Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment


Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using





No alternative to referendum as of yet, Kurdish official

By Rudaw 4/8/2017
Kurdish man sells traditional Kurdish hats  in Erbil. File Photo: AFP/Safin Hamid
Kurdish man sells traditional Kurdish hats in Erbil. File Photo: AFP/Safin Hamid
DARBANDIKHAN, Kurdistan Region – A senior Kurdish official has hinted that the Kurdistan Region is prepared to accept “an alternative” to the independence referendum if they are given regional and international “guarantees” that makes sure, beyond any doubt, that the Kurds will have their rights protected through a new arrangement. 
Mala Bakhtiar, a senior member of the ruling Patriotic Union of Kurdistan (PUK), whose party is instrumental in the bid to hold referendum in less than two months, said that a “confederation” can be a viable solution as a new arrangement between Erbil and Baghdad.
“We will either be part of the equation to [get] the legal guarantees to our rights on an international and regional level, or we will ourselves decide on our destiny,” the official said as he addressed a gathering in Darbandikhan, south of Sulaimani on Thursday night.
He said his party met with Turkish and Iranian diplomats, as well the UN Envoy to Iraq Ján Kubiš in the last two days, all reiterating the fact that the Kurds are right when they mention that Iraq has not been committed to the Iraqi constitution, including the budget that has been cut by Baghdad since early 2014, and Article 140 that concerns the disputed, or Kurdistani, areas claimed by Erbil and Baghdad.
Bakhtiar however said that this is not enough, and that such talks will not fool the Kurds.
“We have not seen a guarantee as an alternative to referendum. And we will not be deceived by the language used by this or that official. Let everyone hear this — and this is not my opinion, but also the opinion of every Kurdistani parties — we will not be deceived by the language of any official, in Iraq or the region. We demand legal and international guarantees [stipulating] that the structure of Iraq be changed, and for us to be reassured of our destiny in the region, not just in Iraq, but also in the region,” the official said, hinting that one solution, as an alternative to an independent Kurdistan could be a confederation between Erbil and Baghdad.
He said the era when regional and other countries can decide on behalf of the Kurdish people is long gone.
“Gone Sykes-Picot, gone [Treaty of] Lausanne, gone Algiers Agreement, gone Iran-Iraq war, and Anfal and Arabization,” Bakhtiar said, listing a number of agreements and events that did not serve the rights of Kurds, including the right to their own state.

The Kurdistan Region is set to hold the referendum on independence on September 25, including in the disputed areas such as the oil-rich and multi-ethnic Kirkuk.
He slammed foreign countries, especially the international community, and reminded them of their absolute silence when the Iraqi regime committed genocide against the Kurds for decades.
Turkey and Iran have expressed their objection to the vote, and Baghdad calls it unconstitutional. The United States, among others, has said that now is not the right time.
“Unless the Halabja [chemical] attack, and unless Kuwait was invaded, the big countries did not utter a single word to defend us,” Bakhtiar said of the Kurdish city of Halabja that fell victim to the largest chemical attack ever carried out in the history against a civilian population in 1988, and the First Gulf War in 1991 when the United States defended tiny, oil-rich Kuwait.

“But twenty-four hours from our decision that we [said] will hold referendum, you all told us to stop,” he continued, describing the reaction to the announcement made by the Kurdish leadership in June.
He played down the regional objections to the referendum by Turkey and Iran, two neighbouring countries, each with significant Kurdish populations.
“Were they not against the federal [government]?” Bakhtiar reminded the people of the moment the Kurds declared the Kurdistan Region a federal region within Iraq without the consent of Baghdad.
He said each of these two countries, and others, soon decided to recognize the Kurdish region.
He said the reactions from the region and by the international community after the referendum will not be strong compared to when Erbil declares an independent state.
He also said that a blockade, such as the one imposed on the Kurdistan Region in the 1990s, is not likely, arguing that Turkey and Iran have billions of dollars of trade exchange with the Region, and therefore they are not ready to lose it all.
He said that trade between Erbil and Tehran is “even twice that of the Shiite Iran with the Shiite Iraq,” as he said the Kurdistan Region is a bigger and well-established market for  both Iran and Turkey.
Regarding the argument put forward by some countries, first and foremost by the Unites States, that the fight against ISIS should remain a priority, the official said this does not concern the Kurdistan Region.
“We have [already] accomplished our mission,” Bakhtiar said as he said the ISIS militants have been driven out of all areas considered Kurdistan.
He said what remains is the responsibility of the Iraqi and Syrian government, including Hawija where he said they are prepared to take part in the offensive to liberate the town that is located southwest of Kirkuk.
He added they are ready to contribute to the war against ISIS anywhere they are needed.


Data pager
Page size:
Muraz Adzhoev | 4/8/2017
Southern Kurdistan not being yet a sovereignty independent state can not be a part of a confederation with failed Iraqi federation. What he's talking about is a political and legal nonsense. More over only the People of reintegrated and sovereignty independent Southern Kurdistan has the supreme authority and right to decide and approve a confederation with reestablished new Iraq. Theoretically a referendum on confederative union with reestablished new Iraq could be held, but only after the Declaration of Independence of reintegrated Southern Kurdistan from the Iraqi federation and after its official recognition by the international community. Theoretically yes, but actually never, because it is absolutely impossible and absolutely unreasonable due to the very well known absence of all appropriate historical, political, ideological, ethnic and cultural preconditions for any federation and confederation with Iraq. What for the People of Southern Kurdistan should give some of its sovereignty to Baghdad. Would the Shiite and/or Sunni Arab elites of Iraq aqree to give some of their state sovereignty to Erbil, recognize Erbil as a capital city of a confederation with Southern Kurdistan? Never. Was Mala Bakhtiar authorized by the People, the President or by the Givernment of the Kurdistan Region to make this statement ?
kurdish | 4/8/2017
That is the real and the brave Mala Bakhtiar
Flaminco | 4/8/2017
In other words are the big powers willing to put in guarantees anr is Baghdad ready to accept a referendum in all so called "disputed territories" in a few months, pay what is owed to Kurdistan since 2003, compensate all Kurdish victims of the former regimes, give at least 20% of all military gear/arms and foreign aid to Kurdistan region, grant even more rights/sovereignty to Kurdistan region (like veto power, border revenue and air space sovereignty) AND of course allocate at least 20% of Iraqs annual budget to Kurdistan confederate state? Because that's the price we're talking about if they are really serious in keeping Kurdistan part of a confederate Iraq, a real partnership with no if's and but's. Let me answer all that: not in a MILLION years! So independence here we come!
bain | 4/8/2017
All rational good points no one can argue with, shirt version is they're telling us; "we agree that Iraq has been terrible for you kurds and we can't gurantee that it will get any better nor are we willing to pressure Baghdad on any of your grevenses, but please stay within Iraq! because it suits us better" And our reply is F U
Baran | 4/8/2017
The problem is Kurdistan have no allies and friends. Our enemies have real allies who support them with everything from weapons to soveranity without condition. Our fake friend the US is playing with Kurds, they say they support Kurds but oppose indipendence or autonomy for Kurds in other parts. They send weapons but light arms and not tanks or air defence like others get from them. To think US is our friend is one of the biggest obstacles for a strong Kurdistan.

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

STOP | 6/20/2018 7:06:22 AM
It is the US and Russian killing machines, operated by Turks and fully in agreement with Iraqi and Kurdish authorities. So what is the problem?...
Outsider | 6/20/2018 11:09:57 PM
Karayilan said that immediately after the Afrin operation...hence not now...but according to local reports...shortly after the Turks closed in on...
Turkish jets strike villages in Kurdistan’s Bradost region
| 19/6/2018 | (2)
pre-Boomer Marine brat | 6/20/2018 10:30:21 AM
Regarding the political realities inside Turkey, if it comes down to Erdogan's tush or America's, the TSK (as presently led) will enter Manbij, at...
Outsider | 6/20/2018 10:57:04 PM
He may forgot to add"....yet" ("The Turks will not enter Manbij, yet..")
US-led coalition: Turkish soldiers will not go into Manbij
| yesterday at 12:59 | (2)
Your hate for the Kurds will end you | 6/20/2018 6:21:49 PM
The Turkish hate for the Kurds will lead to the end of the Turkish state. The Kurdistani will make sure that happens!
Outsider | 6/20/2018 10:46:57 PM
Let's wait and see...
Turkish foreign minister promises to return Manbij to its owners
| yesterday at 03:14 | (5)
pre-Boomer Marine brat | 6/20/2018 8:45:28 PM
The problem is what's called "tribal" culture ... Do not think the West is beyond it. Parts of America's population are headed back into it -- no...
No rest for the Yezidi dead four years after genocide
| yesterday at 11:23 | (1)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

What about Mosul’s Jewish and Christian sites? 11 hours ago |

What about Mosul’s Jewish and Christian sites?

"The tower is in danger to fall more
Iran lists demands for improving relations with US 13 hours ago |

Iran lists demands for improving relations with US

It follows demands laid out in May by Secretary more
Jailed HDP candidate Demirtas to hold election ‘e-rally’ via social media 14 hours ago |

Jailed HDP candidate Demirtas to hold election ‘e-rally’ via social media

Demirtas faces up to 142 years in jail if found more
1.079 seconds