Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Login

Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using
 

Email

 

Rudaw

Analysis

Maliki at root of Sunni desire for separatism, not Kurds' independence drive

By Paul Iddon 20/6/2017
Former Iraqi Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki, who is secretary general of the Dawa Party. Photo: Hadi Mizban | AP
Former Iraqi Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki, who is secretary general of the Dawa Party. Photo: Hadi Mizban | AP
If the Sunni Arabs of Iraq seek greater autonomy, or even some form of independence from Baghdad, the Kurdistan Region's drive for independence should not be blamed. What should be blamed is Iraqi Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki's attempts to impose complete control over the affairs of Iraq's Sunni and Kurdish minorities and his subsequent failure to prevent the rise of Islamic State (ISIS).

For years the regional states of Iran, Syria and Turkey opposed independence for Iraqi Kurdistan because they feared an independent Kurdish state bordering their respective countries would inspire their own, often restive, Kurdish minorities to seek separation. In recent months in Iraq itself leading Shiite figures are expressing their staunch opposition to the possibility of the country fragmenting into “small states”. 

Iraqi Vice President Osama al-Nujaifi's proposal for Sunni autonomy like the Kurdistan Region, for example, makes them wary that Kurdish independence could see Sunni secession in the Sunni Arab-majority provinces of Nineveh and Anbar. 

Even if this were to happen it would be ahistorical to blame Kurdistan for seeking its own independence. One reason the Kurds are so eager not to miss a chance to break from Iraq is their recent experience with Baghdad under Maliki. 

In 2012 Maliki sought to subjugate Kurdistan firmly under his command by demanding the region's Peshmerga forces be placed under Baghdad's command. The same year saw standoffs in Kirkuk – where Maliki tried to consolidate his control over the city's security, then a shared responsibility between Baghdad and the Kurdistan Region – and Zumar in Nineveh, where the Peshmerga successfully prevented the Iraqi Army from stationing troops in that border region with Syria.

At the time Maliki even took issue with the fact the Peshmerga retained some heavy weapons captured from Saddam Hussein's old arsenal, when his regime was overthrown by the American-led invasion of 2003. These weapons consist of simple vintage Soviet-made T-55 and T-62 tanks, the only real armor the Kurds have to defend their region to the present day.

Had Kurdistan not stood its ground in opposition to Maliki's demands the Peshmerga may not have been able to mount an adequate defense against ISIS in short order in the summer of 2014 and could well have lost both Kirkuk and Erbil. 

The Sunnis were not so fortunate. During the Iraq War under US General David Petraeus's strategy against ISIS's predecessor al-Qaeda in Mesopotamia vetted Sunnis formed Awakening Councils, who successfully helped the Americans and Baghdad remove the militants from their territories. The strategy certainly had an immediate success and may well have been the reason why the ISIS caliphate initially took root in Syria rather than in Iraq. Maliki opposed the strategy from the onset, fearing it would effectively enable the emergence of a competent armed Sunni force which could one day challenge him. 

When the Americans were withdrawing they asked him to recruit 100,000 fighters from these councils, pay them and use them to effectively police and combat terrorism in hotspots like Fallujah and Mosul. Maliki took less than 20,000 of them and, in a move not wholly unlike Paul Bremer's infamous disbanding of the old Iraqi Army 2003, ditched the rest of them with no pensions.

Dismantling these councils and their battle-hardened fighters meant the Sunnis, unlike the Peshmerga, were largely defenseless when ISIS overran their territories. They also feared the Iraqi Army as a result of how Maliki used it to suppress anti-government protests against his policies in their regions in 2013.

Maliki's successor Haider al-Abadi is a much more conciliatory premier than Maliki, but is in a weaker position. Having inherited the ISIS crisis he made sufficient headway in rolling back the ISIS threat, with close American support, and in the Mosul offensive oversaw productive coordination between the Iraqi Army and Peshmerga against a common enemy. The Kurds say counter-terrorism cooperation will continue after they eventually break from Iraq. Erbil could also potentially act as an intermediary between Baghdad and the Sunnis of Nineveh for some kind of reconciliation arrangement. 

However, if Baghdad ultimately fails to successfully reconcile with the Sunnis and they opt for greater autonomy or decentralization it's the aforementioned alienating actions of Iraq's former premier which would be to blame, not the Kurds' aim to exercise their own right of self-determination.


Comments

 
Rustembekov | 20/6/2017
There must also be an area of Iraq for the Christians,otherwise there would be more problems to come. As a part Assyrian woman ,I can tell you there are million of Christians ready to volunteer for our rights. Even USA would be afraid to bomb millions of Christians.
FAUthman | 21/6/2017
Baghdad cannot effectively reconcile with Sunnis because Sunnis do not control territories in Iraq anymore. Sunni lands have been swallowed up by the Iran backed Shiia militia all the way from north of Baghdad to the border of the Kurdish territories, south to north, and all the way from the Iranian border to the Syrian border, east to west. (look up the latest Iraq terrain control map on the ISW blog). Abadi has no control over these areas except for the military garrisons around Mosul and in the few camps between Baghdad and Mosul.
FAUthman | 21/6/2017
Here is the ISW link: http://iswresearch.blogspot.com/
Non kurd | 21/6/2017
Maliki has an inferiority complex which fuels his crab mentality.
C G Cattermole | 21/6/2017
Correct. It is widely forgotten that the genesis of IS was the 12 years' repression of Sunnis by Maliki's Shia-sectarian government in Iraq, and 40 years' repression by the Assads' Alawite government in Syria.

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

Gerbert d'Aurillac | 8/20/2017 7:26:02 AM
Germany and Europe are scared of Turkey. They know that Turkey is behinde the jihadists who kill them, but they are cowed. Europe has lost the...
Mark Antonio | 8/20/2017 1:12:07 PM
Why are foreigners allowed to vote in German elections?
Tit for tat, Erdogan tells German Turks to vote against 'aggressive' parties
| yesterday at 11:00 | (5)
TheFacto | 8/20/2017 12:41:31 PM
I will die for Kurdistan ! I will defend every inch of Kurdistan. I will take a bullet for Kurdistan. Yan Kurd Yan Naman! Never back down and keep ur...
President Barzani: Date of referendum is out of the question
| 11 hours ago | (1)
Adel Amini | 8/20/2017 12:25:37 PM
Masoud Barzani as ever is up to facing difficulties and keeping strong with every dick and harry asking to forget the independence referend...
No alternative to September 25 referendum yet, member of Erbil negotiation team in Baghdad
| 18/8/2017 | (1)
The realist Kurd is here | 8/20/2017 9:49:07 AM
Good job, the Kurds should stand up against any country that's dictating them. We lost many young heroes to come to this stage where we're now thus...
Adel Amini | 8/20/2017 12:15:48 PM
Yes, keep away from interfering in Kurds affairs in Iraq, shut your mouth and mind your business. Look after your Iran and keep away from elsewhere...
Peshmerga tell Iran military chief to keep out of Kurdistan affairs
| 18/8/2017 | (24)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

Kirkuk Governor: Kurdistan should allocate presidency posts for minorities 6 hours ago |

Kirkuk Governor: Kurdistan should allocate presidency posts for minorities

Kirkuk authorities demolish tens of houses daily more
UPDATES: Iraqi PM announces operation to retake Turkmen city of Tal Afar 7 hours ago | (1)

UPDATES: Iraqi PM announces operation to retake Turkmen city of Tal Afar

Coalition to provide equipment, training, more
Far-right group sees anti-migrant sea mission as a success 14 hours ago | (3)

Far-right group sees anti-migrant sea mission as a success

Operation Defend Europe came to an abrupt end more
0.422 seconds