Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Login

Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using
 

Email

 

Rudaw

Analysis

Are the Kurds displacing Arabs in Iraq and Syria?

By Paul Iddon 21/1/2016
 A Peshmerga guard scans the horizon at one of the frontlines. Photo: Rudaw
A Peshmerga guard scans the horizon at one of the frontlines. Photo: Rudaw

In the space of a few months Amnesty International has issued two reports condemning the conduct of Kurds in both Syria and Iraq in their war against the Islamic State (ISIS). Both of which accuse the Kurds of essentially displacing Arab populations in order to shift the demographics in their favour under the fog of war against ISIS.

The first took aim at the Syrian Kurds accusing them of purposely displacing Arabs in a bid to consolidate their own autonomy at their expense. This followed Ankara’s accusations in the summer of 2015 that Syrian Kurds were committing a form of ethnic cleansing in Gire Spi (Tal Abyad) when they displaced approximately 20,000 of the town’s residents when they ousted ISIS from there. However it’s important to remember that the Kurds themselves were essentially ethnically cleansed from that town a mere two years beforehand by Jabhat al-Nusra who put out a fatwa against them and encouraged people to steal their property and enslave their women and children. The Syrian Kurds can no doubt be forgiven for being paranoid that in the Arab towns they may come under attack from either sleeper cells or sympathizers of the group. This hasn’t, however, stopped them from cooperating with and assisting Arab, Assyrian or Turkmen groups in the areas where their forces are fighting against ISIS nor have they sought to fundamentally shift the demographics by forcing out minorities. If anything they have striven to showcase the fact that they are building up their area to be a safe haven for minorities who face either displacement or death were ISIS to prevail over the Syrian Kurds on the battle-field.

This certainly doesn’t mean that the Syrian Kurds are perfect. But considering the circumstances and nature of this struggle they have performed admirably well. As have the armed force of the Kurdistan Region, the Peshmerga.

The Kurdistan Region is swollen with internally displaced persons (IDPs) who have fled violence from elsewhere in Iraq since the rise of ISIS. The region has sheltered an enormous 1.8 million of them and the Peshmerga are the only force who is guaranteeing their safety. The destruction of some empty previously ISIS-occupied Arab villages on the front-lines has self-evidently been borne out of necessity and prudence more than anything else.

“Back in September I embedded with the Peshmerga during a battle around Kirkuk,” journalist Benedetta Argentieri told Rudaw, “ISIS decided not to fight the Kurds, instead they put IEDs [improvised explosive device] on all the roads around and booby-trapped each house in the several villages that Peshmerga were trying to get back from the jihadi. As I was told by several sources ISIS employs this military technique very often.”

“Instead of sending EOD [explosive ordnance disposal] teams to clear the area,” she continued, “the Peshmerga decided to tear down the houses. It was primarily a security concern, since you can’t be a hundred percent sure the area has been cleared. Also with little resources, Peshmerga are trying to preserve men as much as possible.”

“I was very surprised to read the Amnesty report on this issue, since it seems it didn’t really take into account the obvious security concerns about repopulation certain areas,” she concluded.

The depopulated IED-laden villages bulldozed by the Peshmerga are along the front-lines, where incidentally it’s estimated the majority of Peshmerga’s casualties were caused by the lethal IED’s ISIS has strewn across the landscape. A protracted effort to defuse all the IEDs with limited equipment and resources and risk losing more military personnel while not holding onto those villages (many of which are in areas Iraq also claims sovereignty over) would be wholly untenable for obvious reasons. This has proven to be the unfortunate price that has to be paid by this costly war of attrition.

Amnesty’s reports and more general investigations into the conduct of the Kurds engaged in this war are certainly necessary as it’s important to assess the conduct of an armed force in a time of war, even if they are engaged against a reprehensible enemy which takes pride in showcasing its many war crimes and crimes against humanity. However the absence of any suggestion of an alternative course of action for the Kurds to take in their war against ISIS is disheartening and does little more than place an unnecessarily large blot on the Peshmerga’s earnest efforts to fight this dirty war as cleanly as they feasibly can.

Paul Iddon is a Rudaw reporter based in Erbil, Kurdistan Region.

The views expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the position of Rudaw.

Comments

 
Data pager
Previous
123
Page size:
PageSizeComboBox
select
Rafeh Hulays | 21/1/2016
Whenever one side's actions are criticized in Amnesty International reports, the default reaction is denial, criticism and soon to follow accusations. The reality is that Amnesty is very thorough in its investigations and is rather conservative when making accusations. It behooves Kurdish authorities to investigate these charges and remedy any action found unwanting rather than react in a knee Jerk defensive fashion.
Jiyan | 21/1/2016
I have noticed for the past many years, as far back as the Iraq war in 2003 that Amnesty International has displayed a motive to demonize the Kurds!!! Makes one wonder who within the organization or behind the curtain is behind these acts. I have also noticed from my own personal experience, that many of the employees at the UN headquarters in Erbil (some in key positions), as well as some at USA NGOs are often Arabs from MENA who don't necessarily have any sympathy for the Kurds, and often they are the roadblocks for cultural projects to be implemented.
Azad zaxoy | 21/1/2016
are kurds displacing arabs ? Yes they are.
Forked tongue | 21/1/2016
Amnesty International is the "Fog horn", just like the United Nations. Both generate apparent outrage that X is killing Y and the hand-wringing, moralistic bastards sit there and do fuck all about a WAR. Kurds and the allied Syrian Forces against evil - attention please! Kill the vermin which is the scourge of humanity. Russia and the Coalition, please keep going.
Human | 21/1/2016
I wonder Who runs Amnesty, who are they ? do they have any idea how this war works?

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

pedo | 6/23/2018 4:02:18 AM
thanks
Registration opens for party alliances in KRG elections
| 18/6/2018 | (1)
not armed! | 6/18/2018 9:31:36 PM
I suppose KRG will be happy to take up arms against the Kurdish freedom fighters to protect Iran? Brilliant!!!!!
OneNation | 6/22/2018 11:42:26 PM
Kick them out KRG, bunch of grandpa led communist terrorists. Iran will not tolerate tribalists, racists and children of landowners/khans b...
KRG won’t let armed parties harm ties with Tehran: spokesperson
| 17/6/2018 | (2)
Mehdi giudarzi | 6/22/2018 7:38:35 PM
Ok
To many trolls | 6/22/2018 9:04:13 PM
As usual no shortages of Turkish and Iranian trolls here, most times they post under Kurdish sounding names lashing out at the US Israel etc. other...
World Cup 2018: Who is Iran’s Kurdish goalkeeper?
| yesterday at 10:07 | (10)
Frank | 6/22/2018 10:40:20 AM
No up until now the US has upheld all it's commentment to the Kurds of Rojava, they defused the situation in Manbij and prevented a Turkish assault...
US Patriot for Kurdistan | 6/22/2018 2:08:07 PM
Sorry, the US never had a presence in Afrin and they never promised the Kurds in Afrin that they would come there to provide help in any way,...
We are staying in Manbij: US general
| yesterday at 07:03 | (6)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

Iran at OPEC: Kirkuk pipeline would increase current oil exports 10-fold 9 hours ago |

Iran at OPEC: Kirkuk pipeline would increase current oil exports 10-fold

we need to increase the level of this swap more
Coalition drops leaflets of ISIS leaders over eastern Syria: monitor 9 hours ago |

Coalition drops leaflets of ISIS leaders over eastern Syria: monitor

"We are in al-Zibah village at the moment more
Burned Kurdish schoolgirls to appeal to President Rouhani for care abroad 11 hours ago |

Burned Kurdish schoolgirls to appeal to President Rouhani for care abroad

Thirty-seven of the girls were injured more
0.235 seconds