Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Login

Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using
 

Email

 

Rudaw

Analysis

Is a ‘Syrian Kurdistan Region’ in the making?

By Paul Iddon 19/8/2018
Afrin residents welcome arrival of Syrian regime forces with posters of President Bashar al-Assad and PKK founder Abdullah Ocalan, February 2018. File photo: Ahmad Shafie Bilal / AFP
Afrin residents welcome arrival of Syrian regime forces with posters of President Bashar al-Assad and PKK founder Abdullah Ocalan, February 2018. File photo: Ahmad Shafie Bilal / AFP
Syrian Kurds held a second round of talks with the Bashar al-Assad regime in Damascus last week. The Syrian Democratic Council (SDC), undertaking negotiations on behalf of the Kurdish administration, which controls Syrian Kurdistan (Rojava) and several Arab territories in northeastern Syria, wants Damascus to decentralize power, allowing the Kurds to preserve their de-facto autonomy. 

Rojava’s ruling Democratic Union Party (PYD) adheres to the ideology of Democratic Confederalism promulgated by Abdulla Ocalan, the imprisoned leader of the Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK). The ideology essentially says Kurds should not seek their own state – since a nation state will not automatically bring about social justice. Rather, the PYD believes decentralization is the best way to enable genuine grassroots democracy to take root. 

The SDC claimed after its first meeting in Damascus late last month that the regime has agreed to “chart a roadmap to a democratic and decentralized Syria”. The Kurdish negotiators view this as the best possible outcome. 

The UN Special Envoy for Syria is planning to draft a new Syrian constitution with Iran, Turkey, and Russia in September. Syrian Kurds, who have been largely excluded from peace talks to date, will likely push for recognition and their rights in a post-war Syria. 

Although Assad has said he is open to negotiations with the Kurdish-led Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF), he also appears adamant about reasserting as much direct control over the country as possible. 

If American forces withdraw, which is President Donald Trump’s stated intention, Assad will likely push for greater control over the northeast, demanding either the dismantling of the SDF or its incorporation into the Syrian military under his command, leaving Kurds with limited local administrative authority. 

Then there are the other territories captured from ISIS by the SDF and essentially annexed into its unrecognized federal system, primarily Raqqa and large swathes of the oil-rich Deir ez-Zor province. 

Although Assad could acquiesce to the Kurds having some significant self-governing role and autonomy in Rojava proper – the Kobane and Jazira regions specifically – it is less likely he will want forces outside his command controlling strategically important and resource-rich Arab majority areas. 

It is also unlikely the Syrian Kurds will achieve the level of recognized autonomy enjoyed by their Iraqi Kurdish neighbours anytime soon. For one, the Kurdistan Region’s hard-won autonomy has its roots in older wars with Baghdad in the 1960s and 1970s, and was only implemented in the aftermath of the 1991 Persian Gulf War. It constitutionally became the autonomous Kurdistan Region of Iraq after the American-led overthrow of the Saddam Hussein regime in 2003. 

Continued wrangling between Baghdad and Erbil could actually serve as an imperfect – though informative – precedent for what the Syrian Kurds could face down the line if they manage comparable constitutional rights and recognition for a self-governing entity. 

The Americans, when Iraq was briefly governed by Paul Bremer’s infamously inept Coalition Provisional Authority, sought to essentially disarm the Kurdistan Region’s Peshmerga armed forces shortly after the 2003 invasion to encourage Iraqi militias to disarm. President Masoud Barzani strenuously resisted this and managed to secure the Peshmerga’s status as the autonomous region’s sole defence force. 

Then-Iraqi Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki would later try, in 2012, to force the Peshmerga to surrender its few heavy weapons – mostly antiquated Soviet-made tanks – and place itself under the command-and-control of the Iraqi Security Forces (ISF), essentially stripping the region of its own defences. This attempt, following some tense standoffs, came to nothing thanks to the steadfastness of Erbil. 

Rojava is unlikely to achieve this level of autonomy and recognition in the short- to mid-term – much less retain its armed forces without risking clashes with Damascus. Also, unlike the Kurdistan Region, major cities in Rojava proper are still garrisoned by Syrian troops and pro-regime militias. The regime still controls the airport in Qamishli, for instance. 

Furthermore, Syrian state personnel are returning to the Tabqa Dam, currently under SDF control, to begin repairs. Any agreement would likely see such key facilities in Rojava and SDF-controlled areas, particularly those related to Syria’s oil reserves, placed firmly under federal control.

Saudi Arabia is investing $100 million in SDF territories to support stabilization efforts – picking up where the US left off. America will instead use its earlier $200 million contribution to bolster other “key foreign policy priorities”. A gradual US withdrawal from northeast Syria could soon follow. 

With their American allies making for the door, Syrian Kurds can be expected to make several trips to Damascus in the coming months. The jury’s out on what kind of deal – if any – they will secure.

Comments

 
Hadi | 20/8/2018
It's unbelievable that the Israelis and Saudis are not taking advantage of this while they can. One of few things that reallly terrifies both Turkey and Iran is a Kurdish state next door. The Saudis or the Israeli could back this Kurdish entity and exert real influence instead of constantly reacting to Iranian and Turkish expansion. With Saudi funding and Israeli military know how and equipment the Syrian Kurds can be much more formidable force than Hezbollah. Extend this aid to Iraqi Kurdistan and suddenly you will have both Turkey and Iran by the balls.
Kay | 20/8/2018
Sorry to say but the Americans can not in any way shape or form be trusted. They can pack up and leave at any time, or make deal with Turkey or Assad or Puten so this is the only option, for now.
FAUthman | 20/8/2018
The scenario in this article that everyone seems to repeat is this: "US will exit Syria soon leaving the Kurds under the mercy of Assad, so Kurds better make a quick deal with Assad before US hits the exit doors. That is possible but there may be another possible scenario to consider, I would call it "gradualism", not a sudden but a gradual withdrawal of not only US but all coalition and foreign forces from Syria once peace and stability and a fair functioning government is in place for all of Syria. That option I believe is what amb. Jim Jeffrey, the new appointed US representative to Syria, would seriously consider!
hiobs | 22/8/2018
I think if a US withdrawal would take place, surrendering to Assad would be the only rational option to consider. Alternatives seem to be very dangerous if not deadly! No happy ending for this movie I guess
pete | 17/9/2018
Your propaganda is absurd. The project is for a decentralised federal Syria, and has nothing to do with creating a Kurdistan. It is not an ethnic project. Where do you get this nonsense?

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

Not yet | 3/23/2019 9:28:18 AM
One of the most brutal terrorist organizations ISIS has lost all it's territory thanks to the sacrifices of Kurdish forces from all parts of...
Thank you Kurds | 3/23/2019 9:37:36 AM
Kurdish lead SDF lost 8000 fighters and were central in defeating ISIL in Rojava and rest of Syria, but let's also not forget that ISIL's first real...
SDF declare ‘total elimination’ of ISIS caliphate
| 23 hours ago | (2)
Afrin is Kurdish | 3/23/2019 8:12:22 AM
Turkey must be expelled from Afrin and other Kurdish territories .
Karl Reiter | 3/23/2019 8:18:42 AM
There is no problem with Golan since the 1967 war.The problem was before that date,not after.The UN has no say over Golan since it tolerates and it...
Trump’s Golan statement draws strong regional condemnation
| yesterday at 08:49 | (2)
Artush | 3/23/2019 3:37:17 AM
FLynn the fake spy traitor criminal and his mullah boss contractor, same ppl recommended James Mattis to Trump to become DS. https://heavy...
IranMan | 3/23/2019 5:56:04 AM
@pre-Boomer Marine brat, Mahabad was Soviet invention that had to be eradicated - I'm referring to the "Jomhuri-e-Mahabad" not the city. The Iranian...
Iran leader dismisses Europe trade mechanism as 'bitter joke'
| 21/3/2019 | (10)
kurd | 3/22/2019 12:00:59 PM
The real problem is a bunch thieves who are running the country. corruption has been a reward of islamic revolution. country is drowning in...
luv u 2 hunibuni | 3/23/2019 4:19:13 AM
The devastating victim card stories again by iranian "refugees" !! About how sanctions hurts iranian "middle class"? REALLY? Iranian middle class ??...
Iran leader calls economy 'urgent problem'
| 21/3/2019 | (6)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

Iraqi fisherman flounder on the Shatt al-Arab 8 hours ago |

Iraqi fisherman flounder on the Shatt al-Arab

Iran and Kuwait prevent them from fishing further more
Trump: ISIS ‘are losers, will always be losers’ 9 hours ago |

Trump: ISIS ‘are losers, will always be losers’

"We will remain vigilant" more
ISIS loses all territory but its shadowy leader still at large 10 hours ago |

ISIS loses all territory but its shadowy leader still at large

“The Coalition is not holding him nor do we know more
0.469 seconds