Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Login

Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using
 

Email

 

Rudaw

Analysis

Maliki's misguided slander of the Peshmerga

By Paul Iddon 27/7/2017
Peshmerga forces celebrate victories on the first day of the Mosul offensive, October 17, on the Khazir front. Photo: Farzin Hassan/Rudaw
Peshmerga forces celebrate victories on the first day of the Mosul offensive, October 17, on the Khazir front. Photo: Farzin Hassan/Rudaw
Former Iraqi prime minister, and current vice president, Nouri al-Maliki is known for making bellicose and dismissive remarks about the Kurdistan Region and its President Masoud Barzani. However, his latest criticism of the region's Kurdish Peshmerga forces is a new low. 

“He [Barzani] knows Peshmerga did not play any role in the fight against the Islamic State, that Erbil would have been given up to ISIS if it were not for the help of Iraqi, Iranian and US aviation. They have no real force,” Maliki told Sputnik News on his recent visit to Russia. 

Iran did provide Kurdistan with small arms in August 2014 when ISIS briefly threatened the region's capital Erbil. That move was in Tehran's own self-interest since Kurdistan serves as a de-facto bulwark standing between its own frontiers and ISIS. 

The Iranian “aviation” which Maliki speaks of was likely a reference to the speedy Iranian delivery of a handful of Russian-made Su-25 attack planes to Baghdad from their own arsenal during that fateful summer – planes which Iran initially acquired when Saddam Hussein surprisingly evacuated his air force to Iran in the 1991 Persian Gulf War. 

However, these planes were used primarily for the defense of Baghdad and did not come to Erbil's aid, nor did any Iraqi aircraft. US warplanes did fire the opening salvos of America's war against ISIS in defense of the Kurdish capital when it was threatened by US-made artillery guns, which the militants captured from the Iraqi Army’s arsenal. 

The security and stability of Kurdistan throughout the war provided American and Iraqi helicopters a safe and strategic launchpad from which to support ground operations against the militants.

Maliki's dismissal of the Kurdish forces as only capable when operating under a US aerial umbrella is also hypocritical. When Ramadi was recaptured by Iraqi forces in January 2016 he downplayed the US contribution, not evening mentioning Washington's crucial air support to that operation, while highlighting the secondary role the Iraqi Shiite Hashd al-Shaabi paramilitaries played. 

Regarding Mosul he argues that the main credit belongs to the Iraqi Army, but at least this time acknowledged that the Americans “supported us with their aviation.” 

Were it not for the Peshmerga, which Maliki left lightly armed and wanted to place under Baghdad's command and control when he was in power, ISIS may well have captured Kirkuk in June 2014 – which the Iraqi Army under Maliki's command were unable to defend at a critical point in time. 

Peshmerga sacrifices also prevented ISIS from capturing the strategic Makhmour Front. If it weren't for these sacrifices much more Iraqi blood would have had to be spilled in order to secure that front as a launchpad for the Mosul operation. 

In striking contrast, the former Iraqi premier often speaks glowingly of the Hashd al-Shaabi and Iranian contributions to the ISIS war effort. The Hashd did indeed initially hold the line against ISIS in places like Samarra when most regular units of the Iraqi Army, paralyzed by widespread corruption under Maliki's watch, were incapable of fighting. The Hashd therefore deserve credit and recognition at least for this. 

Nevertheless, the paramilitaries demonstrated their shortcomings as a fighting force when they attempted to fight ISIS without the regular army and US air support. They failed to capture Tikrit on their own in early 2015 and the village of Bashir in Kirkuk in 2016. The sectarian nature of groups within the Hashd also meant they were a force that would do more harm than good when it came to removing ISIS from Sunni-majority cities, which is the primary reason the US successfully pushed for their exclusion from the Mosul operation. 

Maliki's divisive nature may well have made the historic cooperation reached between the Iraqi Army and the Peshmerga on the eve of the Mosul operation impossible had he still been prime minister, which would have further complicated that fight and possibly even further delayed that operation. 

As of mid-July, the Peshmerga lost 1,745 troops – with another 10,000 injured – defending their region against ISIS, repelling the threat to their homeland and paving the way for Iraq's recapture of Mosul in the process. This deserves acknowledgement and credit from the former Iraqi prime minister rather than derision and crass revisionism of recent history. 

Comments

 
Data pager
Previous
12
Page size:
PageSizeComboBox
select
FAUthman | 27/7/2017
Maliki is famous for his misguided slander esp. of the Kurds. He thinks this way he can become the next prime minister again. But he will not. Abadi will beat him!
FreeSpeech | 27/7/2017
The auther is too kind with the lowlife Malaki. More than a hundered thousand Iraqi troops trained and armed by the American's for a decade under Malaki abandoned all their arms to ISIS and Peshmerga were left to defend their region with outdated light arms because like the aurhor mentiones Baghdad with Malaki at the helm had put a defacto arms embargo on Peshmerga forces since 2005
Kajik | 28/7/2017
These populist remarks should be discussed with Mr Maliki and should be prevented. KRG should contact Mr Malikis Secretery Mr Shaswar Abdulwahid and make an formal complaint.
Kajik | 28/7/2017
These populist remarks should be discussed with Mr Maliki and should be prevented. KRG should contact Mr Malikis Secretery Mr Shaswar Abdulwahid and make an formal complaint.
Peshmerga-4-life | 28/7/2017
Maliki is a idiot, he got a face of a donkey. Did he just say "peshmerga didn't play any role in fighting isis and kurdistan has no real force." Peshmerga fears no man and if it wasn't for peshmerga the entire Iraq would've now been under isis control. Unlike the "Iraqi forces" peshmerga doesn't abandon their weapons, land, women and children and run away like cowards.

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

siraj davis | 8/14/2018 5:22:57 PM
There may be 1000 ISIS fighters in Iraq. No way possible there are 30,000. Kirkuk has been a battle ground for ISIS since the fall of Mosul. If...
Hamid Sayadi | 8/15/2018 5:21:48 AM
the best shot for this cancers diseases is Take Turkey out of NATO ! you will see the Turkik dreams of the Sunny world will disappear. It is the Main...
20,000-30,000 IS fighters left in Iraq, Syria: UN report
| 13/8/2018 | (4)
Mister B | 8/15/2018 3:53:59 AM
There has to be taken into consideration that the fact that under the AKP rule, the leadership over a couple of years didn't make reforms concerning...
Hamid Sayadi | 8/15/2018 5:16:24 AM
Sorry, Erdogan, you need Rabies shot!
Why is Turkey facing economic oblivion?
| 13/8/2018 | (8)
Cary | 8/15/2018 2:14:28 AM
Erdogan forgets that he may be all powerful within the boarders of Turkey, but beyond that his power fades very quickly.
Jay | 8/15/2018 3:14:57 AM
Well put, it's time the dictator wake up from his hallucination and remember his place, he has become the school bully, abusing anyone who dares...
Trump sends Erdogan a reality check
| yesterday at 08:13 | (8)
FAUthman | 8/14/2018 6:58:52 PM
Very good article, thank you. In 2015 the year sanctions on Iran were lifted and one year since the start of the ISIS war, Iraqis sold their Iraqi...
M | 8/15/2018 3:02:28 AM
Abadi is backing off his promise to honor US sanctions. No surprise there.
Iraq’s compliance with Iran sanctions spooks Kurdish business
| yesterday at 10:27 | (3)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

Turkey sets Amnesty country chair Taner Kilic free 4 hours ago |

Turkey sets Amnesty country chair Taner Kilic free

"Beneath the smiles of joy and relief there is a more
Iraqi Sunnis form ‘National Axis Alliance’ to have voice in new government 6 hours ago |

Iraqi Sunnis form ‘National Axis Alliance’ to have voice in new government

“We today stand to announce for you a national more
The sweet taste of success: a Syrian's journey from Gitmo to pastries 7 hours ago |

The sweet taste of success: a Syrian's journey from Gitmo to pastries

His stand has small chalkboards advertising some more
0.531 seconds