Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Login

Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using
 

Email

 

Rudaw

Analysis

KRG independence wouldn’t stir up separatism in other Kurdistans

By Paul Iddon 23/7/2017
Kurdish flags and posters reading
Kurdish flags and posters reading "Yes to referendum" hang on the walls of the ancient citadel in downtown Erbil. Photo by Farzin Hassan/Rudaw

The perennial argument against the independence of the Kurdistan Region is that it will embolden and inspire neighbouring Kurdish regions to secede too from their central governments.  

The Kurdistan Regional Government (KRG) officials are cognizant of these fears and have sought to reassure neighbouring states ahead of the planned September 25 referendum that that won’t be the case. 

“When we talk about a referendum, we talk about Kurdistan in Iraq only,” clarified Falah Mustafa Bakir, the Kurdistan Region's foreign relations chief.

Safeen Dizayee, the chief of staff to the region's prime minister, also told the Turkish press earlier this year that after the KRG holds talks with Baghdad on an “amicable divorce” it will do the same “with our other neighbours so that they do not see this newborn entity as a threat to their security and stability. We are talking about the borders of Iraqi Kurdistan alone. We have no ambitions of a territory in Iran, Syria and Turkey.” 

Nevertheless, the old argument still persists: Reuters recently, for example, assessed that the independence referendum will constitute “a move that will strain Iraq's frayed federal unity and annoy neighbors Syria, Turkey and Iran, who also have sizable Kurdish populations.” 

While both Ankara and Tehran have voiced strong opposition to the referendum an independent Kurdistan Region could actually prove beneficial to them.

Nobody frames the Kurdistan Region's independence quest as a Kurdish acceptance of a rump state rather than some kind of a Greater Kurdistan encompassing Diyarbakir, Qamishli and Sanandaj, in addition to Erbil. 

Therefore in the future either Ankara or Tehran could, with some plausibility, say to any separatist Kurds they face in the future that there is already a fully-fledged and recognized Kurdish state in the region. 

Furthermore, separatist tendencies in the three other Kurdish regions in the Middle East are not as prevalent as in the past. The Kurdistan Workers Party (PKK) advocates decentralization over outright independence, in adherence to the democratic confederalism political system Abdullah Ocalan has advocated in recent years. This proposed system takes issue with the very idea of a nation state since, in Ocalan's own words, “the foundation of a state does not increase the freedom of a people.” 

The Syrian Kurds follow this very same system. Iran's Tasnim News interviewed Abdul Karim Saroukhan, the prime minister of Syria Kurdistan's largest canton Jazira, this month. He said the Syrian Kurdish Democratic Union Party “have no plan to be separated from Syria.” 

Additionally, while the region “has no relations with the central government of Syria since Damascus has refused to recognize them” they “do not plan to fight the government.” 

In Iran itself the Kurdistan Democratic Party of Iran (KDPI) and Iran-Kurdistan Free Life Party (PJAK) don't necessarily seek independence for Iranian Kurdistan. Even at the height of the Iranian regimes suppression of their movement by Ayatollah Khomeini in the 1980s the KDPI advocated “Kurdish national rights within a democratic federal republic of Iran” over outright separatism. Given the fact PJAK is essentially the PKK's Iran offshoot they likely adhere to Ocalan's preference to democratic federalism, as the PYD does in Syria.

Furthermore, Iraqi Kurdish independence would unlikely result in a concerted effort from the Kurdistan Region in support of Kurdish separatist groups in neighbouring countries. The record aptly demonstrates they have favored negotiations to end conflicts. Kurdish President Masoud Barzani has invariably stated that he would like to see the Turkish-PKK conflict ended through renewed peace negotiations and even offered his services to mediate them. 

A Kurdish state that is conscious of its neighbours sensitivities on the Kurdish question would therefore be in the interest of these neighbours as well as for the pursuit of peace in these troubled regions. 

The Kurdistan Region itself earnestly sought to make a federal Iraq succeed following the overthrow of the brutal Saddam Hussein regime in 2003. These efforts have failed. While incumbent Iraqi Prime Minister Haider al-Abadi is probably the best Iraqi leader Erbil will ever deal with in Baghdad he is in a weak position and it's unclear if he can even secure a second-term, given the powerful Iranian-backed elements in Iraq who want to bring his government down. 

Abadi's predecessor Nouri al-Maliki even threatened the Kurdistan Region's autonomy when he was in power, by seeking to pull command and control over the Peshmerga away from Kurdish authorities and talking about invading. A figure close to, or controlled by, Maliki may become prime minister in the foreseeable future – which is one reason Erbil is now pushing full steam ahead in negotiating its independence on good terms and not miss a, possibly short-lived, historic opportunity for statehood. A state which has a clear potential to be a significant factor for stability in an otherwise chronically unstable region.

Comments

 
Data pager
Previous
12
Page size:
PageSizeComboBox
select
The Kurdish State as a peace-maker | 23/7/2017
Evidence tells how Barzani helped to appease for a long while the Turkish-kurdish war,; and Turkey is the first to recognize that. A proto-Kurdish State of South Kurdistan will be an efficent remedy for the hitherto denial and violence used by the neighbouring states of the Kurdish demands.It is reasonable to think that most of this aggressive treatment of the Kurds is due to the fact that those states do indeed fully deny the existence of the Kurds ; an attitude that will ,of course , change dramatically once the Kurdish State emerges and commercial ties are knotted with those countries.
Gerbert d'Aurillac | 23/7/2017
Everybody can be confident that the upcoming establishment of the Kurdish State will happen soon after the 25 September referendum and it will be a truly smooth sailing. The Unites State will make it so. No doubts whatsoever.
Ibrahim Ariyan | 23/7/2017
In order to protect the new-born Kurdistan, this generation of Kurdish politicians will not have the ambition of a Greater Kurdistan. But for the generation of our children and grandchild, you see, those Kurds will not stand idle while their brethren in Diyarbakir, Qamishlo, and Mahabad are not free from their oppressors. So think 30-50 years from now, as Kurds' enemies. KRG will become a state and other parts will follow suit and none of their oppressors can stop this process.
PLINY THE KURD | 23/7/2017
...and some say that the Kurdish independence is of great risk for ...China, because it fears that the Kurdish independence could trigger the separation of Tibet ;... others say that it could trigger the idependence of California or Washington DC from the U.S.A. There are so many colourful "arguments" for the nasty, the wicked and all kinds of anti -kurdish elements. - A question : would the Kurdish case be the first case in history of a country to declare its independence ? The U.S.A had once ,too, declared its independence from Engand ; and England, nevertheless , is the most close ally of the USA.
altani | 23/7/2017
I don't care what happens in Syria, Iraq or Iran. However I do care what happens in Turkey. Turkey will never, ever be divided. I rather would have a civil war than to see my country divided. Another thing, stop making fun of Mongols because I can tell you that if you make descendants of Gengiz Han angry, they will seek revenge. I really don't think that Kurdish women are prettier than Mongolian women.
Post a New Comment
Comment as a guest or Login for more enhanced interactive experience

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

karwan | 8/17/2017 11:55:45 PM
just F±±±± do it enough talking
The Kurdish Boy | 8/18/2017 8:21:12 PM
Shame on Gorran for hijacking Kurdish independence. It is pure ambitition and treason.
Gorran ready to meet with KDP next week: source
| 17/8/2017 | (3)
Hoshyar Zaxoy | 8/18/2017 6:56:24 PM
any chance of shelling Iran & Turkey military border units from south Kurdastan? It will be nice tit for tat.
Adam | 8/18/2017 7:54:52 PM
Yes hes right, he knows what exactly happens because they themselves will create those conflicts
Peshmerga tell Iran military chief to keep out of Kurdistan affairs
| yesterday at 05:36 | (4)
Pliny The Kurd | 8/18/2017 12:11:42 PM
Iraq has refused to apply the article 140 of its constitution . Those territories were taken from Kurds by Saddam with killings and genocide....
Muraz Adzhoev | 8/18/2017 3:59:03 PM
"The acting head of the Provincial Council in Kirkuk Rebwar Talabani said they received a response to the letter by Baghdad which stipulated that...
Second referendum is more likely in disputed areas, Kirkuk Governor suggests
| yesterday at 02:30 | (2)
Publish Me Fam | 8/18/2017 3:53:33 PM
He hasn't sold himself to no one, Iraqi's are not Iranians and that fact hurts Iranians a lot. They forget the fact that even tho Iraqi's are mostly...
Iraqi Shiite cleric's Saudi and UAE trips show Gulf realpolitik
| yesterday at 04:00 | (1)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

Far-right group sees anti-migrant sea mission as a success 1 hour ago |

Far-right group sees anti-migrant sea mission as a success

Operation Defend Europe came to an abrupt end more
Iraqi PM announces operation to retake Turkmen city of Tal Afar 3 hours ago |

Iraqi PM announces operation to retake Turkmen city of Tal Afar

Federal Police reports advances west of Tal Afar more
Local filmmaker creates cultural hangout with cinema café in Kurdistan 12 hours ago |

Local filmmaker creates cultural hangout with cinema café in Kurdistan

“I’m open to films that stimulate the minds more
0.141 seconds