Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Login

Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using
 

Email

 

Rudaw

Analysis

Why Turkey has been taking so long to capture al-Bab

By Paul Iddon 14/2/2017
A member of the Turkish-backed Free Syrian Army northwest of al-Bab on February 2. Photo: Huseyin Nasir/AA
A member of the Turkish-backed Free Syrian Army northwest of al-Bab on February 2. Photo: Huseyin Nasir/AA
Over three months ago, November 6, Turkey, along with its Free Syrian Army (FSA) proxy militia, launched its offensive against the ISIS-occupied city of al-Bab in northwestern Syria. Since then they have been fighting heavy ISIS resistance to their siege.

Al-Bab is 50 kilometers southwest of Manbij. Both cities had pre-war populations of over 50,000 and are of comparable size. Nevertheless, when the Kurdish-led Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF) launched their offensive to rout ISIS from Manbij, it took, altogether, three months: from May 31 to August 27. The city fell to the SDF on August 12 and the subsequent two weeks were spent clearing ISIS out of Manbij's southern countryside. 

How is it that the Turkish Army and its allied FSA militia are taking longer to capture al-Bab from ISIS than it took the SDF to capture Manbij?

Possible answers to that question range from a lack of willingness on Ankara's part to take major steps forward in al-Bab during the Obama administration's last weeks in office until it could assess the new Trump administration, to the limited capabilities of the present Turkish military in Syria and the various forces involved in this siege. 

“In al-Bab, it seems extra complicated because the Turks are trying to coordinate with many others,” David Pollack of the Washington Institute told Rudaw English. “Not just with their own local Arab allies, but also Syrian regime and allied Russian forces.” 

“Turks also prefer not to go in directly to avoid casualties, which SDF took pretty heavily in Manbij,” he added. “Finally, the more ISIS is pushed back, the more desperate it gets while using fighters moving in – so it becomes a harder fight.”

The SDF had consistent US-led coalition air support throughout their offensive. The Turks have not after the US stopped providing them air support when they advanced to al-Bab, which Washington deemed too far south of the Turkish border – where the US was previously supporting Turkey's offensive against ISIS. 

Also, for a week in November Turkish jets ceased entering Syrian airspace to support the al-Bab offensive since Damascus threatened to shoot them down. They were only able to continue after Ankara consulted with the Russians. 

“Delta force and US air power are awesome things and the YPG/SDF is a coherent and unified group under the control of one man, who can direct his forces where the US tells them to go,” noted the Atlantic Council's Aaron Stein, whose areas of expertise include US-Turkey relations. “Turkish targeting is not comparable, the operation was under resourced, and the rebels fighting alongside them are fractured.”

Turkish air power, especially after the July 15, 2016 coup attempt, is also not comparable with US air power. Given the widespread arrests and detentions of suspected coup plotters in all ranks and branches of the military, Turkey's ability field its entire air force has been significantly degraded.  Advertisements in the Turkish press for the country's special forces following the coup attempt also indicate that the Turkish army's manpower has been significantly affected also. 

Only last month did the US begin flying air support missions for the offensive in al-Bab after Ankara and Moscow reached an agreement to militarily coordinate their forces against ISIS in that city. 

Since launching this Euphrates Shield operation into Syria last August, Turkey has relied on armour and special forces to support its FSA militia numbering at least 3,000. These forces have not proven as effective as the SDF on the ground, especially in urban warfare scenarios where, before even reaching al-Bab, several of them were killed by sophisticated ISIS explosives. 

They have also failed to defend some dozen Turkish tanks from ISIS militants wielding anti-tank missiles, leading the Turks to send in more of their own forces to beef up their ground assault force. There are now over 1,300 Turkish troops involved in the al-Bab assault. 

Furthermore, since the early days of Euphrates Shield, the FSA militiamen have spoken of their desire to fight the Assad regime in Aleppo rather than focus on ISIS and the YPG in Syria's northwest border region. The SDF on the other hand are fighting in direct defense of their homes against ISIS. Many of the Arab members of the coalition leading the assault on Raqqa likely feel they have a personal stake in liberating their homes from these militants as opposed to the FSA fighters who see fighting ISIS and the Kurds as little more than a sideshow to the uprising they took up arms in six years ago.  

Comments

 
Data pager
Previous
12
Page size:
PageSizeComboBox
select
Brzoo Kurdi
Brzoo Kurdi | 14/2/2017
The real fear of the Turkish government , is the nightmare of Kurdish nationalism in the region , the Turkish government knows that the Kurds are too large a number to control ,any explosion among the Kurds means disaster for the Turkish government ...the day is gone ,when they could commit a genocide ....even they still try to commit genocide in small numbers , in Kurdish area...but the world is watching ....
PC | 14/2/2017
The simple truth is Kurdish led SDF are superior to any force on the ground in Syria, deal with it.
Flaminco | 14/2/2017
Weak excuses and factual errors by the author who's trying desperately to whitewash Turkeys complete failure in Al Bab. 1. Anyone who knows the area and the terrain knows that Manjit is substantially more difficult to capture than Al-Bab 2. Manbij is a county not just a town like Al-Bab, in those three months SDF had to take the town they had to clear 106 villages before reaching the outskirts of Manbij! while the Turkish military and their jihadis proxies(FSA) have been at the gates of Al-Bab for almost six months 3. Not true that SDF lost more fighters in the Manbij offinsive, if you put the nr. of Turkish casualties and their jihadi proxies together than already the Turkish jihadi coaltion have higher casualties in Al-Bab. 4. Not true that SDF had more fighters on the ground in Manbij 4. It should be unnecessary and embarrassing to mention that Turkey couldn't give their forces air cover for "a whole week" when they've had 6 month , in fact according to the information released officially by the Turkish air force and military they've bombed thousends of ISIS postions and naturalized more than 4000 ISIS terrorists, meaning they've been way more successful than the coaltion air force in Manbij, is the author calling the Turkish military lairs? 5. SDF completed the mission while the Turkish jihadi coalition has taken 10-20% of Al-Bab, so why is the author giving the impression that the job is complete?
pre-Boomer Marine brat | 14/2/2017
(1) I wonder if Erdogan's ego is overriding professional advice from the top ranks of the TSK.
Stewee Guy
Stewee Guy | 15/2/2017
Bunch of xcuses to help the Muslim dictator Erdogan.

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

altani | 7/23/2017 4:46:13 PM
I don't care what happens in Syria, Iraq or Iran. However I do care what happens in Turkey. Turkey will never, ever be divided. I rather would have a...
Kobane-senah | 7/24/2017 4:11:39 AM
@Gerbert d'Aurillac Im kurdish american and love america however warn you put too much trust in amis politicians. Lets keep in mind our worst enemy...
KRG independence wouldn’t stir up separatism in other Kurdistans
| yesterday at 09:39 | (6)
FAUthman | 7/24/2017 2:19:58 AM
These guys need to lose some weight around their middle. With a pot belly like that as defense minister for Iraq and the other guy who is a spokesman...
Kobane | 7/24/2017 4:03:14 AM
Its disgusting all these bullshit of unity while no one asked kurdish people what they want. These full should know being poppets of big powers to...
Peshmerga to Iraqi defense chief: We defend ourselves in face of any possible threats
| 18 hours ago | (8)
FAUthman | 7/23/2017 12:44:31 PM
Looks like Putin is using Maliki to get the Americans out of Iraq when ISIS is defeated and to bolster Maliki to defeat Abadi in the forthcoming...
Jagerxin derashy | 7/24/2017 4:02:09 AM
If anyone is responsible for rise of Isis and fall of Mosul is you nori almaliki you treated sunnis like dirt and abused them!! you sad bastard if it...
Iraqi VP Maliki on official visit to Moscow, scheduled to meet President Putin
| yesterday at 02:00 | (2)
Bilal | 7/23/2017 11:02:00 PM
Shia Iran should just rename Iraq as a province of Iran its a vassel state of Iran at best not a nation partition is the only way forward.
History | 7/24/2017 1:26:23 AM
As much as I like Kurds to be independent country .. Turkey, Iran, Iraq and Syria will never allow it. Obviously to have freedom and respect the...
Kurdistan cannot secede from Iraq, predicts former PM Maliki
| 21/7/2017 | (13)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

Journalists from Turkish daily face trial today 3 hours ago |

Journalists from Turkish daily face trial today

The 17 include reporters and administrators more
Army stays out of referendum dispute: Iraq defense chief 5 hours ago |

Army stays out of referendum dispute: Iraq defense chief

Iraq Defense minister: As for the referendum, the more
German girl who joined ISIS wants to leave Iraq, return to family 6 hours ago |

German girl who joined ISIS wants to leave Iraq, return to family

"I just want to go home to my family more
0.469 seconds