Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Login

Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using
 

Email

 

Rudaw

Analysis

Why doesn't Ireland sympathize with Kurdistan's independence bid?

By Paul Iddon 14/7/2017
The flag of Ireland flaps in the wind over the post office in Dublin, Ireland. Photo: AFP
The flag of Ireland flaps in the wind over the post office in Dublin, Ireland. Photo: AFP
At the beginning of the Second World War Britain's Foreign Secretary Lord Halifax summoned the Turkish ambassador to inquire if a neutral Ankara could throw its lot in with the Allies in that global struggle against fascism. The ambassador told him that the “eastern problem” in his country, an obvious euphemism for the Kurdish issue, could potentially destabilize Turkey if they participated in the war. 

Attempting to reassure his Turkish guest Halifax said he knew of this “eastern problem” and asked if Turkey could resolve it as the British had done with the Scottish issue.

“Kurds aren't Scottish,” the Turkish diplomat responded after a pause. “Kurds are Irish.” 

Turkish professor Hamid Akin Unver, who recalled this exchange, which he learned from Bernard Lewis, argues that Turkey's approach towards the Kurds has since been “increasing the number of Scottish Kurds and decreasing the number of Irish Kurds.” 

Decades later a US Special Forces soldier helping the Kurdish Peshmerga fight the Ansar al-Islam group in 2003 remarked the following to journalist Quil Lawrence, upon looking at the beautiful mountainous landscape of Kurdistan: “I had no idea. Couldn't you be in Ireland or something like that? If this were my land I'd want to own it too.” 

Both quotes, while highly anecdotal and from two very different periods, aptly illustrate the shared rebellious nature of both people's and their affection for their respective homelands. 

It's therefore curious that there hasn't been a greater recognition of the part of the Irish of the similarities between their history and that of the Kurds. Irish activists and politicians never compare the two histories and solidarity towards the Kurds from Ireland has been minimal. They do, however, frequently compare their country's history to the cause of the Palestinians. Palestinian flags were recently publicly flown over city councils across Ireland, including the capital Dublin. Kurdish flags are a rare, if nonexistent sight in Ireland. Even though Ireland is ostensibly a neutral country it has taken a clear stance in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, yet rarely comments, or acknowledges, the Kurds’ own historic drive for independence and self-rule. 

Last year was an important centennial in both Ireland and Kurdistan. Ireland commemorated the 1916 Easter Rising, a moment highlighted by Irish nationalists as the opening salvo of the subsequent war for independence. For Iraqi Kurdistan, 2016 marked the hundredth anniversary of the tragic beginning of the Sykes-Picot carve-up of the Middle East and a century of denial of their national rights, a process Erbil seeks to undo in the near future. 

Ireland attained its independence in 1922. After the September 25 referendum in Kurdistan a Kurdish state may well be declared around the same date Ireland celebrates the centennial of its independence from the United Kingdom. 

So why don't the Irish, who frequently refer to their own history as justification to support self-determination of other stateless peoples, rarely identify or sympathize with the Kurds’ struggle for independence? 

Irish people familiar with Kurdistan usually attribute it to simple ignorance and argue that if the Irish were more familiar with the history of the Kurds and their desire for self-determination they would naturally sympathize. 

There are some tiny exceptions to this general rule, which aren't necessarily encouraging. Earlier this year in Derry in Northern Ireland, for example, Irish Republicans erected a mural in the 'Free Derry Corner' which depicts a common struggle between Irish Republicans in Northern Ireland and the Syrian Kurdish Democratic Union Party (PYD), which rules Syria's Kurdish regions. 

Also, an Irishman who joined the PYD's armed wing, the People's Protection Units (YPG), to fight Islamic State recently told an Irish tabloid that he sees, “many parallels between the Kurdish struggles and the struggles in Ireland. We are both small countries and we have fought powerful enemies.” 

He also said that Kurds have been treated “abominably” by the four states which rule over their territories.  

Dermot Meleady, an Irish historian who has single-handedly debunked many of the shibboleths Irish nationalists have about their own historic drive for independence, goes one step further in explaining the present fixation with the Palestinian cause in Ireland and the comparably mute one over the Kurdish cause. 

“Until Saddam gassed the Kurds and until the Kurds fought Islamic State few had heard of them,” Meleady told Rudaw English. “Whereas the Palestinians had put themselves on the world map in the 1960s and 1970s with highly publicized air hijackings.” 

The leftist political orientation of many Irish activists, the most unrelenting and vocal of whom are members or supporters of Sinn Fein, is another factor Meleady attributes to the striking lack of Irish advocacy for Kurdish self-determination. Even more moderate Irish politicians, who affirm their support to the Palestinians and have even laid wreaths on the grave of the late Yasser Arafat when visiting Israel and the Palestinian Territories, seldom utter a word in support of Kurdish rights. 

“The countries the Kurds have fought for independence – Turkey, Iraq, Syria and Iran – are not perceived in the West to be true colonial powers but are seen themselves as 'oppressed' peoples,” he contends. “Whereas the Palestinians are seen as struggling against white Jewish settler colonists and their US allies, which lends their struggle much more romance in the minds of naive and gullible Irish and other Westerners.” 

During the civil war in the Kurdistan Region in the mid-1990s Ireland hosted US-brokered peace talks, in Drogheda, which tried to end that fratricidal conflict. While ultimately a failed endeavor, Dublin nevertheless played a useful role as a host country for these necessary talks.   

Today Ireland has no obligation to breach its neutrality on the Kurdish issue as it has long done with the Palestinian one. It could, however, offer its services as a neutral mediator in negotiations between the Kurdistan Region and Baghdad over secession, something the United Nations has declined to do. Then, possibly in the foreseeable future, Ireland could welcome Kurdistan into the family of nation states as it prepares to mark its first century of independence.

Comments

 
Data pager
Previous
12
Page size:
PageSizeComboBox
select
David | 14/7/2017
Good question, and I think you answered it -- Irish support for Palestinians but not Kurds has little to do with Palestinians or Kurds, and a lot more to do with who is oppressing or opposing Palestinians vs. Kurds. These guys are about their own Leftist anti-imperialist B.S. antiquated rhetoric and ideology much more than anything actually currently happening in the world.
bebegun | 14/7/2017
Good article, if I had to guess I would also say ignorance is to blame, but it's our duty as Kurds to change that not those who have never heard of us.
Mike | 14/7/2017
It's such a disgrace that those who have European blood on their hands with hijacking of planes, hostages and other terrorist tactics for decades in Europe are given so much attention and support by the same Europeans. They give the Pals billions in funds every year while Kurds who have never committed a single terrorist act against Europeans in any country are completely ignored. If anything the Europeans specially UK & France owe the Kurds because they carved up Kurdistan amongst 4 savage states.
Muiris | 15/7/2017
As an Irish mationalist, I have long sympathised with the Kurds, following closely progress in northwrn Iraq, and latterly Rojava/ northern Syria. We Irish have had it easy of course, being an island makes our boundaries clear cut, and with only one oppressor, who hasn't had the stomach ( in recent times) for the levels of abuse that the Kurds have bad, and continue to endur.
duroi | 15/7/2017
There is a strong admiration for Kurdish struggle among Scottish politicians, especially the current Scottish National Party (SNP) premier in Scotland Nicola Sturgeon has had many contacts with Kurdish activists in the UK and she can name a few of Kurdish SNP activists.
8098 Views

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

Hama | 12/15/2018 6:59:18 PM
They can go to hell. Be reasonable or don't talk. Suggesting ‘in-between’ status for disputed territories is not a legal or reasonable long term...
Realist | 12/16/2018 4:48:34 AM
I don’t understand why you waste your time . Let’s we here . I bet you if Kirkuk didn’t have oil it wouldn’t be the ‘heart’ of Kurdistan . Bunch of...
UN should revive ‘stillborn’ mediation on Kirkuk, disputed territories: ICG
| yesterday at 09:01 | (2)
Renas | 12/15/2018 8:41:41 PM
Depends on, no-fly zone for all, or is THE enemy allowed to bomd there? A no-fly zone should forbid all ountries to fly there, that would have a...
Guest | 12/15/2018 9:26:48 PM
I disagree. A no fly zone is exactly that, a zone that prohibits certain aircraft from flying in that zone. In Iraq, its purpose was to prevent Iraqi...
How feasible is a no-fly zone for Rojava?
| yesterday at 06:16 | (5)
Guest | 12/15/2018 9:06:23 PM
It is unfortunate, but I believe Turkey will continue to be emboldened to attack the sovereign territory of its neighbors unless it suffers a...
Turkey FM vows to continue strikes in Iraq if PKK isn't removed
| yesterday at 02:45 | (1)
pre-Boomer Marine brat | 12/15/2018 6:38:20 PM
Zimmerman's "political disenfranchisement and grievances" are superficialities. She gets them from using pseudo-academic "social movement theory" to...
Guest | 12/15/2018 9:01:40 PM
Katherine Zimmerman is wrong if she says the current strategy is failing. I did not read her article mentioned here but from the quote she gave, it...
War on jihadists won’t end unless West tackles root causes: experts
| yesterday at 07:19 | (3)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

Russian mothers of ISIS runaways form support group 3 hours ago |

Russian mothers of ISIS runaways form support group

1,800 Russian women and children are thoughts to more
Turkey-backed Syrian forces train in Aleppo as Ankara threatens new offensive 4 hours ago |

Turkey-backed Syrian forces train in Aleppo as Ankara threatens new offensive

Ankara's Syrian proxies participated in the Afrin more
UPDATE: SDF rejects Peshmerga offer to bolster Syria-Turkey border: monitor 5 hours ago |

UPDATE: SDF rejects Peshmerga offer to bolster Syria-Turkey border: monitor

It comes days after Turkey threatened to attack more
0.531 seconds