Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment


Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using





Talabani's memorial marked by loss of Kurdistan’s ‘Jerusalem’

By Rudaw 10/11/2017
SULAIMANI, Kurdistan Region – The Patriotic Union of Kurdistan (PUK) held a memorial in Sulaimani on Friday for the party’s late founder Jalal Talabani, who was also the first non-Arab president of Iraq. 
Kosrat Rasul, acting PUK head, said that Talabani’s death was a “great loss for the Kurds, Kurdistan and Iraq. We should all try to fill the void he left.”
The charismatic Kurdish leader died just a week after Kurdistan’s vote for independence. Friday’s memorial, marking the end of the traditional 40-day mourning period, was overshadowed by the fall of Kirkuk that has ended – for now – dreams of independence and caused renewed animosity between Kurds.
Talabani, known affectionately as Mam Jalal, died in Berlin on October 3. He was laid to rest on Sulaimani’s Dabashan hill on October 6.
Former Kurdistan Region Prime Minister Barham Salih, also a former PUK senior member, praised Talabani’s leadership as he attended the memorial.
He said Mam Jalal was a “teacher, leader, and uncle to me,” adding that he will never forget his great personality. 
He said Talabani will be remembered as a Peshmerga who fought against the Iraqi state in the Kurdish mountains and went on to become president of Iraq.
Many Kurds compare the fall of Kirkuk last month to a 1975 defeat of a Kurdish rebellion led by Mullah Mustafa Barzani by an alliance between Iraq and Iran, supported by the silence of the United States.
Salih pointed out that it was Talabani who was able to “resurrect” the Kurdish rebellion after the 1975 setback. He said this could be an example for the path ahead. 
“Our nation is brave and has morale. We can rise again,” Salih said. 
In a famous 1992 speech delivered after yet another a popular Kurdish uprising against the Iraqi regime, Talabani said that the oil-rich and multi-ethnic province of Kirkuk holds the key to solving the Kurdish issue in Iraq. 
He opened his speech mentioning a group of Kurds killed by the regime after the uprising. 
“The fascist dictators in Baghdad believe that with the execution of 288 brave sons of Kurds, they can extinguish the fire of the Baba Gurgur [oil well],” Talabani told a crowd of thousands gathered in Erbil. “But they are daydreaming. So long as there is still a Kurd living, Kirkuk remains a city of Kurdistan. I believe that Kurdistan will give up just about any place, but there is not a Kurd, not even one single noble Kurd, that will give up Kirkuk and Kirkuk area.”
“They key to the solution of the Kurdish cause is Kirkuk, Kirkuk alone, and Kirkuk itself,” Talabani said, adding that the southern border of Kurdistan extends to the Hamrin Mountains.
A former senior PUK member told Rudaw that Talabani galvanized Kurdish awareness for Kirkuk, a city he always called Kurdistan’s Jerusalem.
“When you talk about Mam Jalal and Kirkuk, the two are inseparable,” said Faraidun Abdulqadir. 
“Mam Jalal was the first Kurdish leader who taught us that ‘either we will get Kirkuk and Khanaqin, or we will fight to the very end,’” he continued. 


Some in the party Talabani founded, the first to advocate for the Kurdish right to self-determination, have been accused of treason for the loss of Kirkuk. His family denies the accusations.

Lahur Talabany, head of the PUK’s anti-terror agency, said on Friday that the loss of Kirkuk came as the result of a “mistake by the Kurdish leadership,” that includes all the parties. He added that the Kurds will one day return back to the oil-rich province despite the current setbacks. 
Asked about the fate of Kirkuk, the stronghold of the PUK, senior party member Mala Bakhtiyar said at the memorial that the military incursion by the Iraqi forces will ultimately fail.
“Every military success that comes as the result of a plot will lead to arrogance. This arrogance will not be translated into a political and administrative fact on the ground. The best thing is for all of us to go back to the table of negotiation and let the [Iraqi] constitution judge between us,” Bakhtiyar said. 
Regarding some calls to turn Kirkuk into an independent region, he said such a move should be opposed by all, down to “the last remaining Kurd.”
Addressing the issue of intra-Kurdish divisions in the wake of the Kirkuk crisis, Kosrat Rasul said it is time to “put the Kurdish house in order.”
His Peshmerga force suffered tens of casualties in Kirkuk and he has blamed elements within his own party.
The PUK’s leadership council has decided to dissolve the politburo office and instead elect an 11-member committee to be headed by Rasul to prepare the party to hold its congress in early next year and run party activities in the interim. This move is still to be finalized by the party.


Data pager
Page size:
Muraz Adzhoev | 10/11/2017
Disgusting hypocrisy.
United Peshmerga | 10/11/2017
The iranian backed arabs entered Kerkuk through the hole left on the wall of Kerkuk by some traitors among the children of Talabani and others. Nevertheless ,there are noble Kurds within the PUK like Kosrat Rasul who must use their authority to strengthen the morale and begin working within the KRG to build up a modern Kurdish army without partisan afiliation and strictly under one command . The recent defeat has proven that peshmerga should be united and apolitical , a professional army not tied to any polical party whatsoever. Peshmerga must belong to the Kurdish nation and it should not be the property of any political party. The recent bitter defeat confirms what I say. Long live united peshmerga.
rastgo | 10/11/2017
It is obvious to me that the YNK and its leadership are unable to examine the loss of Kerkûk. No party in the world can bluntly acknowledge their mistakes, certainly not directly after the loss of Kerkûk. It is even suspicious if the YNK investigates this case internally. The loss of Kerkûk is the result of betrayal by some of the leading members of the Celal Talabani family itself. As this family leads the YNK and considers large parts of Kurdistan as their own property, a ruthless clarification of the Kerkûk case can only be seen as a farce. Sad enough.
guest2002 | 10/11/2017
well he can blame his own children for that!!!
Treason | 11/11/2017
The family of Talabani and associates have commited treason and inflicted on Kurdistan the loss of Kerkuk, they are responsible of the death of hundresmds of peshmerga , and they have invited the iranian-arab invasion .They are powerful PUK lords, they are ruthless traitors.

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

Basem | 9/26/2018 10:00:28 AM
No doubt Fuad Hussien would make a good president, but so would Barham Saleh. This poltical bickering is childish and distructive, it will cost Kurds...
Pliny The Kurd | 9/26/2018 10:38:22 AM
Let's heed the wise advises of Galbraith :Dr Fuad Hoseen is the best choice.Let's unite behid him for the best. May I make a question to Mr...
Galbraith: Fuad Hussein has the interests of his people at heart
| 7 hours ago | (3)
Qader | 9/26/2018 8:34:00 AM
The countries you mentioned rank the lowest when it comes to stability, human rights, freedom of speech, political rights, health etc. Look how the...
kurdish natinalist | 9/26/2018 9:47:17 AM
too this clown terorist Iranier bark not much like dogs you will bark you can bark with your clown familj and all know iran are terorrist country...
Pompeo: US seeking 'Iraqi national government' to counter Iran's influence
| yesterday at 08:59 | (7)
kurdish natinalist | 9/26/2018 9:37:48 AM
Nazi and fascist country what complication
Erdogan, Merkel to meet amid tensions, protests
| 10 hours ago | (1)
dilan | 9/23/2018 11:19:30 PM
Thanks Mr Kent but the so called "iranians" or "persians" i.e. turk sikh kashmiri mullah rulers of iran, were the major factor behind the invasion...
Halli | 9/26/2018 9:14:42 AM
Brits, including the writer do not recognize the Oil factor in Kirkuk for Britan, policy was formed and twisted based on the fact BP will have the...
A letter to Kurdistani patriots a year after the referendum
| 23/9/2018 | (4)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

Maliki: Kurds should field just one candidate for Iraq presidency 2 hours ago |

Maliki: Kurds should field just one candidate for Iraq presidency

"We also have our own views on who best serves more
Foreign consulates to monitor fairness of KRG election: commission 3 hours ago |

Foreign consulates to monitor fairness of KRG election: commission

Consulates of the US, Canada, UK, Japan, France, more
Erdogan: Fate of detained US pastor will be decided by courts 6 hours ago |

Erdogan: Fate of detained US pastor will be decided by courts

"As the president, I don’t have the right to more
1.187 seconds