Sign In / Up

Add contribution as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment

Comment as a guest

Your email will not be displayed publicly
Benefit of signing in/signing up to personalize comment


Not a member Register   Forgot Password
or connect using





Barzani: No alternative has been offered that can replace referendum

By Rudaw 15/9/2017
President Masoud Barzani attends a rally in support of the Kurdish independence referendum on September 15, 2017, a day after the US, UN and the UK presented an alternative to the vote. Photo: Rudaw video
President Masoud Barzani attends a rally in support of the Kurdish independence referendum on September 15, 2017, a day after the US, UN and the UK presented an alternative to the vote. Photo: Rudaw video

AMEDI, Kurdistan Region – No alternative that can replace the independence referendum has been offered, Kurdistan President Masoud Barzani said one day after the US, UN, and UK presented what they called an “alternative” in an effort to convince Erbil to postpone the vote.

“To this date, we have not received an alternative that can take the place of the referendum,” Barzani told a pro-referendum rally in Amedi, Friday evening.
He also slammed those claiming the referendum does not have legitimacy.
“The referendum’s legitimacy comes from the people of Kurdistan, not from the outside,” Barzani said to the cheering crowd, waving Kurdistan flags.

Brett McGurk, the US Presidential Envoy to the anti-ISIS Global Coalition, said on Thursday that the referendum does have “international legitimacy” and the US holds the same view as the Global Coalition that considers the vote “ill-advised” and “ill-timed.”

The US Envoy said at a press conference in Erbil that their alternative is one that will be acceptable to all sides, without getting into details.

Barzani met the visiting delegation on Thursday at a coordination center for the war against ISIS. 

The Kurdistan president said at the rally it was a disappointment the Global Coalition did not take into consideration the Peshmerga’s contribution to the war. 

“We thought that in reward to the people of Kurdistan – as a result of the blood of all these martyrs and the Peshmerga breaking the myth of ISIS – they will say that you the people of Kurdistan, it is your right. Since they do not take that into consideration, we do not take theirs either, not even a bit,” Barzani said.

The Peshmerga have lost about 2,000 soldiers and another about 10,000 have been injured since the war against ISIS began in 2014. 

Barzani told the crowd that while there are risks associated with the vote, “the risk of waiting... is far more dangerous.” 

It is an issue of will, he said. “When your will is strong, then the achievements are in reach.”

He said that the Kurdish people have paid the price for independence in blood “ten times more” than is necessary, explaining that the referendum in itself has never been an objective of the Kurdish leadership.

“The referendum is a tool to achieve independence. Referendum is not the objective. Independence is our objective,” Barzani said in clear terms before addressing those who have demanded the vote be delayed. “Come forward, bring us an alternative in place of the referendum. Then the referendum is not needed at all.”

He also slammed recent votes of the Iraqi parliament rejecting the referendum and removing Kirkuk Governor Najmaldin Karim. The Iraqi parliament is giving room to “chauvinists,” he said, who do not agree with true partnership and consensus, the foundations of the new Iraq after the US-led invasion in 2003. 

He said the Iraqi parliament has violated the same constitution that Kurds worked hard to receive national approval after the invasion.

He explained that he lost members of his bodyguards while in Baghdad to draft the Iraqi constitution in 2005, when his place of residence was attacked by rockets 36 times. Despite this, he and other Kurdish officials stayed in the Iraqi capital to complete the constitution. 

Barzani then said in a defiant message that the people of Kurdistan do not take orders from such a parliament that has sidelined the Kurdish minority. 

“We also tell them that your decision will not reach Kurdistan. So don't even bother,” Barzani said to the Iraqi parliament.

The Iraqi government is opposed to the Kurdistan referendum and the parliament gave Prime Minister Haider al-Abadi directions to take “all measures” to cancel the vote that is to take place 10 days from now.

Last updated at 6:43 pm


Data pager
Page size:
FAUthman | 15/9/2017
All there was in the alternative was probably "keep talking to Bafgdhdad" Of course that was expected to be turned down. We will have the referendum on the 25th and that is the right course of action! and most likely there will be no violence resulting from the referendum and may not be any even after!
K-Man | 15/9/2017
Kurdish leaders and people, stay strong! Don't let any offers be the alternative for the referendum. Don't let the blood of the fallen kurdish heroes in fighting for a independence Kurdistan being for nothing.
Ferhad | 15/9/2017
Bravo Mr Barzani! I am not a supporter of the PDK but be sure all Kurds are behind the Referendum! When it's a national matter all Kurds from all parts of Kurdistan stand together. We are all with you against everyone who stands against the Referendum or threatens our Kurdistan! Bijî yekîtîya Kurdistanê, Belê bo Referandûmê!
FAUthman | 15/9/2017
Barzani is absolutely right to turn down an empty proposal and Kurds are very fortunate to have that kind of a resolute leader with a backbone! If you do not draw the line here and now you are doomed to a life of slavery for another century if not more! It is that simple and it is your choice. The good neighbors proposal with Baghdad with dual citizenship for both is the best answer, wait and see how Iraq (everywhere) will really take off if the "good neighbors" proposal is adopted with treaties on water, oil, airspace, border security etc.
Pliny The Kurd | 15/9/2017
When Barzani speaks it is the Kurdish nation who speaks.

Be Part of Your Rudaw!

Share your stories, photos and videos with Rudaw, and quite possibly the world.

What You Say

Zagros | 7/20/2018 5:27:06 AM
Pete, if you had traveled the world as you claim then you'd have known that Rojava is not the most egalitarian system in the world. You'd have known...
Outsider | 7/21/2018 4:36:24 AM
The PKK/KCK/PYD/YPG reminds me on the political system in the "good old" Communist countries... yes you have a choice.. hence claiming demo...
Assad or Turkey? Uncertainty surrounds future of Qamishli
| 17/7/2018 | (13)
Shaxawan | 7/18/2018 7:35:12 AM
All what US gave us is some scraps whike they support Irani militias and Sunna Arabs with the most developed weapons. Shame on you US, still seeks...
Robert Patrick Shuttlesworth | 7/21/2018 3:33:58 AM
My fellow Americans, why are we allowing our leaders to ask permission to form Kurdish security forces, from some of the very people the Kurds have...
US to arm two more Peshmerga brigades – if Baghdad permits it
| 16/7/2018 | (4)
Mohamedzzz | 7/19/2018 5:39:19 PM
''A deal was reached Tuesday between regime-backer Russia and rebel-ally Turkey''... I always said Turkey 'IS' the problem, Problems cannot be solved...
kurd | 7/21/2018 2:21:45 AM
Mohammaedzzz@ you have always been wrong. the main problem for kurds is PKK+YPG. they are cancerous cell on body of kurdistan. they are in service...
Thousands evacuate pro-regime Syria towns
| 19/7/2018 | (3)
Dlawar | 7/20/2018 10:33:10 PM
The regime is often described is smart or shrwed but they're not, even dumber are the nationalists who are against the regime but happily applaud...
Family says execution of Kurdish prisoner in Iran is imminent
| yesterday at 10:57 | (1)

Elsewhere on Rudaw

Parties eager for skilled politicians in next Kurdistan parliament 4 hours ago |

Parties eager for skilled politicians in next Kurdistan parliament

"If we want to have a strong government, our MPs more
Stacks of cash change hands at Erbil’s currency exchange market 7 hours ago |

Stacks of cash change hands at Erbil’s currency exchange market

Security is surprisingly lax more
Alcohol sales, consumption banned in Saladin province 8 hours ago |

Alcohol sales, consumption banned in Saladin province

Residents have compared the ban to the strict more
0.172 seconds