Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Login

Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using
 

Email

 

Rudaw

Analysis

Militarily preventing Kurdish referendum will not serve Turkey's interests

By Paul Iddon 24/9/2017
Turkey conducts troop movements in the Silopi area of southeastern Turkey near the Kurdistan Region's border. Photo: AA
Turkey conducts troop movements in the Silopi area of southeastern Turkey near the Kurdistan Region's border. Photo: AA
The Turkish military is engaging in a military exercise directly on its border with the Kurdistan Region which is purposely coinciding with the upcoming independence referendum. This show of strength is doubtlessly symbolic and is unlikely to develop into anything more than, at most, a limited cross-border operation solely targeting the Kurdistan Workers Party (PKK).

Approximately 100 tanks and howitzer launchers are participating in this border exercise, a formidable array of firepower right on the region's doorstep. Ankara says this force is there to destroy, in Prime Minister Binali Yildirim's words, “any attempt that threatens our national security, from inside or outside our borders.” 

Turkey has pressured Kurdish President Masoud Barzani to cancel the September 25 referendum, something Barzani is adamantly pushing forward. While Turkey remains opposed to the idea of an independent Kurdistan Region Barzani and his Kurdistan Democratic Party (KDP) continues to constitute a major factor for stability in the Kurdistan Region and the only region neighbouring Turkey which it retains friendly ties with. This will remain true regardless of whether or not the region becomes independent or not. 

When the Turkish government views developments across northern Iraq as objectionable it invariably likes to flex its military muscles. Last year ahead of the Mosul operation it similarly massed its forces on the border to Silopi, threatening to intervene against the Shiite-majority Hashd al-Shaabi forces if they harmed Sunni Turkmen in Tal Afar. Such an intervention never took place. Turkey has also threatened on numerous occasions to intervene against the PKK in Shingal but has yet to do anything – with the sole exception of an airstrike last April which ended up killing Peshmerga soldiers rather than the intended PKK targets. 

Invading Kurdistan to prevent separation from Iraq would also weaken Barzani and empower other groups less friendly to Turkey, possibly even the PKK. This would be a far worse outcome for Turkey.  

If these current maneuvers amount to anything other than a show of strength it will likely be stepped up attacks on the PKK, more airstrikes on Qandil and possibly a small ground incursion just over the border. For months there have been statements from Turkish leaders and rumours in the Turkish press that Ankara planned to follow up its concluded Euphrates Shield campaign in Syria (against both Islamic State and the Syrian Kurdish People's Protection Units) with a similar Tigris Shield operation in the Kurdistan Region.  

Tigris Shield would likely entail sending ground forces to Khabur, which is where the borders between the Kurdistan Region, Turkey and Syria meet and is therefore an ideal crossing area for PKK operations in the wider region. A limited but highly publicized operation there along with intensified airstrikes against PKK could be presented at home as Turkey doing something to contain and counter these forces while doing nothing more about the referendum than voicing opposition to, and spreading conspiracy theories about, it. 

In the long-term Ankara might also offer Baghdad to withdraw its controversial troop presence from Bashiqa near Mosul in return for increased local efforts to compel, or even force, the PKK to leave Shingal, another development Ankara could present as victory to the Turkish public in lieu of taking military action against the Kurdistan Region itself. 

Ankara recently extended its troops deployed in both northwest Syria and Iraq's Bashiqa. While this decision does come just two days before the Kurdish referendum it is unlikely a move aimed at forcibly thwarting this endeavour. After all, the parliamentary mandate was initially improved in October 2014 and renewed, before this month, in September 2015 and October 2016, meaning this renewed mandate is more coincidental than intentional. 

Turkey is more likely to channel the momentum it has built up at home against the referendum into action against its more traditional Kurdish enemies, the PKK and more recently PYD Syrian Kurds, neither of whom Erbil has good relations with. This salient distinction hasn't been lost on Ankara, which clearly distinguished the Peshmerga from other Kurdish groups by offering the wounded among them medical treatment last year during the ISIS war. 

[Even before Turkish authorities made any real distinction between the PKK and the Kurdistan Region's leaders it didn't intervene with the 70,000 troops it had deployed on Kurdistan's borders, a much larger force than today's one, back in 2003.]

Ankara will not welcome the referendum nor ultimately independence. However, when faced with the clear outcome that directly attacking Kurdistan, to try and forcibly prevent these inevitable developments, will amount to little more than shooting itself in the foot, reality will ultimately compel it to come to terms.

Comments

 
Data pager
Previous
12
Page size:
PageSizeComboBox
select
Schkak, the Kurdish Painter | 24/9/2017
Good insight into the complex situation envolving the region. Let's hope, as the author rightly hints, that Turkey comes to terms with the compelling realities on the ground.
Let the wicked know that : | 24/9/2017
Kurdistan is the only safe and stable place in the region : during the last few years there have been not one single death in any terrorist attack in Erbil the capital of Kurdistan , while France, Britain, Spain and Germany have suffered from deadly terror attacks. Shame on those countries who say that voting the Kurdish referendum will destabilize the world. Shameful cynism and utter perfidy . Those sinister cynics among world leaders opposing the Kurdish right to vote should know that those who attacked Paris, Nice ,Berlin ,London,Manchester and Barcelona they were Arabs and not Kurds .They were Arabs bred in Baghdad the capital of Iraq which is the most violent and unstable country of the world. Shame on those western leaders who deny the brave and noble Kurds their right to vote . Shamefull and despicable .
Gerbert d'Aurillac | 24/9/2017
It is highly improbable that neither Turkey nor any other country would dare to intervene militarilly against Kurdistan .The rhetorical oposition to the the Kurdish referendum does not imply any military intervention .
C G Cattermole | 24/9/2017
Driving tanks around and parking them in neat lines. Long-distance artillery fire at Kurds who are committed to not firing back into Turkey. That's all TSK is up to these days. Particularly after it has been decapitated of all its better Generals . . .
Baizan | 24/9/2017
And why would we care about Turkey's interest? we clearly see that Turkey is the biggest obstacle in front of Kurdish interest everywhere. Turkey invading or using sanctions might very well turn into a good thing, if they go through with it kdp/barzani will loose power, either Iranian friendly groups or PKK will fill the power vacuum. Personally I don't like any of the parties we have but one party less means less divisions, it's better to have one big strong party emerge than 5 weak ones constantly bickering amongst themselves, being influenced and used by Baghdad Teheran and Ankara
4568 Views

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

Amed | 10/7/2018 10:26:05 AM
Once the PKK is eliminated the Kurds in the region will prosper with new trade with Turkey. PKK is a huge problem for the Kurds, they're preventing...
Bradost | 10/19/2018 8:49:43 AM
I wonder why they chose Mergasor, Kani Rash in Bradost region would have made more sense!
Locals expect economic boost from new Kurdistan-Turkey link
| 5/10/2018 | (5)
love Peshmerga, AK USA | 10/19/2018 1:16:18 AM
PUK always denies on every thing they do and what they say just like they denied giving kirkuk to Iraq regime also making thire frinds happy in Iran....
pete | 10/19/2018 6:39:44 AM
Both these parties are criminal organisations. They are the shame of Kurdistan. They make the Iraqi Kurds look like prehistoric fools to the...
PUK tells KDP to get over it, bigger challenges lie ahead
| yesterday at 10:26 | (6)
mark bishop | 10/18/2018 9:17:30 AM
After reading Masoud Barzani's statement on October 16, I believe that we are given only half of a message. He says that the events leading up to...
John Bird | 10/19/2018 3:27:59 AM
PUK is a great place for gangsters, hoodlums, mobsters, cutthroats, villains, bandits, crooks, racketeers and hooligans. But not for highly educated...
Former Kirkuk governor Karim denies joining KDP
| yesterday at 11:07 | (3)
Guest | 10/18/2018 1:49:48 PM
The individual who made a comment about the U.S. holding a gun to his head, doesn't understand what he is talking about. The U.S. government has...
Saad hussien | 10/19/2018 2:02:49 AM
Hello May you please send your email or atelephone no. To contact your company With my respect Eng. saad From CA/ USA
US's General Electric beats out Germany's Siemens for Iraq contract - report
| yesterday at 10:09 | (3)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

Kirkuk governor orders Kurdish groups, workers’ syndicates to vacate offices 16 hours ago |

Kirkuk governor orders Kurdish groups, workers’ syndicates to vacate offices

"We assure teachers that we won’t vacate this more
Trump says Saudi journalist likely dead, warns of ‘severe’ response 18 hours ago |

Trump says Saudi journalist likely dead, warns of ‘severe’ response

“It certainly looks that way to me. It’s very more
Turkey to host Syria summit with Russia, Germany, France 19 hours ago |

Turkey to host Syria summit with Russia, Germany, France

"To harmonize joint efforts for finding a lasting more
0.36 seconds