Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Login

Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using
 

Email

 

Rudaw

Interview

Saudis will never admit MbS was culpable – but he’s still finished: British colonel

By Robert Edwards 24/10/2018
Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman. File photo: AFP
Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman. File photo: AFP
ERBIL, Kurdistan Region – Although Riyadh will never admit Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman was culpable in the killing of dissident journalist Jamal Khashoggi, his days as de facto ruler are numbered, according to Britain’s former defense attaché to Saudi Arabia and Yemen.

Colonel Brian Lees, author of A Handbook of the Al Sa’ud Ruling Family of Saudi Arabia and an expert on the inner workings of the Gulf kingdom, says the credibility of the Saudi monarchy rests on whether Mohammed bin Salman (MbS) stays or goes.

“The Saudis will never admit that MbS was culpable but this does not mean that he is in the clear,” Lees told Rudaw English by email. “I believe that the king – assuming he is in one of his ‘clear’ periods – will get rid of MbS by replacing him. 

“He cannot do so immediately, or even in the next few months, because that would look like bowing to foreign pressure. He may use the already established device of using the special advisory council within the family to appoint a successor. This would certainly restore the credibility of the monarchy,” Lees added. 

Washington Post columnist Khashoggi – who was living in self-exile in the US – was killed on October 2 inside the Saudi consulate in Istanbul, where he was reportedly collecting marriage documents. His Turkish fiancé was waiting outside.

Turkish state media – in extremely gruesome detail – claims a 15-man Saudi hit squad arrived at the consulate and murdered the Saudi critic, then attempted to cover up his disappearance. 

Two weeks after the journalist vanished – and having passionately denied the allegations – the Saudi government finally admitted Khashoggi was killed inside the consulate (allegedly in a “fist fight”) but continued to deny any state involvement. 

The international community has not bought the story. 

“The Saudi version is not credible in the least,” said Lees. “The team visiting Istanbul were certainly not tourists and the person seen to leave the consulate in Khashoggi’s clothes was obviously not him. Even Trump now admits that this was the most inept cover-up of all times.”

The killing has sparked a global diplomatic crisis, which threatens to leave the world’s biggest oil producer isolated unless the Saudi’s can come up with a convincing account of events – and turn over Khashoggi’s body.

“The international community’s response has been stumbling,” said Lees. “Trump has changed his mind daily but is likely to bow to Congressional pressure. 

“Britain is sidelined but will hide under the European cloak. Russia and China hope to benefit, but they are not natural allies, although the Saudis will use them to threaten the West. 

“The Saudis rely on the US and will continue to do so,” Lees added.

Where does this leave regional powers Iran, Israel, and (perhaps the most intimately involved player) Turkey? 

“Iran just needs to let the Saudis continue to shoot themselves in the foot,” said Lees. “The much vaunted rapprochement from Israel (Trump’s son-in-law’s idea) must be dead in the water.”

“Turkey would certainly like to take over the Saudi role and return to the Ottoman Empire, but this is a pipe-dream. The Saudis control the two most holy places and MbS was criticized publicly by the king for supporting the US recognition of Jerusalem as the capital of Israel. In any case, Erdogan has enough on his plate with a faltering economy,” Lees added.

MbS was widely seen by Middle East watchers as the young reformer who would modernize Saudi Arabia, diversify its economy away from oil, and ease the kingdom’s strict social conservatism.

Lees says the image of reform was always a sham.

“The reform drive is by no means dead because it was largely cosmetic in the first place,” he said. “The western media focused on women being allowed to drive – big deal! 

“Dissidents, including women, are in jail; no real moves on liberty; Aramco [is] unlikely to be part-privatized for the foreseeable future; no extension of religious freedom. The catalogue goes on.”

Comments

 
Data pager
Previous
12
Page size:
PageSizeComboBox
select
Jay | 24/10/2018
Only the gullable, naive and stupid would believe that the young Prince is innocent. The prince sends a group of his inner circle to Turkey to murder Khashoggi, it was all planned, so whatever Saudis say about him not having knowledge is pure lie. I also believe the Prince will stay, he is the king' s selection and if he goes the whole royal family will go with him. It's a hot issue now but we will see in a couple of months it will be a forgotten story and Britain and US will continue selling SA weapons to bomb civilians. Erdogan on the other hand will use his embezzlement techniques to extract a few hundred millions from the Saudis and will go quite.
Diver | 24/10/2018
Like Romano pointed out in his piece, what the Saudis did was no worse than what the Turks, Iranians,, Syrians, Iraqis even Americans do on a regular bases, so this is all a deliberate campaign spearheaded by Turkey, Iran and certain elements in the West.
karwan | 24/10/2018
"MbS was widely seen by Middle East watchers as the young reformer who would modernize Saudi Arabia, diversify its economy away from oil, and ease the kingdom’s strict social conservatism" . And there's your answer why every power from A to Z (with a few exceptions) want the Saudi crown prince gone! all the reform steps he took is forgotten, or even dismissed as "symbolic". As if he can turn a culture like the Saudis into a liberal democracy over night! the Shah of Iran tried something like that and look that happened to him!
pre-Boomer Marine brat | 24/10/2018
Anyone who thinks that particular monarchy has "credibility" should (1) study the history of the Hashemite dynasty with respect to the Hejaz, and (2) study the reason behind the spread of reactionary, Jihad-focused Wahhabism (yes, "ism") across the face of the planet.
MBS | 24/10/2018
Maybe MBS should also let it’s media run 24/7 those pictures of Erdogans killer commandos tanks and jets butchering and overrunning Kurds and about Turkish crimes against the world. The Turks are after MBS and Trump and Europe is helping them. I can’t imagine that those will not handle turkey. I think the Turks try to tranquilize them with fear but they should do exactly the same.
4876 Views

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

Luigi Palermo | 3/26/2019 6:41:01 AM
America is already preparing for a Turkish occupation of Rojava letting Turks kill Kurds and occupy their land. America is responsible for any...
After ISIS – what next for the SDF?
| 17 hours ago | (1)
Sayjee | 3/26/2019 5:38:43 AM
Lets not blame all turks for these comments, but the biggest threat to "safety" since the crusaders has been turkish and tatar mamluks.
Stop killing Kurds | 3/26/2019 6:32:14 AM
America and the world used and abused the Kurds as sacrificial animals : 11000 Kurds killed, other 22000 wounded suffering without health care in...
‘No YPG forces’ in Syria safe zone with Turkey: US
| 15 hours ago | (5)
Heshmat | 3/26/2019 5:17:11 AM
Good, iraq always been inseparable part of iran for millenniums. Lets celebrate when iraq gets annexed to iran empire
Bridge linking Iraq to Kurdistan Region ‘may collapse at any moment’
| 14 hours ago | (1)
Jarrett | 3/25/2019 9:03:10 PM
As if there are really roads in Kurdistan specially between Dohuk Erbil and Erbil Suleimani, for some 20 years corrupt officials have embezzled...
Heavy rains block roads, damage homes in Kurdistan Region
| yesterday at 12:00 | (1)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

Bridge linking Iraq to Kurdistan Region ‘may collapse at any moment’ 14 hours ago | (1)

Bridge linking Iraq to Kurdistan Region ‘may collapse at any moment’

"This may bring a catastrophe for us" more
‘No YPG forces’ in Syria safe zone with Turkey: US 15 hours ago | (5)

‘No YPG forces’ in Syria safe zone with Turkey: US

"Turkey feels very nervous about the YPG and more
Syrian group wants international tribunal for ISIS detainees 16 hours ago |

Syrian group wants international tribunal for ISIS detainees

"We can’t put up with this burden alone" more
0.375 seconds