other in many areas rather than hunting down insurgents," he elaborated. 

Following the demoralizing loss of Kirkuk, the Peshmerga engaged Iraqi military and Shiite-majority Hashd al-Shaabi along the Kurdistan Region’s frontiers, notably knocking out an American-made Iraqi M1 Abrams main battle tank at the Pirde border-crossing on October 20. These clashes were halted as a result of a ceasefire implemented a week later. 

More recently, on December 26, Peshmerga forces in Kifri south of Sulaimani Province engaged in a tense standoff with Iraqi forces. This ended when the Iraqis withdrew to their previous positions and both sides agreed they would coordinate against any ISIS remnants in the region.  

After these standoffs, Iraqi forces early this January began a large-scale operation in Kirkuk's south and west to rout the remaining militants. As part of this endeavour they are using armoured forces (including the army's powerful 9th Armoured Division) and Hashd fighters backed by air support. 

Wing points out that Hawija "is a large rural area that has been an insurgent hot spot for years and, like other parts of Iraq, if a permanent presence is not established the militants will move back in. That happened in Hawija, and is the reason why there is a large security operation going on there currently." 

Michael Knights, the Lafer Fellow at The Washington Institute and a leading Iraq analyst, told Rudaw English that ISIS's "bounceback in Hawija is unrelated to the October [Iraqi] takeover" of Kirkuk. 

Hawija aside, having pushed out the Peshmerga from the rest of Kirkuk the Iraqis need to provide security for, and stabilize, the entire province themselves – if they do not reestablish a joint security arrangement with the Kurds – which they have not yet shown any real adeptness in doing. 

"Today conditions in the area are like those in the days of Saddam Hussein. It is very bad. There must be joint efforts by Peshmerga forces and security units as in the days before ISIS," Iraqi member of parliament Sahawan Abdullah, who is from Kirkuk, recently told Al-Monitor. 

For Kurds, memories of Saddam Hussein's Arabization of the region – the forced deportation of Kurds and importation of Arab settlers to alter Kirkuk's demography – have been particularly vivid since October when approximately 180,000 civilians, mostly Kurds, were displaced by that Iraqi action. Moreover, the presence of some of the more sectarian Shiite Hashd forces ran the grave risk of inflaming sectarian schisms in that Sunni-majority province of the kind ISIS, and its al-Qaeda forebearer, skillfully capitalized upon elsewhere in Iraq over the years. 

On the prospect of a joint security arrangement between Iraqi and Kurdish forces in Kirkuk, as existed before June 2014, Knights anticipates that: "Kurds will probably not return to Kirkuk as the kind of rulers they were since 2014, but they may still hold a lead in the new provincial council and elect a Kurdish governor if they stick together as one bloc with great discipline." 

"The new security arrangements will see the Kurds functioning as one of many security providers, not the main security agency," he elaborated. 

Such arrangements may prove essential in the long-term to fill the aforementioned security vacuum in the province created by the tumultuous events of October.

"That being said," Knights concluded, "Kirkuk was lost in a day and it is possible, if unlikely, that it could be regained in a day."


Barzani | 14/1/2018
I like the picture Barzani referendum was a success
The Occupation was agreed by the U.S. | 14/1/2018
It was only the Kurds who fought the more and defeated the I.S. and made the streets of Paris and London safer from fanatic Arabs, but as soon as the war was over the perfidous U.S. has agreed with the Islamic terror states of Iran/Iraq/Turkey to assault Kurdistan and submit it to the Arab occupation as it is now under siege -blockade condemned to starvation.The American leadership is depraved and lacks honor and decency .America by betraying the Kurds has betrayed the very European values and civilistion .
Peshmerga-4-life | 15/1/2018
This time around when isis returns the peshmerga should not help “iraqi army” noticed how I put that in quotations, what a joke. Let’s see how fast the “Iraqi army” can last without peshmerga or will they run away like cowards once again. Arabs should never be trusted the only way the cooperate is if you strike fear into their cowardly hearts.

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

Leon | 4/20/2019 11:40:24 AM
Islam is cancer and it must be destroyed. The only way forward for the Middle East is to abandon Pisslam. It is the most vile religion and has driven...
Istanbul vote result marks watershed in political history
| 8 hours ago | (1)
Jay | 4/19/2019 10:43:13 PM
PUK should stop making tasks for forming the government harder and Iraqi Kurds should start negotiating with the central government. Despite PUK...
Kurdi | 4/20/2019 10:42:40 AM
Rudaw : how come only Muraz can comment and I see comments reduced to almost nil ??!!! This proves that you are clandestine
Gorran and PUK ready to sign on dotted line or are gaps still too big?
| yesterday at 11:24 | (4)
Peter | 4/20/2019 6:55:20 AM
Good. Turkish "soldiers" are terrorists, no different to any other member of ISIS.
4 Turkish soldiers killed in skirmish with PKK: defense ministry
| 11 hours ago | (1)
Hans | 4/11/2019 8:09:05 PM
@fraud, let's see if we understand this, so Kurds, who at the time held no power in Turkey, committed genocide on christians for Turks, then FLED...
Shahin Sorekli | 4/20/2019 4:39:55 AM
The name of this town has always been "Kobani." I challenge anyone to show me the evidence that the false name "Kobane" existed before 2011.
Kobane or Kobani? History won't care, but some locals will
| 10/4/2019 | (9)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

President Macron pledges ‘military, civilian support': SDC leader 20 hours ago | (1)

President Macron pledges ‘military, civilian support': SDC leader

The SDC is the political wing of the co more
Watchdog concerned with press freedom in Iran, Iraq, Syria, Turkey 21 hours ago | (1)

Watchdog concerned with press freedom in Iran, Iraq, Syria, Turkey

Norway, Finland and Sweden topped the list more
Iraq parliament to host regional rivals in Baghdad 22 hours ago |

Iraq parliament to host regional rivals in Baghdad

Baghdad has sought to bring Syria back into the more
1.109 seconds