Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Login

Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using
 

Email

 

Rudaw

Analysis

The geopolitical significance of the Russian deployment to Afrin

By Paul Iddon 29/3/2017
A Russian tank entering the city of Afrin in Rojava. Photo: Youtube screenshot
A Russian tank entering the city of Afrin in Rojava. Photo: Youtube screenshot
Russia's deployment of ground forces to the small isolated northwestern Syrian Kurdish Afrin Canton has, predictably, frustrated Turkey. Coupled with the US and Russian deployment of ground forces to the Kurdish-led Syrian Democratic Forces' (SDF) administered city of Manbij, to stop Turkish-backed militiamen from attacking the deployment, this greatly hinders Turkish attempts to target either the SDF or the Syrian Kurdish People's Protection Units (YPG). 

While Moscow has sought to downplay the significance of the deployment – claiming it is another reconciliation center to monitor truces as opposed to an active troop deployment to work with the YPG there – it does nevertheless have significant geopolitical implications. 

“Russian-Turkish relations are extremely strained right now,” noted Syria analyst Professor Joshua Landis told Rudaw English. “Turkey has been helping al-Qaeda get arms. Russia and Assad blame Turkey for the recent Hama offensive as well as the Ghoutta/Joubar offensive in Damascus.”

“Russia's move to help the Kurds build military capacity is an escalation meant to punish Turkey for refusing to stop its support to Tahrir al-Sham and anti-Assad militias,” he concluded. 

Afrin would be an ideal launchpad for any future military campaign against militants, like the al-Qaeda-affiliated Tahrir al-Sham, in the nearby Idlib province.    

Russia and Turkey patched up their ties seven month after the November 2015 warplane last summer, which resulted in a mini cold war between the two in which Moscow leveled economic sanctions against Ankara and beefed up its air defenses in Syria. However, Russia continued to voice its opposition to Turkish targeting of SDF/YPG forces in its campaign against Islamic State (ISIS) – which concluded with their capture of al-Bab from the militants in February. Shortly after the Russian deployment Turkey claimed one of its soldiers was killed by sniper fire emanating from Afrin. It retaliated with its own cross-border fire.  

“The deployments to Manbij and Afrin are significant,” Neil Hauer, the lead analyst at SecDev who follows Russian-Syrian relations, told Rudaw English. “The former signifies that Russia has some hard red lines in Syria it does not want Ankara to cross, while Afrin was even more of an escalation in that sense. Turkey has always declared it retains the right to shell the YPG in Afrin, which it periodically does, and Russian presence makes that much more difficult.”

Turkey has sought to forcibly halt YPG excursions from Afrin, launched against militant groups which have attacked Afrin, by targeting them with cross-border artillery strikes in February 2016 when they launched an offensive which captured the Menagh Airbase.

“The intense reaction to the killing of a single Russian pilot by Turkish forces in 2015 suggests that Russia would raise similar issues were a Russian soldier to be killed by Turkish shelling,” Hauer added. “The Atlantic Council's Turkey analyst Aaron Stein has detailed recently how Turkish/Russian cooperation is waning and now that IS has been evicted from nearly all of Aleppo, the aims of the two no longer coincide.”

He went on to point out that Ankara has “accepted that its initial aim in Syria of toppling Assad can no longer be accomplished.” 

“Now,” he elaborated, “Russia is increasingly blocking its secondary and more existential objective, diminishing and restraining a Syrian Kurdish polity.”

“I think relations are going to worsen significantly in the coming months,” he concluded. 

Tumur Akhmetov, an analyst on Russia's Middle East foreign policy, noted that while the deployment “was limited in its scale and tasks, it has a serious symbolic meaning.” 

“Russia is trying to secure its position as one of the players, and therefore a part of any solution, within the conflict between the [Syrian Kurdish Democratic Union Party] PYD/YPG and Turkey,” he told Rudaw English. 

“In the longer run, it must increase negotiating positions of Russia vis-a-vis Turkey during efforts to end a civil war in Syria,” he added. 

Asked if Russia is enforcing a de-facto ceasefire between the PYD/YPG and Turkey Akmetov said this seems to be the case.

“Maybe there were plans in Turkey to expand the Euphrates Shield westwards and Russia was acting to prevent this,” he speculated. “Now Turkey sees Russia responsible for everything that is flying from Afrin Canton.”

“So it bears some risks for Russia,” he concluded.

Comments

 
Dutchman | 29/3/2017
More remarkable than Russias noisy presence in Afrin and Manbij, is the complete silence in the USA about it. One might think that Washington would not be pleased with the Russian involvement, but the opposite is true. Secure borders of Western Rojova allows the YPG/SDF and the US-led coalition to concentrate on the main goals on short term (liberate Raqqa), medium term (destroy IS in Syria) and longer term (replacing the cruel Assad minority regime by a democracy).
FAUthman | 5/4/2017
Great column by Iddon and a good comment above by Dutchman!fascinating this whole triangle of Russia/Turkey/US, and how Kurds can navigate through this complex maze of relationships with Assad and the rebels competing to eliminate each other!

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

A Kurd in exile | 6/26/2017 1:01:44 AM
Let's hope that the PBS'S program "Front-line" or something will show this film in the U.S., as well. I really like to see it. It will also be a...
Dorinca Villegas | 6/26/2017 1:08:43 AM
This is a long but great inspiring review. I was intrigued to the story and wanted to see the film. I got a Sence of the commitment that Bazidi had...
Kobani: Landscape of Resistance and Childhood Nostalgia
| yesterday at 03:36 | (4)
He lies | 6/25/2017 8:09:08 PM
Bloodpressure is not rekated to diabetes , so he is lying as usually does.
Guest | 6/26/2017 12:42:32 AM
I am sorry that Erdogan is still alive! He should have been in HELL by now. A special room has been prepared for him in there.
Turkish President Erdogan in good condition after Eid prayer collapse
| yesterday at 05:30 | (7)
duroi | 6/25/2017 10:52:22 PM
Raqqa is smaller than west of Mosul and bigger than Manbij. YPG at this stage needs to carefully think through the uncertain aftermath of Raqqa and...
Stewee Guy
Stewee Guy | 6/26/2017 12:30:00 AM
Mr. Erdogan, relax and take it easy you almost died today from your hate toward Kurds.
US, Turkey still disagree on arming Kurds, as SDF progress into Raqqa
| yesterday at 11:40 | (4)
Ashur | 6/25/2017 9:51:06 PM
Do Kurds want to occupy more land? They can go to Hawija but should leave Assyria;
Dutchman | 6/25/2017 10:19:32 PM
The Peshmerga are much to passive last months. They should have taken the Yezidi territories south of Singal long ago, instead of waiting for shiite...
Islamic State's last stand in Iraq: Who will liberate Hawija?
| yesterday at 10:30 | (2)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

Iran's supreme leader pardons 1,049 prisoners on Eid occasion 23 hours ago |

Iran's supreme leader pardons 1,049 prisoners on Eid occasion

Khamenei pardoned or commuted prison terms more
Islamic State's last stand in Iraq: Who will liberate Hawija? yesterday at 10:30 | (2)

Islamic State's last stand in Iraq: Who will liberate Hawija?

there could be Peshmerga and Hashd cooperation more
Shiite authorities in Iraq declare Monday to be Eid al-Fitr yesterday at 09:30 | (1)

Shiite authorities in Iraq declare Monday to be Eid al-Fitr

the new moon wasn’t seen in Islamic and Arab more
0.359 seconds